James Webster Cowie, of Shanghai, solicitor for the claimants in prosecuting a claim for damage preferred on behalf of Yang-Chang-Lin, residing at Shanghai, the sole owner of the Chisese junk Niok: jestoat, the omners of the cargo on board the said junk at the time of the collision hereinafter referred ty and clothes, goods, and private offes on board thereof, against Dela of the master and crow of the et jack, for their the American steamer Golden Age, her tackle, apparel, and farnitureand freight, and against George F. Bowman, the Agent acting for, and on behalf of, the said ateamevel Golden Age, says as follows—That at about §.30 otlock pin. on the 10th June, 1STi, the said junk (recently arrived from Yaughoo, the peo from Woosung al. the said Junk was theo, and at the tine of the collision herein for pended, tight, staunch, andatrovg, abd well ed slid tackled aod well found in every respect. She tinder the command of Chang jeeaben, her master, and hada crow of 20 sailor.
°3-—At or about the time, and on the day stated in the paragraph, the sid Jubk was beating up river on tie Hood tide about ona It ("of a mie south of the Krowjeo. Cros, and about 300 feet said steamer Golden ge, at or about the time last uasaely, Inguing down the river froméhanghaly ran stm on it tha' port se of" the said june, Between the fore and tait mats stout Tt feet om the bow and ext one through the whale beam of the junk, Wea drat sen ly th junk, the eid steamer was about one li (3 of a mile) distant, and approached very Tapidly. The junk Kept-on het cours, thinking the pany 'a8 she might easily have done, passed he-for cased by the collision wes very violent, and strained the whole hull of the said ju causing She her starboard aide to open out. Thee farrowly escaped with thers fives The water rushed Fine began to rapidly She rite nero exter Side of the river, abd eetibal down in the. med, Ins deck being covered water.
othe said collision the improper naviga: da ent thereon were wholly occaionea tiom'et the: Gotlex ge aod negligence Asftole of those on boned her, aad somme are not Shy manner attributable tothe sal Juni, or tony person on boam of her who all id the wtmose tu their ower to avoid or prevent-the tai ellen, ToThat the extyo bu beard thes junk was consequence of the cnlson eatiely dovtroyed withthe Yurtdealars Herewito auvexed, and the cost of raislag lon, ofa. very. amall quaailyealved, as por wreck and repairing her weald have more than equal. Ind her value blore the collision took Toft the amount found to be due. to the claimants should be paid to mo. a8 their Solicitor, for ittdbution emougse" them, necordng to the aunts thee respective claims.
Datel of Shangha, this 18 day of July, 187. He then went. or say that the contention on behalf of his clients in that case was briefly this: that in conformity with well known rules of navigation, the persons in charge of the junk, when seeing the steamer approaching them, kept on their course, and that the steamer was bound to give way to the junk. His friend, Mr. Eames, would no doubt take exception to this, and explain that it was never intended that the rule referred to should be invariably followed. [t would be incum-Lent, however, for the other side to shew why the steamer had placed herself in such a position as not to have been able to have kept out of the way of the junk. Evidence would be adduced to shew clearly that the junk did keep her course, and that the steamer was solely to blame for the collision. He then quoted the following cases, decided in the American Courts, Cummins v. Spruance, 4 Harring, 315; The Columbus, 1 Abb. Adm. 385; the Clement, 2 Curtis C. C. 363; St. John v. Paina 13 How, 581; the Washington Treing, 1 Abb. Adm. 336; Conkling's U. S. Adm. Prac! 399. With regard to the rate at which the steamer was going, namely, 9 to 10 miles an hour, he thought there could be no question about the negligence and want of nautical skill displayed on the part of those in charge of the steamer, in rushing through a narrow channel at that speed on a dark night. Tt was a course of proceeding wholly unjustifable. He would refer to a case decided in America, where, under circumstances almost similar to the present, three and a half miles an hour had been pronounced too great for safety. It was known as the case of the A. Rossiter, 1 Newb. Adm. 225. That collision occurred at Chicago.
