The Archive · 1870

Oficial Documents

THE TIEN?SIN MASSACRE

The following correspondence has passed between H. B. M. Consul and Messrs.

Lees and Hall, regarding the damage done to Protestant Mission property, during the recent outbreak.

H. B. M. Coxsvtare, Tientsin, 20th July, 1870.

Sm,—I have been requested by H. B.

amount of damage sustained by British Changs Affaires, to ascertain, the subjects during the ate unfortunate trow-les.

As I am aware that "many of your Chapels, were destroyed, and much valuable property lost; I have to request you, if see fit, to have estimates made of the ses and send them to me, in order that they may be forwarded to the Chinese Au-*thorities.

Your obedient Servant, W. HI Lay, Acting Consul.

$m,—We have the honour to. acknowledge the receipt of your official letter to. us, dated the 20th instant, touching the losses sustained by Blissions we represent, during the recent outrages.

We cannot but express our surprise, not only that at this early stage we should be required to state the amount of those losses, but that, prior to the settlement of the more important questions which are still pending, the subject of monetary compensation should be entertained at all.

Apart altogether from the fact that we are yet uncertain as-to the action which willie taken at the present crisis,—almost certainly by the French, and possibly even by our own Government,—action which it might be as useless as it. would be impolitic for us to forestall, by consenting to any unsatisfactory condonation of the crimes which have been committed; it can hardly be necessary to remind you that, until peace has been definitively secured, there are various items of loss for which we should feel it to be our duty to claim compensation, the limits of which can hardly yet have been reached. Such is the utter disorganization of this city and neighbourhood that all mission work must, in all likelihood, be suspended for months to come. Our respective staffs are thus thrown upon our hands. Our country converts, oth in this province and in Shantung, are everywhere expecting new outbreaks, in their various districts. Native Christians in the city continue to be daily exposed to spoliation and personal injury, while there is every reason to fear that our own appearance in the streets would still be fraught with danger.

With respect to our chapels, we fear that, however willing we might be to meet the Wwishes.of His Excellency, it is not Possible, for us.to do so. Our converts dare linger in the neighbourhood of the ruins; what hope can there be, then, that we can visit them in safety, or procure builders' estimates as to the cost of re-erection, not to speak of any actual attempt restoration? Our deliberate conviction is, that such an attempt would only end in their renewed destruction, even if workmen could be found brave enough' to undertake the task.

Will you forgive our expressing an. anxious desire, not to be separated from our suffering "French brethren, in - any settlement of these unhappy troubles? This is not a mere question of sentiment. We cannot but feel that the interests of our country are involved in what has occurred: We are British subjects, resident here under the protection of treaties, and engaged i, the prudent prosecution of our lawful calling. Our lives have been sought, our property has been destroyed, our converts grievously injured, and our characters assailed.\ "Moreover, there seems good reason to' believe, that at least one of the murdered Sisters was a British subject. There cannot be the slightest doubt upon the mind of anyone who has been brought much into converse with the people, during the last few weeks, that the original design was to treat all nationalities-alike. It is easy to understand why the -mandarins are now anxious to produce a different impression. But just as the excuses. which unhappily served them so well, in regard to the outrages at Formosa, Yangchow, and elsewhere, fail them now, so should the evident falsity of their present professions, of special friendship with ourselves, fail to separate us from those allies with whose interests our own so evidently are bound up.

We beg you will not mistake us. We are not crying for war and vengeance, but' we do claim justice, and we hold most firmly to the belief, that the path of safety and of honour, no less for individual Englishmen, than for our Government, is to stand cly our fellow-sufferers in the hour of trial.

fay, more, we believe this, for obvious reasons, to he the most merciful line_of action in reference to the Chinese them-solve We searcely know, whether we ought to apologise for venturing to express such views, for we hope that they find an echo in your own and every other heart. We have only, therefore, respectfully to assure you that' we shall strive to meet, as soon as possible, the wishes of H. B. MI. Charge WAffaires, and_ to request you to represent to him our difficulties in the matter.

We are, Sir, Your most obdt, Servants,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account