The Archive · 1878

Russia, in Maritime Law Cases, page 351

He next reviewed the facts of the case as eved in evidence, remarking that the Tingpo, in broad daylight, collided with the plaintiff's junk which was at anchor in a judice ious position. She was anchored out of the way, and that was all he maintained was necessary to be proved on her behalf; it Femained with the 'Vingpo to juriily herself for the damage she bad done. His learned friend had endeavoured to make out, cause of damage against the junk, that because other june, over which the plaintiff had no control' whatever, had chosen to take course which placed the steamer in difficulty, abe (plaintiff's junk) was to suffer the consequences.

Mr. Ronmsow, in summing up on behalf. of ined that Mr. Rennie the plaintiff, said that after the very patient bad argued that plaintiff's junk, being th hearing already given to the case, be should last to anchor, completed the blocking endeavour to be as brief as his duty to his the channel—that is, she filled the remaining client would permit. When he ventured to space that was left by the other junks. hint, in opening the case, that if certain facts Mr. Ronixsox replied plaiuti®'s were proved on behalf of the plaintiff the junk did not obstruct the fairway, and argued case would virtually be an undefended one, that the evidence of Captain Goodieilow he did not for a moment suppose that went a great way to establish that ed friend would not oppose him with His Lorvsuir expressed the opinion accustomed vigour and ability, or even with the endurance and heroism of an Osman Ceptain Goodfellow's evidence was great] Pasha, That brave commander could, not favour of the junk. defend Ple Mr. Rostxson thought he had established food and one broad fact—that the junk was at anchor facta in a proper place at the time she was run fo support his cage. 18 was clearly sid down into by the Ningpo, He would now proceed vessel in motion collided with a show that the Ningpo was not navigated char, the burden of proof rested on with that care and attention she ought to to prove that the collision was have been, but at too high a speed in coming ble or that the vessel at up the rit It was the bounden duty of ay to blame. This princi-the Ningpo to do all she possibly could in the cases of the to avoid the collision, if even the junk was rolamo and Batavier, cited improperly anchored, and failing to do so she i now again 3 was bound to make the junk compensation ut on to remark that in his opinion for the damage she had done. He (Mr. Robin-law was not alone to be administered son) then analysed the evidence which bad Court, He took it that the law to be administered was that which Mr. Lowndes called the comnion law of the aes, which was speed the Ningpo was going, avd contended been produced on both aides on the point of the

that it was the duty of ey master, com-eneral maritime Jaw. Foreign vessels were ing round a curve like Black Point, to slow Tivt at all bound by British municipal law, down before reaching it. All prudent masters and_ who sh vessels travelled into would do so, but if they did not and loss foreign waters, the British municipal law did resulted, they would be clearly to blame. The not apply; for instance, it could not be applied Ningpo came up to Black Point at eight knots caves of collision occurring in an hour, much too high a speed, and cuddenly point he referred found herself in the presence of danger, having Sazonia, reported in Luebington, page 410, and then proceeded jer own Captain's statement, by the high it out of her own power, according to at it would not be speed, at which abe was going, to pre:

ply Britis vent herself doing injury to oth was this kind, for regard must be ba as clear as anything could possibly be that peculiar position of the Chinese and the the master of the Mingpo was responsible. customs in force amon; It was obvious that if instead of going eight knots the steamer had been going two or four she could have stopped and anchored; but eben stopy or slowed bat went ahead. At this particular season of the year clusively proved that the chaun june might have been ex; pected to be anjoodfellow's evidence was of groat chored above Black Point; for, from thedefenlduce on the point, for it proved that ant's own show: they dropped down the wu-hour before the accident, his ates river in groups and were a source of great which waa twenty-one feet bron an trouble to ship-mast hey were com-the Ningpo, used the fairway at a speed plained of as anchoring at dangerous places, of ten knots ay holtr, and the and on this account it might naturally be jucks without accident. "There could be no thought that aay prudent master would slow proof than this that the channel was down considerably in. approaching a curve 10 it was not at all to be assumed like Black Point.

junks, said to be anchored in the His Lorpsure thought it was " stron; anchored in improper places. point, and one which pressed the defendants nts, it had been proved beyond dis-the Captain did not slow down at all at Black ware that the plaintiff's junk was anchored

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account