We have received so many letters on the following disagreeable subject, that we feel, though reluctantly, compelled to allude to it once more in a manner illustrative of the feelings and opinions of the writers; but With no intention of c-vpeuiny correspondence. At the same time, we sincerely hope the Municipal Council will take such action as will spare the necessity for further public reference to it.
The trial at working the Contagious Diseases Ordinance at Hongkong has been little more successful than the attempts of the Municipal Council here to introduce a similar system, and for very similar reasons. Support it by every measure possible, the fact remains that it is contrary to the instincts of human nature, whether male or female, and the natural result has been that whenever tried it has resulted in the utter demoralization of all those who have been thrown into contact with its working, whether as women submitting to degradation or as men employed as informers or in other capacities, where all thought of manliness has to be suppressed. The system has now for several years been at work in Hongkong, where all the powers of a centralized and practically irresponsible Governmenthavebeen brought to bear. It has, therefore, had an opportunity of development impossible in Shanghai, For a time apparently successful, grave doubts have arisen as to its satisfactory continuance, and the conclusions of the committee appointed to enquire into its working, while differing as to details, are unanimous in their expression of opinion as to the demoralization induced. The medical evidence as to the advantages of the system is at Hongkong as elsewhere divergent; still two members of the Commission, after hearing the evidence, express themselves as satisfied that the licensed establishments are in themselves sources of infection, and that they, rather than unlicensed houses, have acted "as the sources of disease to soldiers and sailors." The third member of the Commission, while thinking the condemnation of the other two too strong, is yet forced to admit as a necessary result of a system which brings into its service the lowest class of Europeans and natives, that "abuses of a very serious nature have occurred." Altogether the effect of the Ordinance has by no means answered to the wishes of its originators, and it has, with at the best but doubtful sanitary success, been attended with social evils of the worst description. Originally the Ordinance was intended to apply to natives and foreigners alike, but experience has shown that all the powers of the Government were unequal to the task.
The relaxation in favour of exclusively native institutions, while it has so far redrived the objections to the system, has done so only at the cost of depriving it of its only reason for existence. As in an embankment the strength of the whole is only the strength of its weakest point, so in these matters where infection is to be kept out by repressive measures, the leaving of a loophole is apt to be as dangerous as if a passage way were left unguarded. That when such an institution is first started it may have beneficial effects is plain, but experience has long ago proved that these benefits decrease with practice, and in their stead a now species of evils arise. This may be taken as the true reading of the statistics published in the Last report of the Municipal Council. From these it ix seen Unat during the stay of one of Her Majesty's ships in Singapore, there was on an average one case in in Hongkong, 1 in 74, in Nagasaki, Lin 4; in Yokohama, 1in 74. Now it is noteworthy that in all these places (except Singapore, of which there is no information), the system of repression has been actively put in practice. In Shanghai, where it has hitherto been but partially enforced, the number of eases amounted to only 1 in 31 days, and in Chinkiang, where nothing of the sort exists, there was not a single case during stay of 47 days. The acting Medical Officer to the Council states that the experience of was similar to that of H.B.M. might, therefore, be suggested to the Muni cipal Council that the real reason of the comparative immunity of Shanghai is rather to be sought in the absence then the presence of repressive measures, At the same time whileagreeing with the general recommendations of the Commission at Hong-korly, that a certain amount of surveillance may be useful, provided the feelings and prejudices of those most concerned be consulted, we think, with them, ' that the less irksome and distasteful the rules are made, the less likely are they to be evaded."
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.