Tae Woosung Bar question has been at length brought toa head. Instructed by their several Governments, the Foreign Ministers have succeeded in extracting an answer from the Tsung-Yamen; and even the distinct refusal conveyed is preferable to the utter neglect of past years. We at least know now where we are, and can do-bate what further steps are necessary to attain the desired end. Official information, it would be too much to expect yet for some months; but the Chamber of Commerce will probably not await it, before pressing the matter again upon the Home Government. Some day or other, in some remote Blue Book, the Tsungli Yamen's despatch will probably see the light. Bat in the meantime, the position taken up has become sufficiently known to enable farther action.
The matter was of course, as a first step, referred from Peking to the Provinees—that admirable device for gaining time, and putting into other mouths arguments that come better from a distance, which Sir Rutherford Alcock so ably satirised in one of his best despatches. The Viceroy of Nanking, who is also Superintendent of Trade for the Southern Ports, was called on to report, and appears to have collated with some sequence and ability a number of quaint reasons why not to do it. Indeed, starting from the text of opposition, it would have been dif-ticuls to make out a better case.
The heads of His Excellency's argument are as follow: 1° The inconvenience of the Bar is exaggerated; only the deepest vessels are detained, and not even they at all seasons. 2° The Bar is a natural defence, which it would be folly to destroy. 3° To dredge the Bar would be to allow ingress to a greater flow of tide, to the danger of native craft, to the damage of the embankments, and to the consequent me jury of agriculture and loss of revenue, And these several points are expatiated on with the plausibility which always excites admiration in a Chinese despatch. The Viceroy has examined all the books, maps and records bearing on the subject, and finds that for at least 120 years the Bar has existed in its present position, and is manifestly de. signed by Heaven as a protection against outside enemies and Yangtze silt. Tt does not interfere with native craft, which pass and repass with ease; it does not detain even many foreign ships, and not even these at all seasons ofthe year, Besides, if they cannot get over, they only have to discharge cargo into lighters, and then they can cross at leisure. Ships of more moderate draft can always get in by waiting for high water; let them wait. If Foreigners choose for their own advantage to build big ships, it is no reason why China should be deprived of her natural defences!—The fallacy of this argument has been sufficiently exposed, by the constant record in our columns of steamers delayed, and the estimates of heavy loss consequently sustained, But it brings us to the point which is most strongly urged from both Southern and Northern Capitals; though one which we should not have expected to see so frankly put forward, Stress is laid both by" the Viceroy and Prince Kung, on this question of Defence. There used formerly to be forts at Woosung, and if they should be reconstructed after the example of Taku, the Bar would be a powerful adjunct. It is a natural defence; ships have to travel over it through a winding channel which would prolong their exposure. The argument, indeed, is so frankly stated, that it might almost be taken as a hint that China will not be worried into dredging the Woosung Bar or doing any other work at Foreign instance, against her own wish and will, But there are so many ways of reaching Shanghai besides passing Woosung, and so many ways of capturing
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.