The Archive · 1879

Before R. A. Mowar, Esq

(AMAR) v, Assay, Assault, Prisoner is runner for a Malay boarding house in Hongkew, and ing one of the in evidence was to opinion was that on gave Poignand the goat.

Lonpsure said it was not for the witness to form an opinion about the conversa. tion, He himself had todothat, Besides, the inese could not remember the conversation.

wor to the defendant, the damage had been caused by the default of the plaintiff.

Mr. Bexsasix, Q.C., and Mr, Horxe Payxz, Q.C., appeared for plaintiff; and Mr. Wester, Q.C., Mr. Guitx, Q.C., and Mr, Survzy, represented the defendants, Plaintiff is a merchant carrying on business in Manchester, London, and Shanghsi, and defendants are manufacturers of cotton goods at Manchester. Between November, 1875, March, 1876, the defendants, at the plain: tiffs order sapphod him with a large quantity of Grey Shirtings for exportation to China. The goods were recognized by plaintiff as being heavily sized, and were bought at prices varying from 6s. 74d. to Jo. O24. per piece, and were S$-lbs, Upon arrival of the goods at Shanghai in various vessels, it was found that about one-half were damaged by brickish red streaks appearing on the top and at the ends of the ales, AVhen the goods wore old at Shanghai, plaintiff' £1,626, which the pr The plaintiff alleged thi the alt ome substances defendants by some colouring matter having been volatilized from the tarpaulin which had been used packing of the goods, summing up, the Lord Chi portance of the case as involving affecting manufacture. He referred: notoriety of the practice of adulte th_a view to cheapening fabrics "until the article was quite unfit for the purpose for which it was destined," but ho did not suggest that there had been any intentional act of the kind by defendants in the present case, It would, however, be for the Jury tosay whether the deleterious ingrediorite {inthis were introduced by the negligence or mischievousness of any one in efendanta' employ. The broad facta that from some cause or other a discolouring substance appeared on half of the large ud pieces of shirtings contended that it arose from the.cking as being made from alleged that it arose from is Lonosmmr—How about the kid, Mr. Robertson? You give it to the defendant in Plaintifi—I am quite agreeable to abide by phar Tiny there, "He is at liberty to keep you Plaintiff You told his Lordship just now Zau had no more questions to aay and therofore you should not speak now.

His Lorpsure—There is nothing in the letter about the goat?

Plaintiff—No, Only the kid, Defendant—And I have banded in that letter to show my right to the kid, His Lonpsur.—The kid is clearly yours, but you mast return the goat.

Defendant—Your Worship decides I must return the goat.

His Lonpsure—Yes, You must return the goat, but as to the kid I think there is evid- Pa" fence that he gave it you. Aa to the goat he has distinctly sworn that he never intended to you. ppetendant—He amore the same about the of thie particular goat and kid.

Plaintiff—I find Mr, Poignand has disposed

Defendant—You are perfectly correct in saying 20, His Lorpsure—Then the question is what in the value of the goat, Plaintifi—Before I went away ality milk, She cost me $7.50. Since Thave been without her I have had to pay $1.50 per month for milk. Ihave done that ever since Teame back from Nagasaki. Your Lordship can reckon what it hae cost me.

His Lonvsire—Bat that would not be the value of the goat.

Plaintiff—1 claim $10.

I think that is. reasonable, with the costa of the Court. lad no right to go.

'His Worsmir eaid he did not believe the prisoner's statement, and imposed a fine of $5 and coste, or in default of payment 10 days' imprisonment, 18th March.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account