The Archive · 1870

Before G. Jaussox, Esq

Sitting for Assistant Judge

Rrvsoups v. Moxey.

Claim of $195, money advanced.

The.plaintiff claimed the shove sum, as an advance or loan, made to the defendant 2s a personal accommodation, ud appearing in the transactions between the parties only in that light, Petition was filed in June 1898, The defendant admitted having received the amount, but claimed a set-off of an equal amount fora boat supplied to the Cheat," the cost of which he ha allowed to lapse, recollecting that the sum now sued for had, like it, been-Overlooked at the time accounts concerning the "Chusan" were squared between them.

Mr. Rerxoups, sworn, states—In Nov. 1565, Capt. Mooney was" in command of the Chu: sau" steamer, and I permitted him to draw on me the amount of this order, which was all paid. (Handed in a memo. in Capt. Mooney's handwriting, of all the expenses at Foochow.) I have repeatedly applied to Capt. Mooney for this amount, for which, in squaring accounts, he omitted to give credit; and after some time, when squaring Mr. McCall, I discovered it. In May 1866, applied to Capt. Mooney, for payment of a clam of $1,900, and was answered through Mr. Eames.' This. letter admits the claim of $195 to be good, and that it would be paid on due demand, but.the rest to be "without foundation." Again, in June 1868, I sent a Dill in to Capt. Mooney. During the intervening two years, I had been away from Shanghai, i—_ us two monte ait a time. "I d the' large claim; 23 wanted. this one settled first 'The repl received from Capt. Mooney was in peseil, off the back of "an envelope, saying he did not know anything-about my claim in that form. Lreplied, informing him T should now add interest, and take legal proceedings. for' recovery. On the 7th of July, Capt. Mooney replied to one of my notes, refusing payment and intimating a contre account, which he said he had not sent in, 2s he thought the one might have stood against the other. A very' likely thing, to let $200 stand against $125—cularly with Capt. Mooney. This claim 13 quite an afterthought. I also received from Capt. Mooney, July 13th 1858, a bill against the steamer "'Chusan," for a new gig. Capt. Mooney has already es doubts whether I was owner of that "vessel. "I filed a petition'in this Court, for the recovery of this money, when Captain Mooney replied to Mr. Bate, saying that, as he was an American citizen, he could not be summoned in a British Court. I took: proceedings accordingly, paid expenses; and in August got a letter from the U.S. Consulate, declaring that Captain M was only a naturalised American citizen, an having been amenable to British law in China and Japan, "should he sued in a British Court. On the 13th April, this year, sent a copy of bill, with: a note asking payment, and saying that if not paid that day, I should bring him before the Court. Mr. Eames replied, pressing the claim for the boat "furnish= ed to me"—not to the ""Chusan,"

Cross-examined by Captain Moosex—The accounts do not show that yon got the sum claimed for other than personal expenses. 1 found out the mistake when I received my account current from Mr." McCall. I fatly deny that the boat was a subject of converzation at Halland Holtz's. I dont know how long you were at H. & HL's after leaving thie "Chisan," before going to sea again.

To the Covet—I was informed that a collision had occurred in Amoy harbour, that Ca Mooney lost the ship's boat, for which he claimed $200, and got it. This money he kept, and. supplied the deficient boat bya racing gig of his own, not a ship's boat at all.

Capt.' Moosey hoped his Worship would note these remarks of Mr. Reynolds, as he certainly regarded them as amounting to a de-tarnation of character.

Mr. Revsouns said his Worship had asked. him if he had heard anything about this boat. What he had stated he stated in open Court, as having heard; but of his own knowledge hechd not know.

To the Covrt—The boat remained with the ship, and was ultimately sold with her. Thave seen it, It never was a subject of accounts between us, till Capt. Mooney claimed it asa sot-off. Tt was necessary that the ship should have a proper and efficient boat. Nothing of this collision was ever directly reported to Capt in Moxey, sw: eu, stated—T admit T got at Foochow. I dont it claimed from me before July 1868, when I replied, making my claim on account of the gig. I gave up the command of the "Chusan" in Dec., 1865. 1 had an interest in the " Chusan;" Ladvanced mon when she was bought, and took command. connection ceased in Dee. 1865, and squaring of accounts early in 1863. I can, bring proof of claim for the boat. I was myself first to admit the omission of this $125; and also in Hall and Holtz's was advised to press my claim for the, Leat, but said no, Ishould let the one go'? airist the other now. Iancbored ahead of the Gleudover and the collision was caused by wy anchors foiling. As it was I. commit. ted the damage, I could make no claim, 1 supplied an entirely new boat, I paid $165 the boat alone, andi with fMétings over $200.

was used for fire-wood—the ear-avo used the nails, The boat in the log. Inever got paid for I had remembered it at the time, I would certainly have claimed for it. Mr. Reynolds knew of the new boat being sup-ied; when I first came in here, after getting it, I told him it was there. He had no objec tions.

"This concluded the evidence taken; and after some remarks from each of the partis his Warship adjourned the ease for a, day, t0 allow Captain Mooney to call the mate of the "Chusan," to give evidence regarding the boat in question.

Tarr yr. Jarvis.

This was an action of trover, brought by the plaintiff against the defendant, for the "pronufal detention of his carriage, It appeared from the evidence, that the plaintiff sent his carriage to be repaired, and when the repairs were exeeated, he applied for delivery. The defendant requested payment of Ts. 40 for the repairs, avd for certain articles sold to aintiit, before delivery would be granted. Pho plaintiff applied for a bill, setting forth the items, and waited twenty-four hours for it, when he tendered the defendant what he thongist was due to him un the whole account, viz, Tls. 30. Thissum was refused, and an account rendered for Tls. 45, but the plaint had si ready entered sri cation ce conga delivery of the trap, value of repairs, and damages. After a long and patient hearing,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account