The junk King-chiang-ho v, the steamship Ningpo.
Mr. Rosnvson appeared for the plaintiff Mr. Revwiz conducted the case on behalf of the defendants.
To-day his Lordebip delivered the following Judgment:
This la a case of collision brought by the owners of the Chinese junk King-chiang-ho inst the owners of the British steamship fingyo; the junk having been run down on
the river Hwangpoo, by the Ningpo, at " place the of March, 1678, while a anchor on distant from Bleck Point about yo cables up the river. The collision took place in day-ight; and, from the evidence given by those in, the employ of the Harbour-master's de: partment at Wooeung, and which I feel bound fo accept as correct, it would seem to have covurred as, nearly'se possible p, m. The direction of the wind at the ti Fight sorose the channel, being Kast by North. The. weather was and clear, and the wind was light. The steamer Was proceeding up the river at the rate of eight knots an our, with a flood tide just making. When the position of the junk collided with was first seen from the steamer, the junk and the steamer must have been at a distance of little less than, were at all lasa th: i This will, I think, afterwards appear in the course of my judgment, The junk drew 11 feet, and was anchored ona bank on the west ern side of the steamer channel called the Upper Middle Ground, im about 13 feet at low water, 20 that at low water it had n0 more than enough water to ride at anchor in safety. It cannot, therefore, be said to have been anchored in the steamer channel, The junk, when collided with, was lying with its head to the Eastern and its atom to the Western bank of the river. It was slack water, and the junk was brought into that position by the alight breeze which there then was. Thus the jank was taken atill more out of the steamer channel by the wind than it would have been if the tide lad been strong enough to place it with ite bead to the floods which, as 'I have observed, waa just beginning to make at the time of the collision. From the evidence for the defendants, it appeared that at the time of the collision the steamer channel was blocked by several junks. Captain Cass, the master of t Ningpo, said that shortly after the coll channel to the wind, their beads being to ihe counted eleven, lying right acroa that
the N.E., and that the atom of one overlapped the bow of another ao closely that it was impossible for the Ningpo to pass up the steamer channel between them. That position of the janks was attributable to. the state of the tide—it being then slack water—and to the easterly direction of the wind; for about three quarters of an hour before the collision, the Tunsin, which is paddle steamer with a width of about 52 feet from the outside of one paddle box to the onteide of the other, passed up the r between two of the junks in the steamer channel. From the evidence for the plaintiffs, it speared that the junk collided with dropped down the river from Shanghai with the tide, and the lowdah of said he came to an anchor at half-11 o'clock a.m., when the tide was slack.
who junk had 24 men on board all told but the only person on board of it who] b gives any evidence at all as to the collision, igaman who was on board at the time of the collision and bad charge of the anchore, and be says be only saw the collision when the steamer was about 50 feet from the junk. The manner in which the collision took place is thus only to be ascertained from the evidence for the defendants, Captain Cass, the master of the Ningpo, says that he kept " good look-out, and that when be got abreast of Black Point he saw number of junks anchored right across the steamer channel, from a point about one cable above on the extreme east side to point four cables up on the western side of the channel that he had ween nothing on coming to Black Point to show that the ateamer d vel was obstructed; that it was impossible for him to see that the channel above Black Point was obstructed until he was abreastof that Point, inasmuch s the river above the Point curves in considerably, and be could not, from below the Point, see over it on account of the trees which there are at the Point; that although when he got close up to the Point he could see masts of junks, he could not, until he got up to the Point, see how the junks were lying or how they were obstructing the channel or their distance from each other; that when he found the channel so blocked as to prevent his taking his usual course, he he must either beach his vessel, that is, ran her on the West bank, or attempt to pass westward of the junk collided with; that in coming to that conclusion he took' into con on having to stop and anchor; that to attempt to anchor would have been attended with very serious risk, and a collision with thros or four junks would probably have been the result, because when be was abreast of Black Point be was going eight knots an hour, and to have anchored be must have stopped and k sent his engines full speed d astern; that time} be would thereby have lost all command of his vessel as far as steering cerned, and that by letting go his anchor he would have lost it or broken his windlass, and probably have collided with one or more of the other june; that if the anchor had held he would have brought up with the steamer's head to the N.E.; but that she would have carried her anchor over the ground @ long ay even if the cable had not broken before bringing up. Ceptain Cass then and that be readied hin vessel to pass about 30 fast clear of the stern of the westernmost junk, that fs, the junk collided with; and that his vessel's ead was pointed in' that direction, His ship wasat that time going eight knot an yur and he took her on at fall speed, that is, he made no alteration. He thought the worst that could happen would be that his vessel would run ashore on the bank, He estimated the probable depth of water, and was doubtful whether there would be eno water for him to pass. He thought it he might ground in mud, To slows down would bat mud he thought by going full speed.
would probably drive through it, Captain aid that when about 200 yards from the juck collided with, the Ningpo took the ground and lost steering power. The bottom was soft mud. She did not stop on the ground, as he had calculated she would, until the tide rove. Having lost steering ywor, she canted with her head to the at, towards the jank collided with, The' helm was then thrown hard to port and here stopped, The steamer Fefused to avower her helm and atill canted to port. The engines were then put full speed astern, and the starboard anchor was Tot'go.. She carried way enough to reach the junk, which she struck on her broadside, Immediately after the collision, the steam began to go astern and grounded heavily 11 on the bank in 13 (eet of water ami about 40 feet clear of the isan account given by Captain Cass of the manner in which the collision took place 5 and he says that the Ningpo remained about half an hour on the bank where be had anchored, got off with the rising tide and steam power, she proceed up to The lowdah of the junk No rules or ig themselves to an anchor; and I think clearly established by the 0 in this cine that the tonk an anchored in 9 Bot' anchored in' the steamer" channel, roper pi and further that it was With reference to the distance which the junk and the steamer were from each other when the junk was first seen from the steamer,
the Captain of the Ningpo, Supposing an. Mr. Robison pa the following question to experienced pilot bad suid that below Black "Point the waste of junks above Black Point would he seen at a distance of one mile, or "one mile and" half, if the weather was clear, would that be correct Captain Cass answered, If they were lying on the eastern "side of the river, they could not be seen 5 "but if they wore lying on the western side chanae, they could be seen 2 and in to a question by me, Captain Cass he fret a ko got into ith, he was distant from it eight ight-tothe of knot. I therefore think the Court is not in error in estimat the distance between the jank collided wi and the steamer, when the former was fi teen from the latter at little lees than, if indeed it were at all less than, mile, Then as to the manner in which Captain Cass navigated the Ningpo. The evidence in season of the year many i 8 hey hat they are in the and that anyone experienced in th "ston habit of dropping down the river in gran of the river would be acquainted wit at fact. Cap! hhimaelf in hia evidence peake of thia practice, Now from the state of and tide, and from the position in which the junk was' when ho first aaw ber, Ceptain Case must have known that any junks be might meet at anchor at that time in the of the river in which ¢ ie he collided Tithe wan, viz, with their heads to the with was, would be lying in the same posi eastern and their' sterns to the westera side of the river. He also says that the river curves considerably immediately above Black
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.