The Archive · 1872

The Quarterly Review on China

Very curious is the picture of China, painted in no doubtful shades, in the April number of the Quarterly Review. Curious not only in its delineation of the state of the Empire, but also in its entire unlikeness to the ordinary China of the reviewer. The Quarterly is, however, a journal of so high standing and so old establishment, that we cannot believe that it would lend itself to the publication of statements of so extraordinary a nature, and con-traveling so completely the established theories regilding the people and government of China, without sufficient authority; and it behoves us therefore, before discussing those statements, to enquire what grounds the reviewer possessed for his assertions. We all of us know the traditional sources of information on Chinese matters; the stories of the early Jesuits, the travels of Marco Polo, the cling pages of theAbbé Hue. From these, and from the partial observations of the embassies of Lords Amherst and Macartney, and of such writers as that of the Fangui in China, et hoc genus one, the popular accounts of China have been drawn up. Later still, these accounts have been re-gilded by the flowing rhetoric of the Burlingame mission, so that petticoats. and pigtails have @ sort of charmed existence in the eyes of the ordinary British public. 'A nation of four hundred millions of souls, embracing one-third of the human race, and living in happiness and contentment under a patriarchal government is the traditional idea still current even -in educated circles in England; an idea however rudely cast aside by the reviewer, who produces a mass of authorities, more recent and more capable of forming a practical judgment. The Rev. A. Williamson, the Baron von Richthofen, the late Mr. Markham, the Chamber of Commerce delegates, not to speak of blue books and pamphlets of undoubted authority, are the sources whence the writer derives his outlines and colours. In fact the painstaking fidelity with which the writer has adhered to his sources of information is worthy of all credit and commendation. We have no fanciful picture filled in from a rough outline, but on the contrary every assertion supported by the most respectable authority. Little less remarkable than the tenor of the of the writers quoted. That witnesses such as we have quoted, official," corn. mercial and professional, should display this unanimityis indeed an circumstance, which cannot be lightly set aside- in the consideration of. our' future relations with the Empire; andre therefore hail the appearance in the pages of the Quarterly of an article so strange in its revelations, and yet so guarded in its manner of setting them out. Prior to its decease, our. former contemporary the Cycle lamented. the want of influence of the press in China; we fear, however, that the logic of hard facts had more to do with our contemporary's disappearance, Even in his own pages, facts which seemed difficult to reconcile with the known opinion of the journal would continu. ally crop out, and herein, we opine, lay the gist of his complaint. The press in China, we have reason to believe, does possess influence, though probably not the influence desired by the Cycle. Tt is influential in drawing public attention to facts, and in recording those facts for reference, and it is only in so far as its opinions tally with those facts that it can hope to influence public opinion. Were it not for the awakening of public opinion to affairs in China, to which the efforts of the China press have largely tended, it would have been difficult for the reviewer to obtain knowledge of the facts on which his article is based; so that a statement which will, more or less, influence our future relations with China, must have remained unwritten, or have been written with insufficient information. then to the Review,. we: find the writer at once giving.up the traditional four hundred. millions of the Flowery Land; the China of the willow pattern gives way to the China of practical men, - and we are introduced to a country of. some two hundred million inhabitants, having commercial relations more or. less intimate' with the reest. of the world. Respecting it the Reviewer learns—I—That a considerable amount of agricultural wealth, and an inexhaustible store of mineral weath are not utilised in China.

IL—That, with the exception of those districts which are "embraced in the canal systems of China, the existing means of communication are of the most defective kind.

TIL—That there is still a large available opening for the extension of British trade in manufactured' goods IV.—That the people are, as rule, well disposed, and anxious to cultivate commercial relations with Europeans.

To the ordinary Englishman, the statement that a large amount of cultural wealth is'wasted in China, wil seem at first sight almost incredible. Chinese industry and 'Chinese agviculture have ever been' proverbial in Europe. The authorities produced by the writer are however beyond que

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account