The Archive · 1876

CHINESE FORTIFICATIONS

Ir was Machiavelli who laid down the maxim that fortifications are of little utility against popular risings; worse than' useless against foreign enemies. And although this axiom of the philo-sophie statesman has not met with universal reception as an absolute truth, experience has abundantly proved that there is more trath in his aphorism than appears at first sight, The trae defences of a country, the Italian adds, and here the trath of the proposition is indisputable, consist in the mutual confidence of governors and people. Machiavelli spoke of a state of society where all military duty was devolved upon mercenaries; and where the last thing that occurred to 2 government, was to seek the goodwill or respect of its people—of a condition in fact, with the exception of the petty ions of States, not unlike the conditions prevailing in China of to-day. But if experience of the three or four centuries which have elapsed since Macbiavelli's time, has not fully borne out the state~ ment about the absolute inutility of fortresses, it has abundantly proved that, unless supported by an army sufficiently powerful to keep the field, their use is only temporary—to throw off for the moment, rather than avert, final defeat. It was thus that the fortresses of France in 1869-70, though they certainly prolonged the final struggle, did not seriously affect the result; unless indeed we hold, as apparently we are justified in doing, that the shutting up of Bazaine's army within the fortress of Metz was an illustre. tion of the truth of the old Italian's maxim, that fortresses really are a disadvantage to the defending party, In some respects, the mercenary armies of the Italian states of the fifteenth century were not unlike the levies in China' of to-day. They were men picked up anywhere, with no natural bond of anion with those they were serving. Every man know that, although to-day he might be serving in one army, the next might find him in the ranks of the opposite party. No disability, moral or otherwise, was attached to such a change of masters, His only interest lay in the pay he was receiving, or the booty he hoped to obtain; and the side which offered the best attrac. tions was the one for the moment to be preferred. In consequence, the Italian Generals of the day reduced ton few %general rules the conduct of war. First, seeing that their pay depended on their continuance in service, campaign was not to be needlessly hurried. Second, seeing it was more comfortable to be carried than to walk, the soldiers consisted for the most part of cavalry, Third, as war was a profession, the fruits of which the soldier hoped to enjoy, no lives were to be sacrificed or even jeopardised, beyond the number necessary to give a colour. able aspect of reality to war, As a consequence of all this, the history of the Italian contests of the fifteenth century is little more than a record of marchings and countermarchings, of towns besieged and surrendered, of drawn battles with thousands of prisoners but, curiously enough, with all this, without the loss of life we should expect to meet in an ordinary strent melee, Except indeed that vanquishers had a fellow-feeling for vanquished, and that the taking of defenceless lives was not consonant with the ideas of the any, the render might imagine himself perusing Uke ncconnt of the victorious march of areal Chinese army in the nineteenth century. The reasons for such a similarity are not far to seek. The Government and the people of China have no common interest, In consequence, it will not trust them, nor will they in turn give it their support, moral or physical, The soldier ences for nothing but the plunder he hopes to gain, for pay is always withheld, and hence he makes fighting a trade. He is more anxious for a whole skin than for honour; and to escape being picked off by the enemy is more his aim than to gain glory in a hard won contest.

Machiavelli's words about the uselessness of fort fications apply theres fore with especial force to China. give a false security, absorb milli is of taels in their construction, and prevent

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account