The Archive · 1876

Refusal of Duty

Defendant, one of the stokers of the above: named steamer, was charged with refusal of duty on the 17th inst.

Captain Haatétx deposed that since the ip had been in the stream, there had been no need to get the steam up, and the firemen had therefore been employed in early morning to work the hand pump to give the seamen water to wash decks, instead of using steam from the donkey-engine. On Sunday morning, the firemen refused to perform the duty, first refusing collectively and afterwards individually, They had done the duty on previous mornings, since the vessel had been out of dock, the crew being shorthanded. In the articles it was stipu-ated that the deck bands should assist the firemen, and the firemen the deck hands. He had brought the present case ay a test, rather than bring all the firemen in a body.

Defendant, in answer to the charge, said the firemen were called on Sunday morning, only just as they were wanted, and n usual on board ship, half-an-hour They were in their bed-clothes. during the four mouths he. that had never before been requi

served, but if the had time they would not have refused, because the washing of the decks would' have been finished early.

His Worsttr said he had no doubt there had been a refusal in the case, simply because the firemen thought it was not their place to Eown below and not on deck, But the articles srform such work, and that their work lay

expressly stated that the seamen and. firemen ere mutually to assist each other. Tt was fectly clear that if steam had been up, the firemen would have done the work required of them by the engine; but as there was no steam up, it was necessary for them to work at the hand pump, The question the Captain wanted the Court to decide was whether the firemen were to assist th men or not. His Worship had looked at one articles, and found the firemen were to 0 80, Captain Hascis applied that defendant might be ordered to pay costs.

His Worsuzr said the Captain bad applied for defendant to pay costs. In the case brought, he was right and defendant was wrong, and defendant must therefore pay costs; but as it was a test case, Worship thought the costs ought not to be borne altogether by this one man, Captain Hastis said the amount would be divided among eight men who were concerned, and would be only a few cents each.

Defendant said he had been eighteen years at sea, and had never been in a Police Court before.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account