Mr. Sewarp—Mr. Cowie, the river there is not much wider than the Soochow Creek, and is full of shipping.
Mr. Cowre continued—Wo'l, your Hono: it must be remembered that the navigable channel of the Shanghai river, where the collision occurred, is very marrow, and is much used by junks at all hours of the day and night. He then referred to the case "The Ogdensburgh," 1 Newb. Adm. 113. Then, as to lights, evidence would be brought forward to prove that there was a bright light faring on the junk at the ureal place on dhe stern of the time of, and subsequent to, the collision. Having heard the foreign evidence on this head, he did not wish to impute in any degree a wilful perversion of the truth by any of the witnesses who had already been examined, but it would be proved unmistakeably that' there was a light on the junk at the time of collision, and that it was fixed {in the usual place, and he could account for the statements to the contrary thus, that in the excitement occasioned by the collision the witnesses who had been examined did not remember very minutely what they actually did or did not see. Besides, the presumption was that the crew of the junk carried a light for their own safety. He then drow atten. tion to the remarks made by the U.S. A. Consul-General in the case of the King-dong Fong v. Hangchow, reported in the North-China Herald of 26th August, 1869: "Tt is well known the Chinese are ignorant of our rules of steering, of lights, &e., and are very likely to become confused in the face of danger. This should be remembered as an element to be provided for in approaching Chinese craft, and when it is disregarded, the Courts will be very likely to deal seve with the foreign vessel. It is absolutely cri inal to forget the inexperience and want of coolness of Chinese navigators, and it is altogether unreasonable to set down their failures to perversity. In the cause of the Gazelle, Robinson 518, Dr. Lushington observed: It is an undoubted proposition that the steamer is bound to give way, whether the sailing vessel be on the starboard or port tack. What, then, is the meaning of the term give way? [have already stated my own impression that it means getting out of the way by any measures that the occasion may require and this construction of the right ani duty of a steamer when meeting a sailing v perfectly affirmed by the Rules more Keep out of the way of the aalling ship.
lished, which say only "the steamship
conclusion, he said—Gentlemen, my friend, Cooper, and I are fully sensible of the' di ficulty of our position in advocating a claim of this nature aganstan influential and deservedly Feat satisfied. that. neither the influence or popular Foreign Steamship Company, yot we
popularity of the parties on the other side will-interfere with your giving a just and suitable decision in this ease, and when the idence has been received, I ean-be favourable to my clients, and no exons whatever will be found for the steamer running down the junk. He then proceeded to call evidence.
Lzo Mixe Suvw, stated—I was lowdah of the Neok Joe Shun. Ihave been on her three ears. Lama Tientsin man. Thave been going in and out of Shanghai for 20 years. I know the river well. She arrived on the 26th day of the Gth Moon; had a full cargo of bean: and had 21 men including myself. The jun had two masts; she would carry 2,200 piculs. The jank was a Tientsin junk. We had a light. It was at the stern. It was suspended on a post at the after part of the junk, about 17 feet high. It was a Tientsin lantern about a foot in diameter and 20 inches high. It was anew one. We entered Woosung that night as the sun was setting. The tide was at the last of the ebb or beginning of the flood. We lighted the lamp before we reached the bar. A boy, one of the crow, lighted the lamp. It is usual with Chinese as well as foreigners to have a light on vessels at night. I do not remember a night when our mp wasn't lighted. Dangersare on every side in coming into this river and all should have alight, [t was the duty of one man to keep the lights. Itwasacandle lantern, The candle was 1 inch in diameter, and 6 inches long, and the ordinary lights. Different junks have different lights, some large, some small. It was burning brightly the night of the edllision, It could be seen two miles. When we left Woosung we had two sails set, one on the fore and one on the main mast. We had no sail on the mizen mast that night. It was a bad night, and the wind was such that it vould be of no use. The mizen is only hoisted as a rule when the wind is fair. When I first saw the lights of the steamer was just above the head of Gough Island When I first saw the light, we had just passed the mouth of Keo-jow-creek, We had not passed the month of the creek more than the space of a half li, when I first saw the white
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.