The Archive · 1877

CHINESE LAW

Tur Ohina Review has in recent num. bers treated at some length on the important but little understood subject of Ohinese law, or rather Chinese practice; for Jaw in the sense intro. duced by the Romans can scarcely be said to exist. Law in China consists mainly of tradition, but in general of tolerably clear and well understood tradition; and though decisions are largely influenced by the personal feelings or interests of the magistrate, public feeling in the majority of cases reduces the practice to something like uniformity; so that in a review number of. cases, however aberrant may be some of the decisions, we may probably arrive at some inkling of the trae legal tradition bearing upon- a particular case. This indofinitenesa on subject so important as that of law, and in a race which has in some respects shown itself go far in advance of other Orientals, is a strange feature in the China of to-day. Compared with the general accuracy and imparti with which history is treated, and with the refinement to which they have brought their philosophical treatises, the absence of some definite rules of law amongst the Chinese is a most remarkable coincidence. The legal practice of the Chinese is, notwithstanding this defect, " study of some importance, as tending to increase not only our knowledge of the people, bat as throwing light on some of the still vexed questions as to the origin of European law. Looked at superficially, nothing could seem more absurd than the suggestion that the legal systems of Europe and China have anything more than an accidental resemblance; but closer investigation shows identities with the older practice of European nations, and more especially with Rorsan judicature in its oldest forms, which cannot be accidental. Sir Henry Maine, in his "Ancient Law," points out a curious contrast between European and Asiatic nations generally in this introduction of codes to regulate the practice of law. In Greece, Italy, and on the Hellenised sea-board of Western Asis, codes made their appearance in @ similar condition of society. The origin of these codes was probably connected rather with the invention of writing than with any ideas of the superior advan of code over unwritten law. Still, the introduction of codes operated as a check against the abuse of the laws by the aristocracies, who had in all these cases managed to secure a monopoly of legal jurisdiction. In the East, the tendency, however, was for the raling aristocracies to degenerate into religious corporations, while the physical confi-duration of the country had the effect of making the individual communities of larger dimensions than in Europe. "The religious oligarchies of Asia, either for their own guidance, or for relief of their memory, or for the instruction of their disciples, seem in all cases to ultimately embodied their legal learning in a code; but the opportunity of increasing and consolidating their influence was probably too tempting to be resisted. Their complete monopoly of legal knowledge appears to have enabled them to pnt off on the world collections, not so much of the rales actually observed, as of the rules which the priestly order considered proper to be observed." The most remarkable instance of this being the Indian laws of Manu, described curtly as "an ideal picture of that which, in the view of the Brahmins, ought to be the law," and which, though the date of their promulgation is not easily discovered, are, in point of the relative progress of Hindoo jurisprudence, of recent production. The fact that Chinese law has never been codified (we omit, as not bearing directly on our subject, the "Ta T'sing Lu-li"), in itself draws attention to the fact that it diverged from the other streams before the period of codification, and in itself leads to the presumption that we have in China a not inapt representation of the condition of law in the primitive days of humanity. This presumption we find strengthened by a closer comparison of what we can learn of the early state of Jaw in Europe, as well as of the remains of a similar condition to be found in the practice of India. The moat recent investigations go apparently to prove that the art of writing was not introduced in. India till probably the third century, B.C; The great immigration into China had taken place several centuries previously, and the first historical dynasty, that of the Chows, was already in a moribund condition. The sacerdotal element in China bad never assumed a separate istence; the nominal Emperor was still high priest, and each sovereign in his own territories was chief of the religions cult, as of the political or= ganization of his state. While the apparently dissimilar alphabetic systems of Europe and India are now with confidence referred to a common source, no light has yet been thrown on the idolic character of Chinese writing but writing to some extent ab least seems to have been known some five or six centuries before the Christian ora, It was probably too rade to be applied to the nice points of legal nomenclature, while at the same time the principles. of a common law were evidently already well understood. The legal traditions of the Chows were widely spread and well understood. The rulers of the states wore a family presided over by the representative of the eldest branch and in each separate state a similar condition of affairs existed, the family being, in fact, the ruling principle in the constitution of the republic, Notwithstanding the rade shock given to this system by the occupation of the sins and the establishment of a military empire, the fundamental principle has still survived, and to China the jurist must look for the most perfect development of a type of law once reaching from the Pacific to the eastern coast of the Atlantic, REPRESENTATIVE GOVERNMENT, 'A @pwenat impression prevails that an Eastern Government cannot manage to exist with a representative system. We have not yet freed ourselves from the impression that an Oriental state somohow or other must be managed by a despot. When we are contrasting the East and West, we find underlying our various arguments a strong impression that the East must of necessity be under the control of a single individual, generally polygamous, and almost always tyrannical; whereas, when we speak of Western states, we always sce, or fancy we see, some relics of the Anglo-Saxon Witan. It would be a great point gained if people would get it into their heads that at least one Oriental state, and that state the one towards which the eyes of the world are at this moment directed, has a very respectable Parliament. The Turkish Chamber may have many faults, but it is undeniably a National Assembly. For centuries, of course, Turkey has had a personal Government. The traditions of this egotistical form of rale cannot be abolished ina few months. Still, there is every hope that the struggling and imperfect attempt may in time realize the European ideal. The Times

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account