The Archive · 1872

The Soochow Creek Bridge Company

the Editor of the Dean Stz,—The more one studies the letter of the Agents of the above Company, which was given in your issue of the 14th inst., the more difficult is it to understand how they can for a moment suppose its production will in any way benefit their position. It is nothing less than an insult to the common sense of the community to again bring up the worn-out arguments of the past six years, which have been constantly refuted, and which the discussions on the 6th May and 12th Aug. wereeupponed to have consigned tooblivion.

On the 12th August, more especially, the Proprietors of the Bridge were finally brought to bay, and the Agents for the first time gave definite information as to the tenure by which they claimed to hold their rights, at the same time admitting they were not aware that the Taoutai has the power to grant the monopoly which they alleged they possessed. At that meeting it was generally understood that the Council were to act without reference to these alleged Bridge Rights, and it consequently follows that, to sui the Agent's lotter which I' now criticise was written by any one conversant with the results of that meeting, is to credit the Proprietors with more effrontery than even they can be guilty of. The letter reminds one of those abortive efforts we sometimes see to create amusement on the stage, where one person speaks or sings from behind the scenes while another moves lips in view of the audience. The two never keep time at the best, and the song is sometimes prolonged with sad effect after the dummy has ceased his pantomime. In short, the only explanation or excuse for the letter is, that it was written far from Shanghai, and without any knowledge of the meeting of Ratepayers of the 12th ult, At the same time, the local proprietors might have used their discretion in Keeping the anachronism out of print. It was not necessary for the Bridge Company to publish its own epitaph, to sing its own dirge, and to appear before the publican the character of the dying swan because some distant shareholder, full of subtlety, desired to give vent to his fine sophistries in defence of a lost cause. The whole question, as between the Bridge Company and the Public, lies in a nutshell, and need be dificult of solution, Either the Bridge Company have-a monopoly, by virtue oft tai's grant, or they have not. Ihol not, nor can they have, for the has no control over the roads of diction, would be at once to place the whole foreshore of the Bund'at his di then even the upper ten" (i. e. the Bund Jot-owners) would come forth manfully, and dispute such a theory.

ing on the that any grant possessed by the Bridge Company is: invalid, Lam of opinion that their bridges should be taken over at their actual value, and would suggest that particular care taken, in reference to the Iron one, as without it the purchase may prove anything but a good one. Any maudlin sympathy for supposed rights is out of place, for the Company have been for years reaping profits from a monopoly to which they were not legally entitled.

remain, yours truly, Shanghai, 24th September, 1872.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account