The Archive · 1871

Tite Tientsin Massacre

Mu. Wane to tHe Eaxt oF CLaREND6s.

Pexmxo, July 3, 1870.

My Lord,—By the Russian mail of the agth June Iliad the honour to forward your Lordship a report of the attack upon the French Settlement at Tientsin, and the fearful massacre of the Consul and other French subjects.

Thave delayed writing up.to the last moment in hopes that I might vetuiee to supply something like a connected his of cits Yorrible outbreak 5 but this is not yet in my power. I have arranged the despatches and memoranda enclosed in something like chronological order, and I have added an'analytical table of their contents, which may be of some assistance in the study of this mass of documents.

The most important of these, in my opinion, is the. letter of the French Consul, the unfortunate M. Fontanier, dispatched from Tientsin at 10 o'clock on the morning of the 2ist June, little more than an hour before his death. Itshows that for some days previously there had_ been mobs surrounding the Hospital of the Sisters of Merey, and clamouring against them; the ory being that they were receivers of stolen children, of whose: hearts and eyes they made unholy use.

On the 20th, Mr. Lay his sur-

not astonishing that he had heard nothing of the steps taken by M. Fontanier, for the latter had not even mentioned what was doing to his Minister. M. de Rochechouart frst heard of the misunderstanding this question of the children had occasioned by the letter dated and dispatched on the day his Consul was killed; yet the public had certainly been murmuring for upwards of a month. So far back as the 5th June, a missionary absent in Peking was written to to return to Tientsin, because there was apparently trouble brewing.

feel bound to combat. the impression, which is that of many foreigners, that this discontent was sheerly the work of the authorities or of the influential classes. The Chinese, as their law-books show, do believe that by spells and drugs kidnappers can bewitch whom they will (vide Inclosure 33). In their Materia Medica various parts of the human frame are employed for purposes unknown to Western science (vide Inclosure 34). The educated classes are, in all that belongs to physiological knowledge, as ignorant and superstitious as the common Mentsin authorities did believe, as. the ple. I think it is asslikely as not that the

Prgele believed, that children were being kidnapped, and that for the purposes alleged; nor would this conclusion be shaken if it were shown that, as some declare, they took pains to extort & confession from those who have been brought before them as guilty of Kidoapping, It is the habit of it Courts, in half the serious cases they try, to strain the evidence to secure a convietion.

Tam not going to contend that they were not anti-foreign,—it would be difficult to understand how any mandarin can be any~ thing else; and I shall not deny that had they chosen to soothe the people the people might have been soothed, though this is by no means absolutely certain. But it does appear that the only means to this end was neglected, and that the one chance of averting the storm was thrown away in the interview in which M. Fontanier reports the authorities who were demanding an inspection of the hospital to have forgotten themselves so far as to menace him with the wrath of the people.

Ch'ung Hou is a Manchu, high in office, but without magisterial functions. Durin, the ten years that he has filled the post of Minister Superintendent (we might call him Consul-General) ofthe northern ports, he official with whom he has had to deal. But as gained the good opinion of every forei

the good understanding he has contrived to maintain with them would but add to his powerlessness in a crisis like that just past. He must have known! what was ahead of him at least some days before the storm broke, and he is certainly chargeable with having done nothing to put foreigners on their guard. He seems to have regarded the.affair as exclusively French, or more properly Romish, and he may have hoped that the arrangement to by M. Fontanier on the 20th would have enabled him to calm the public mind. Had he thought otherwise, however, I doubt that he would have ventured to give the alarm, The blow struck, he tells a story which must be received with very great caus tion, to wit, that M. Fontanier came armed to his yamen, abused him, fired a pistol, if not at him, in his presence; similarly assaulted the Magistrate, and was consequently killed by the people.

Mr. Lay proves that in one important particular he has contradicted himself. On the 22nd he affirmed that M. Fontanier had been killed close to him, and that he had his remains in his yamen. On the 23rd MIN. Fontanier's body was recovered by Mr. Lay from the river.

the other part there is almost complete unanimity in the reports that MI Fon-tanier was seen armed_towards Ch'ung Hov's yamen, and that either he or his companion did fire at, or threaten, the Magistrate with some weapon. And if this took place in Gl'ung Hou's yamen, his followers, to say nothing of the nob, would infallibly have out down the unhappy Consul. The riot once begun, no official would for the time have been able to stay it. The most active of the rioters would of course be those who had something to gain by it, and I think with Mr. Lay that the attitude of the community and the badness of the weather had much to say in the immunity of the British settlement from molestation.

On receipt of the news of this tragedy at Peking it was agreed that the Representatives of the Treaty Powers in residence should sign a collective note to the Prince of Kung. inclose a copy of this with the reply to it. His Highness is still confined to his room, but the conferences between the Ministers of the Yamen and the Diplomatic Corps have been frequent. These have led to one or two results worth notice.

Upon the 28th, a Decree* was published apparently to meet the wishes expressed in the collective note. It is but a lukewarm production. It condemns, indeed, the law-ess proceedings of the Tien-tsin ese, but it scarcely insists with the peremptoriness the occasion demands upon the duty of the Government, under Treaty, both towards foreigners and towards Christians. Upon the 29th a second Decree, t not published in the Gazette, but communicated to foreign Ministers, announced the appointment of Ch'ung Hou as High Commissioner to France; an arrangement understood to be specially acceptable to the French Legation. Iv is believed that he will have a colleague, but the Minister is not yet named. He will be most likely a Chinese.

The Tien-tsin outrage has, of course, been well ventilated amongst the Pekinese, but no foreigner has been in any way molested, nor have I heard any one remar! upon the slightest change up here in the demeanour of the population.

Lhave, &e.

(Signed) Tuomas Fraxors Wane.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account