the Editor of the Dear S12,—Your leader of Wednesday's issue will, no doubt, be read with interest, inasmuch' as it refers to a subject which touches-the pockets of all loyal Britons—the Rogisiration squeeze. There is no Aoubt but that the tax is a very obnoxious one in the Settlement, and everybody would gladly sce it abolished, or at least substituted by something more equitable in the matter of enforce-"That being so, the question. of its ity or illegality becomes of first class importance, because if it is believed to be illegal, it ought to be resisted by the methods which the law points out, and which have not yet all been exhausted; but if legal, a different method altogether must be pursued; and it is because in your remarks bu this point there seems to me to be a rious misconception that I thus address WeThe part to which I refer is when you seem to class Royal Proclamations and Orders in Council in the same category. I think there is this material difference between the two, that the latter are made in pursuance of powers conferred by a special Ket of Parliament, and are good #0 long as these powers are' not exoveded; whereas the other are issued of the Queen's own motion, in virtue of her position as Queen, or as it is usually termed in virtue of her prerogative, and are good only #0 far as the Constitution and laws of the kingdom po mit, whi ico the memo: able stragyles with tory are familiar, have not permitted the leat disability to be imposed thereby on subjects in England.
Orders in Council are, Leoncoive, simply instances of laws made not directly by the supreme legislature, but by some subordinate body under delegated powers, a form of legislature familiar to us all—the ple. The Queen, as such, has nothing todo bye-laws of Railiray Companies for exam-
with them—the legislature might just as well have said the Lord Chancellor or anybody else. They in fact simply say, instead of making this law ourselves we will Teave it to you-to do, and whatever you order shall have the same authority a8 if we had done it, So that if a judge is called upon to enforce any so made order, all he has got to see is whether it comes within the powers conferred. Oi course if it does not it is void.
Now to come to the O: ler in Council.—It is made, as every one will see who takes the trouble to read the beginning of it, in pursuance of two Acts—the first enables Her Majesty tomake laws forthe good government of her subjects in China in the Sime way as she might in Hongkong, and on this the obvious questions are: Is a poll tax of $5a head forthe good government of Her Majesty'seubjects, and could Her Majesty levy such a toxin Hongkong? A very fair argument, [think, might be maintained to uphold the negative in both, and perhaps some etch doubt may have prompted the next Act, which is of a far more sweeping kind, Itenables Her Majesty tolegisiate for British subjects in Shanghai (for instance) in the same way as she could have done if the territory had been acquired by cession conquest, 'This does not make us much wiser until we know what the Queen' can do with territory gained by cession or conquest; but the books on Colonial law do not leave us in doubt, and it seems she can do pretty much as she pleases. This is no place to go into a dissertation about the nature of colonies, but this much may be said, that generally speaking all colonies are divided into two classes—those acquired by cession or conquest, and those formed by settlers from England, The latter carry with them the laws of England for the time being in force as their inalienable birthright, and the Queen, as such, has no power to interfere; but the former having been gained by the Queen's forces are entirely at the mercy of the Crown, which has the right to tax them and control them at will. The power, however, of taxation and local legislation or home rule" has been generally surrendered to local legislative council, on payment of a fixed contribution to Irperial i kong, for instance, pays, I believe, £20,000—and once surrendered la irrevocable, It seems, therefore, that we stand to the Crown on the footing of a conquered co-Tony. Had it not been for the positive enactment, it might fairly have been argued that we are analogous to, and should have the rights asa colony of settlers, Parliament, which of cours all cases, has made it, other. wise. Whether we ate better than Hongkong, or whether while trying to have matters altered, is another subject of discussion altogether. Your obedient servant, Dee, 26, 1873.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.