The Archive · 1877

'MR, HENNESSY'S MISGOVERNMENT

Tur sentimental weakness for subject races which seems to be the distinguishing feature of Mr. Hennessy's character, appears to be leading him again into precisely the same course of impolicy which caused so much trouble in Barbadoves. People at home are not very well informed about Hongkong. Beyond a general impression that it is somewhere on the coast of China, and is an extremely small place, nine hundred-and-ninety-nine out of a thousand know nothing; and even the Colonial Office probably is very little aware of the real conditions of life and society in the island. No doubt it thought it was sending Mr. Hennessy to a place where—if the Barbadoes fiasco had not cured him of his crotchets—he could at least air them with impunity; where—if he was not likely to increase the prosperity of the colony—he could ab least not do much harm. And in ove respect this is true. He could hardly succeed, by the most ingenious system of petting the Chinese residents, in bringing about the riots and the dead-lock which occurred at Berbadoes; but he does seem in a fair way to bring about a condition of affairs nearly as dangerous, by " system matically weak administration of justice. Small as it is, Hongkong is not a place which can be gover tied anyhow. Its weak point.is its proximity to the mainland, and the tempting field it offers to the criminal classes of Canton. In Sir Hercules Robinson, Sir Richard Macdonald, and Sir Arthur Kennedy, Hongkong has bad a succession of able administrators who recognised this position, and by a firm and judicious policy gradually established order, and made things so uncomfortable for bad characters that the colony, despite its sitnation, had come to be as orderly and free from exceptional crime as any average community. Not content to let well alone, Mr. Hennessy is tending to undo all this, and, by a policy of sentimental weakness towards the criminal classes, which can have no other effect than to encourage crime, to let the colony fall back into the state of insecurity from which it has been carefully educed.—An ordinary man would be content to assume that the experience of his predecessors had probably not led them altogether astray, and would defer initiating an opposite policy until be had at least hnd time to acquaint himself somewhat with the people and the society he was going to reform. Bat Mr. Hennessy was not content to wait; he at once abolished one deterrent force, in expressing disapproval of flogging; and the Chief Justice has, curiously enough, discovered simul. taneously that the sentences of deportation which have been passed upon crime mals, are illegal in cases' where the date of the warrants and of their execution did not exactly coincide. There are at present a large number of deportation warrants made out in the same form as the one on which this decision was based; and, according to the decision of the Chief Justice, they are all null and void. So that, practically, a number of the scoundrels who have been sent out of the colony find themselves at liberty to return, while the mode of punishment which was most effectual in deterring them from crime is no longer in opera. tion. Enquiry and observation would probably have shown Mr, Hennessy that simple confinement in gaol is hardly any punishment to a Chinaman. He is better housed and fed than he would be outside; and deprivation of personal liberty is to him a trifling inconvenience. But the lash he does dread, and fear of the lash was most effectual in keeping him in order. Yet Mr. Hennessy, in defiance of the experience of his predecessors and of the universal opinion of the colonists, native as well as foreign, has introduced his own crotchet, with the effect that crime has sprang into renewed activity, and people are dreading a return to the days when it was not safe to ven-tare alone beyond the limits of the town. To quote the Ohina Mail, "the aggravating point in regard' to these changes is that they have been introduced by a newly-arrived administrator in the Colony, who, from anything we know to the contrary, bad not previously spent twenty-four hours in either Hongkong or China. The British Government and Administration are in spirit and in practice representative of the people. Vow populi, vox adminis. trations, is the ruling principle not only in the government of the British isles, but, so far as is consistent with safety and the interests of the mother country, in that of the whole of the British Colonies. Here, however, we seem to be entirely at the mercy of one high official, who is not elected by the colonists to the position he occupies, and who appears to possess views on local matters entirely at variance with those of nearly everybody else here. We have not heard of the Legislative Council being consulted in any one matter since Mr. Hennessy's arrival certainly it could not have been con: sulted on the question of fogging. In placing his veto on flogging, we are perfectly convinced His Excellency merely represented himself. The saving of the scoundrel Wong Apa and his confreres, convicted of brutal violence, from the lash, was neither in accordance with the wishes of the native or the foreign population of the Island. We do not consider it healthy for the Government of any" Colony, much less such a pecaliarlyconstituted one as Hongkong, for its high administrative functions to be discharged by one person, who is an entire stranger to the quarter of the globe in which it is situated, and who seems to be superior to outside or any counsel but that of his own mental churning." The Mail does not mince matters, bat there seems no doubt that it expresses the feelings of the community.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account