The Archive · 1877

MR, GROSVENOR'S LECTURE ON THE YUNNAN MISSION

Ir is seldom fair to judge of a lecture by a published precis; the author's favourite points may be omitted, and his most interesting sentences distorted, especially when the subject treated is one with which the reporter is likely to be unfamiliar. The only cafe way in such a case is for the author himself to write the sketch; and from the remarkable absence of blunders in the report given by the Times of Mr. Grosvenor's lecture at the Hall of the Royal. Association in aid of the Deaf and Dumb, we are inclined to think he must have acted on that conviction. Tt would follow that one might com. ment on any sins of omission or commission that suggest themselves, with less' fear of doing injustice to the lecturer. But the premiss is too important to be so easily begged, and we can only rely on the probabilities or otherwise of the report being correct at the points which strike us. It is very curious for instance that the names of Mr. Grosyenor's companions, Messrs. Davenport and Baber, do not occur once in the course of the narrative; yet we can hardly think that, if they "been fittingly brought forward, they would have been overlooked by.'the reporter. One can hardly fancy Spoke's name omitted from a precis of.a lecture by Grant, even in the most negligent summary still, the omission to speak of his companions would be such a neglect of courtesy that it is difficult to imagine Mr. Grosvenor can have been guilty of it, A similar doubt may be held to attend an expression towards the end of the paper, which would be curiously out of place in Mr. Grosvenor's mouth. "In the eighth month after starting," we are told, "he had reached Rangoon, having completed the first journey through China ever accom. plished successfully by a European." Surely these cannot be the words of a gentleman whose journey was actually undertaken to enquire into the murder of Mr, Margary who was returning after having accomplished the same journey alone, and without all the prestige and preparation which facilitated Mr. Grosvenor's progress. The sentence must be an emanation from the reporter's own brain, or have been distorted in the report; though it is curious that the Standard falls into the same error. The Home News puts it that he "accomplished the first overland journey from Shanghai to Rangoon ever undertaken by an Englishman," and this is more literally correct, though the fact still remains that the really difficult part of the journey had been accomplished by Mr. Margary, when he had travelled from Shanghai to Bhamo. From Bhamo to Rangoon is a comparatively well worn route.

The provoking silence which is maintained as to the proceedings at Yiinnanfoo makes us more anxious to see the report, which Mr. Bourke promised should be very shortly made public Even if it should prove to be a record of having dono nothing, the strain on our curiosity will be at an end, and we shall be confirmed in the. opinion we all along expressed, that the Chinese would have everything too carefully prepared, after so many months respite, for the mission to serve any useful purpose of investigation. It" would require an officer of much more experience in Chinese customs and language than Mr. Grosvenor, to disentangle such a web as the Yunnan offcials bad had leisure to weave; and through the peculiar construction of the mission, it of course devolved on Mr. Grosvenor to take every initiative in conducting the enquiry. One piece of information we are given, and it is a sad one; the party remained at Man-wem five or six days, and were able to identify the spot of the murder, but failed to find apy trace of the remains The Chinese indeed, unless we are misinformed, shorned their usual faculty for knowing nothing and producing nothing that it was inconvenient to know or to have produced. Mr. Margary's body, they affirmed, was thrown into the river, a rapid stream which would have borne it quickly out of reach—if the tale be trae. We have yet to learn whether the painful report of the exposure of his head on the walls of Momein was verified or contradicted by Mr. Grosvenor's enquiries, Whether the statements of the Chinese in this respect were true or false, it was probably impossible to amend them; but we cannot but think it would have been possible to recover a better tale of Mr. Margary's effects than is reported to have been forthcoming. What was of little use was given up, what was worth keeping was retained but it is difficult to believe that the officials could not have recovered every thing if they bad chosen to make the effort. OF course they would have denied their power, however much they might have been pressed, at the first outset, But if the English mission bad announced its intention of remaining at Yunnan till what it wanted was forth. coming, we suspect it would have at. tained its end. However, we are anticipating in all this, on the strength of common report, comments that will arise more naturally after porneal of the promised document, which can hardly fail to clear up much that is yet obscure, even it if fail to record the achievement of any useful end in bringing to light the real authors of the crime.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account