The Archive · 1871

In Admiralty

Before C. W. Goopwry, Esq., Acting Chief Judge, Commander Risixc H. M.S.

Midge, and Captain Ginsox Weymouth, present by invitation Assessors.

Ko-witer and others, Owners of the junk Sing-yung-tah, v. the Master and Owners of the S. S. Norna.

Cause of damages—sum Tls. 12,000.

Counsel for Plaintifis, Mr. A. Robinson. Goutal for Dafendants, Me. RW.

Mr. Ronmsoy first desired to remedy an inaccuracy in the petition, which had occurred through his own fault, The petition sot forth in paragraphs 1 and 5 that there had been 12 hands altogether and 11 passengers, but there had been also a super-carya, and consequently a total of 24 in the junk, which accounted for one man Growned. Paragraph Sth stated that 23 persons were on board the junk, and that the Norna took off 22. These figures should have been 24 and 23.

Mr. Binp objected to such an amendment, because as it was he would be able to show that the petition stated one thing while the evidence proved another, whic would go to, shake the testimony for the alleged statement that a man was drowned. ~If"the'petition stated that 23 men were on deard the junk, and it was proved that 23 men were taken on board the steamer, it would be very material for his case that this should appear on the record.

"After some discussion, His Lonosiur agreed to rake a note of Mr. Robinson's statement, that this misstatement occurred through his individual error.

Mr. Rovixsox then proceeded to open his case. He did not think it would be necessary to read the pleadings. It would save time if he described, as shortly as he could, the nature of the suit and the voyage it arose in. The suit was one by the owners of a large Chinese junk, to recover damages from the steamer Norna which ran into her on the morning of the 15th May, 1871, and sunk her, with her cargo..'The junk was a large one, of about 3,000 piculs burden, and loaded with a cargo of oil, pease in'bulk, and packages of vermicelli, in short a general Chinese cargo. Shewas coming from Kaotchew, on the eastern coast of Shantung, and was bound to Foochow. Her crew consisted of 12 men and a supercargo, and 11 persons whom the Chinamen called passengers, but it seemed to be the custom in China that poor persons should work their passage, so that the junk had abundance of hands. The junk started from Kaotchew on the 8th of fay, and everything proceeded well until the night of the 14th or morning of the 15th. "At that time she got to a place in the caster. archipelago, about 12 or 14 miles to the southward of Video. The wind was from the south-west. It was difficult, it must be remembered, in dealing with Chinese witnesses to be as accurate in these particulars as with other witnesses. The defendants stated that the wind was southerly, but if so, the junk could not have deen going the course she was sailing. The to plointiffy" statement, was clears it had tide was very slack. The night, accord

en dark about two or three hours previously, but at the time of the collision was clear, and the stars visible. The defendants stated in their answer that the night was dark and cloudy, and the atmosphere hazy. The junk carried a light, and as this was one of the great facts of his case, he had procured an exact facsimile of the lantern carried by her, which was hoisted to the mast by a small boom run up by halyards, That this was hoisted conformed With the statement of defendants themselves, who stated that, shortly before the collision, they did see a light run up. Now when the Norna was first seen by the junk, she was about three miles off, bearing in a northerly direction. The only light they could perceive at the time was a white one, and, being a good way off, they had no power to alarm her., As the Norna neared them, a green light came into use, and the master of the junk, an old and experienced man, apprehending danger from. the.moment he saw it, caused paper to be burnt, in Chinese fashion, fore and aft on the port side, the side the steamer was op) and' as the steamer came nearer, the crew of the junk shouted, in Chinese of course, telling her to pass astern. The allegation of the natives is, that no notice was taken of this, and that the people must have been asleep, or at any rate not looking out. He would ask the Court to bear in mind that the steamer had overtaken the junk. That was an important matter in connection with what his clients did when the collision threatened. If the Court would turn to the answer of the defendants, it would find out what they were doing at the same time. After having mentioned the state of the weather at 1.40 a.at. of the 15th, the third paragraph of the answer said: "That shortly afterwards, the night being dark, the said David Burgess believed he saw something indistinct ahead; at the sh same time the look-out man in the bows struck once on a gong, (which was kept in the bows for the purpose of signalling,) to signify that there was something on the starboard bow. The said David Bx immediately ordered the engines to slow and blew the whistle, and ordered the helm to be put to port, "hard-a-port," which orders were promptly obeyed. 'The whistle was blown a second time, when a small light was seen to be hoisted, and the object was discovered to be a three-masted junk standing right across the bows of the' said steamship and steering a south-easterly course." If there was time to do all the things described here, one of two consejnences followed; either there was abundant time to avoid the collision, or, if these things were done immediately before it, that the answer did not candidly convey the impression that they were done one after the other and. that there was. time for the junk to do anything. Everything was simply done for mere excuse afterwards. No. 17 of the Regulations for preventing collisions at sea stated distinctly that any vessel ov dertaking any other vessel shall keep out of the.way of such Inst mentioned vessel. The learned Counsel took it to be plain, and in accordance with common sense, that if a vessel finds another in the way it is her duty to wait on her. These appeared to him to be the main facts, upon which the whole case would tum," What occurred after the collision was not very material, but he believed even there the evidence would not quite agree with what the defendants said they did, Substantially, however, the crew were received on board the steamer and puton board a junk belonging to the same owners which they fortunately met, and which took them to Foochow. The men got, from the Norna, different sums—810, $5, and the larger portion$2each—tofind theminfood onthe junk. 'The Court had now all the facts as far as he was acquainted with them, With regard to the lay, he would only make a few preliminary observations. 'There were obviously several alternatives; the first was that the Norma was solely' to blame, that was his contention, but in order to' support ithe would not adduce any argu. ments at that time, because the whole of the evidence he would bring would go to show that it was the only alternative. The second alternative was that the junk was solely to blame, which under the citcumstances stated in the pleadings was simply impossible. A vessel bearing down is bound to go out of the way, especial if the hinder vessel iso steamer and the other a junk, The third altenative was that both were to blame, on which he would address some observa-ons to the Court later on, but the consequence of both being to blame would be that the loss would be borne equally between both vessels. For that dictum he adduced the case of the WoodruffSims, 2 Dodson, 85, and the Swarland 2 Spinks 113.

Mr. Brep did not contest the principle Mr. Routssox proceeded—The fourth alternative was that the collision was the result of inevitable accident, and in such case the suit would be dismissed without costs to either party. The authority on that point was the Itinerant in 2 William Robinson, 244.

Mr. Bmp did not contest this principle either.

Mr. Rozissox, for the definition of inevitable accident" referred the Court tothe ease of the Loch Lido 8 William Robinson, 318, the moral of which was that if any blame' attached to either of the vessels the collision was not one by inevit table accident. As to the degree of vigil lance which would justify the finding of inevitable accident, he referred to the Bfillona case, 3 William Robinson, 13, where the captain had gone down to consult the chart and did not place an officer on the lookout, and where it was held that this was blameable even though the night was so dark that a man on the lookout could not have been of any use. The principle was that it mattered not what the effect of the vigilance may be—in order to justify the finding that a collision was an inevitable accident, the greatest amount of

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account