The Archive · 1872

THE BRIDGE COMPANY'S POSITION

Ar the meeting held on the 15th instant, the Ratepayers bad again an opportunity of acquiring the property and rights of the Soochow Creek Bridge Company. The Company offered to sell for Tls. 60,000; the Council suggested Tls. 40,000, and for this amount a settlement is likely to become On 12th August, the Company's representative stated the position of his constituents very fully, in a commentary on an article which appeared in our daily issue, and founded a good defence upon the fact that the Company did not rely on the charter we then quoted, but on one granted in 1863, a translation of which we give to-day. Of the former, we need only say that it was strong evidence of the intention for which tolls were imposed—the recoupment of the outlay on the Bridge. The charter of 1863 is, as it has been described, perfectly clear. It gives the Company an exclusive right to build a bridge over the Creek, and to hold it and levy tolls for 25 years from 1854, the monopoly therefore lapsing in the beginning of 1879. The document is very satisfactory, so far as the Company are concerned, except in respect to the all-important doubt whether the Taotai had the powertograntit, and the question whether, a Taotai having done this, a Taotai cannot annul it. This is to the charter, what the bad bottom of the creek has been to the iron bridge, and we can only express surprise that during the nine years for which the matter has been agitated, this radical defect has not been more directly and persistently assailed. The clear terms of the charter were of course recognised by Mr. Medhurst, but this fundamental doubt was only relatively. settled by suggesting another—whether it would be prudent to upset a document given under the Taotai's seal. We may repeat what we have already said, that though, as the delegated officer of the Chinese Government, the Taotai affixes his seal to certain public documents, his act is an evidence only of legality, not legality itself; and if he has not the power to grant a Bridge monopoly over the Soochow creek, as against the foreign community, the mere use of his seal cannot create such a power, nor its misuse in a single instance affect its validity where it is legitimately employed.

Turning to the terms of the charter, we find that it refers to one bridge at the end of the old Bund, and not to bridges generally, though the agents of the Bridge Company stated, at a meeting in 1863—the year in which the gathering public feeling suggested the advisability of obtaining a more conclusive if shorter tenure of the monopoly—that it was granted on the condition that a second bridge should be put up, at Lowza, and that this Bridge had absorbed the profits for the year—Tls. 12,000! Even if the vali-Gity of the charter were maintained,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account