The Archive · 1880

A War with China

In the event of a Russo-Chinese war, it is a somewhat doubtful question how the subjects of foreign treaty Powers would be circumstanced. The Japan Herald, in an article on the subject, says What is the nature of a foreign Conces-ion? It is in its objective a virtual cession in perpetuity, conditional upon payment of fixed yearly rents, and observance of some regulations, which in reality are provisions for ensuring respect to Chinese territorial interests external to the foreign settlement. In China there are many concessions, and but one unqualified cession, Hongkong. Macao is a concession held upon what virtually a lease in perpetuity.

The question arises, what is the exact legal status of an extra-territorialized concession in time of war? and in what way will belligerents consider its identity or difference if compared with auch a place as Hongkong, which is no longer Chinese, but has become British ground by unconditional cession. Wio.ate disposed te contend that while the nationals of treaty Powers resident in Shanghai, Tientsin, and other extra-territorialized settlements must be Enforoement of strict neutral ty, the settle-jealously hedged around by the strongest

ments, their foreign population, and their trade, must be held to be neutralized, and free from all hindrance from either belligerent. We hold that the operations of war, such as landing, blockade, search, seizure, requisition for ransom, or actual occupation, will not be suffered to apply to the foreign settlements.

TheChinese Government hasrelinquished, save in case of non-payment of rent, all rights over the foreign extra-territorialized settlements. No Chinese troops occupy or can occupy them; no Chinese troops can pass through without permission. Although abuses have crept into some places where Tekin offices have been opened, yet the existence of these places is in a way kept secret, has no oficial sanction from forei; authorities, and at any moment may prohibited. There are in Shanghai, for instance, native courts, prisons, de., but these establishments exist by request of foreign Powers, for foreign convenience, and, so far, have no right in permanence. If ground rent is paid,—if boundaries are respected, and certain regulations for common protection,—native and foreign,—are observed, the settlements are as much neutralized possessions by law as is Hongkong, and in case of war, are entitled we hold, to have neutral rights respected by both belligerents.

The Russian attack must be confined to Chinese towns, Chinese territory, Chinese ships, Chinese trade. But the foreign Settlements are withdrawn from Chinese occupation, and are freed from Chin jurisdiction. 'The Chinese will not be por-mitted, for instance, to make a battery on the Shanghai Public Garden, nor may a redoubt be placed on the Race Course, nor may the Chinese authorities block' the river, or bar the entrance by torpedoes. But then Russia, on her part, must not occupy parts of the settlements, to command Soochow Creek, or Shanghai city. "The obligation to respect neutrality is reciprocal on both. If there were no extra-territorialized settlement for foreigners they must, as neutrals, have notice from the attacker, take their chances, or go away. But the settlements have, in origin and de facto, ishmunities, and these immunities must be jealously guarded against both Chinese and Russian aggressions, Our argument is, that in accordance with undoubted firat intention, foreign residents in China, subjects of treaty Powers, and living in places set apart, have the full rights of neutrals, equal in effect to those enjoyed by the residents in Hongkong. Further, that these neutral rights involve freedom, not only of access and exit, but of all the operations of legitimate export and import trade.

The French Government has always contended that the French concessions of Shanghai, Tentsin, and Canton arg, de jure and de facto, French territory, which "has all the rights, privileges, and neutrality; proper to ceded ground.' We may add, as an illustration, that when it was averred that the cession, or rather concession, was conditional upon payment of rent to the Emperor, in token of the Emperor's territorial rights, it was answered that if a foreign nation invaded and afterwards annexed territory, the rights of landlords, proprietors, &c., to rent, would yet remain undisturbed. 'In China, as in Japan, the Emperor is lord of the soil, and the purchase moneys that may be paid for ground bought are merely tenants' or Ocoupiers' rights, so that the yearly ground rents paid by Frenchmen are the dues belonging to the owner of the soil, and are

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account