The Archive · 1872

'THE PIECE GOODS' BROKERS

(Daily Press.)

The comments which are made in the North-China Daily News concerning the letter from Brokers, are written in an admirable rit, and with a perfect mastery of the subject. ' While sympathizing with the Brokers, Whose difficulties are such as may justly make it, a subject of regret to ''sit harder" upon them than is absolutely necessary, our northern contemporary points out with much lucidity many of the errors which attach to the position the Brokers have assumed. In writing recently upon the subject, we need scarcely say that we were not insensible of ter was treated somewhat severely for the what is due to the Brokers, though the mat-

simple reason that, in their letter to the Chamber, the Brokers committed the common, but very grave error, of declaring oneself treated unjustly, because those who have given assistance up' to a certain, time, will not continue to do so longer. They complained that the merchants would not continue the support which had called them into existence, overlooking that they had absolutely no dain on the merchants at all. They, in fact, took the position which is familiar to_ all who have had to do with County or Bankraptey Courts, where it is the commonest thing to find that a creditor to whom the greatest tether has been given, considlors himself immensely aggrieved when his debtor at last insists upon payment—the very consideration extended increasing his resentment, instead of evoking his gratitude.

Our northern contemporary suggests a remedy for the existing state of things, in the Brokers combining more together, instead of cutting so greatly against one another, pointing out that the foreign Brokers themselves inaugurated the system of returning a portion of the commission to the Chinese buyer. We fear, however, that, this remedy would be of little use, for' the simple reason that fore Brokers are not very greatly required in Shanghai, If the merchants could not sell without their intervention, proper arrangements as to commissions, '&c., might be of use, but the merchants, who being direct! interested in the matter must be considera competent judges, are fully persuaded that they can do as well upon the average by selling through Chinese as through fore brokers. Gur contemporary admits that the Brokers hit the mark when they stated that their intervention in the sale of the goods was not a necessity, but urges that they should as far as possible make it necessary. We fear, however, that artificial means to attain this end will be found to fail. A Broker's strength is derived not from' the sellers, but from the buyers. Anybody can step into a merchant's office, and bid for his goods, but the people whom the merchant wants to seo are those who, having orders from the buyers, can make the highest bids, and it is for the sake of these higher bid: that he is willing to pay 1 i As long as Chinese buyers find that they em obtain goods through native brokers more cheaply than through the foreign brokers, they will employ the native brokers, and it is not to be expected that merchants will accept a smaller nett amount for a parcel of siely for the purpose of supporting fore Brokers. The trath is, that the suc-coss or otherwise of the piece goods Brokers must be dependent, as stated, upon their making themselves a necessity, but they must make themselves necessary to the buyers in the first instance, as it is only in that wa that they can make themselves indispensable to the sellers. At home, a Broker is a centre around which buyers, who could not possibly become individually acquainted with the details of the market, congregate, and the Broker's strength consists in his connection with them. In China, the buyer ordinarily knows the seller as well as the foreign Broker, and as to the details of the markets he probably knows them better. There is, therefore, no very extensive field for foreign Brokers, and their policy is clearly to endeavour to meet this difficulty as far as practicable by lowering their charges, and relying rather upon the extent of business than Tieger, percentage on each transaction. It is true that there does not, so far as can be now seen, appear to be a very great deal that can be done in this direction; but it is undoubtedly the only direction in which there is any hope of remedying the state of things complained of. The evil of which the Brokers complain is only the natural working out of trade, and can only be.remedied by the ordinary rules of supply and demand. If the Brokers can make themselves useful, buyers will employ them; if they cannot, their trade must go, notwithstanding any artificial mea-gures which might be adopted, either by themselves or by the merchants, to whom they made their appeal.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account