To the Editor of the Si,—In the North-China Herald of 7th March 1872, I observe that Mr. C. Hannen—a man for whom I have much t, both as an English gentleman as Commissioner of Customs—had addressed you a letter dated %h February 1872, animadverting on the tenor of my communication of 9th December 1871, published in the North-China Herald of 11th January 1872, being my observations on the disireas of the people of this province caused by the flood, When, im the document in question, I wrote respecting the great misery sutlered by the population of the inundated tract of country; and when I deemed it proper, in support of my views, to call inthe aid of the of the Commissioner of Customs, and quoted his own words, neither more nor less, being these: Altogether the extent of flooded eountsy in Chibli may be estimated at about 1,000 lo from north to south and 600 lo from east to west"; and after this taking the data as to population of the province of Chibli from Dr. Williams work The Middle Kingdom," to shew the possible number of the population living within the extent of country given by the Keport of the Commissioner of Customs; [did not attempt to animadvert, nor did I even for an instant think of doing s0, on the statements made by the Commissioner of Customs. I left his words to speak for themselves. I merely called in his statemenia in support of my subject, to shew the existing distress in a large extent of this region. The language which I use is such xs the Almighty has been pleased to endow me with; and the Inn-gage which T eupleyed on the vecasio in question was suely as the gravity of the subject demanded, in which was discussed the fate of the living or dying of thousands of human being Lam extremely sorry to observe from the tone of the tenor of Mr. Hannen's letter, that his feelings are hurt by my having quoted from his report. _Is it reasonable, however, on his part, I will dare now to ask him, that he, after having published his report, after having read my paper quot: ing from it, and after having discovered shat his data of the extent of flooded country~ 1,000 1ix 600 li exceeds the whole of the extent of the province of Chibi, which is only 58,949 smiles English (sce Chinese typography of the provinces, dep and districts inthe Chinese empire, with their latitudes and longitudes,) while he makes the extent of the flooded country alone in the province of Chihli 60,000 square miles English—should become angry with me, and speak of one as if I was his enemy? 1 beg him to observe that, throughout nly observations on his report, L had the generosity to carefully avoid noticing his error, and only generally alluded to his Gata of th Of country suffering obviously in his mind Inrge, which was alone what I wished to show to the public to support my views of great destitution existing throughout a large tract of Chibli province. Mr. Hannen may be assured that 1 respect him tov highly to even think of censuring his acts or written
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.