The Archive · 1876

Refusal of Duty

Accused is a fireman and coal trimmer on board the above mamed steamer, ud wat fon the Ot2 instant.

yy Captain with refusing duty Complainant stated that on Sunday, the Gth instant, when at sea, but in sight of the Saddles, on the voyage to Shanghai, the chief engineer reported to him that accused had in refused to go below to work in the stoke-hole for an extra two hours' watch, One of the stokers was ill, and this necessitated others keeping a six hours' watch, instead of the usual fon jours on and eight off. Complainant ordered accused to go below, when he insolently refused, saying he was not made of iron.

Acoused said in defence that there was something the matter with his back, and he could not do more than his usual four hours' work ata time.

Complainant said acoused did not complain to him about his back. He had done the extra work before without complaining, and on the occasion in question wae told the ship have a good long rest, He (Complainant) did ould be in port next day, and he woul not not want the accused punished, but only for the Court to give him to understand that he must obey orders, or the probability would be that the other men would cause trouble in like manner, The second engineer of the ship confirmed the captain's statements.

His Worsurr said he held that the Captain was fied in requiring the accused to do the extra work, and that accused had not given sufficient reason to justify his refusal. His Worship had entered in his book that acoused was to forfeit tivo days' pay, and to pay costs, for refusing to obey proper orders, but as it' appeared that he had done extra work on former occasions, he would now only enter him to pay costs, Accused was bound, as far as he could, to comply with the Captain's orders," and nothing but illness which incapacitated from work altogether, could justi him in refusing. If the Captai engineer had seen that he was too ill to do the work on this occasion, they would not have pressed him to doit. Accused bad already worked for four hours, and he could not have been Boker men had done it as well as accused, physically incapable to work another two. and he had no reasonable excuse to offer. His Worship would always require to be clearly satisfied of a man's incapacity to comply with the orders of a Captain, especially of a ship at sea, before accepting an excuse for refusal of duty. If accused had been willing to work, he could have done it, but the fact was he did not want to do it, U. S. CONSULATE.GENERAL, Shanghai, August 8th, Before J. C, Mvzns, Esq., U.S, Consut-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account