Esq., H. B. M. Vice-Consul, also on the bench.
Canter & Ca. v. Dee-say.
Claim. for Tls. 4,313.99, the amount of loss uncertain silk shipped to London in July 1872, on Defendant's account.
This was a case referred from the Mixed Court, which had decided in favour of plaintiffs, but where the Magistrate and the British Assessor had been unable to agree as to the amount that should be awarded.
Mr. Caner explained that the two parties to the case agreed, in November 1873, to refer the matter to be arbitrated before Sir E. Hornby; but the defendant declined to sign tthe necessary bond to be bound by the latter's Aecision, unless the Judge should give what peared to him (Deft.)to be a reasonable verdict. The difficulty was that Deesay said he gave Carter & Ca. special instructions to sell at once on arrival, and the latter denied having received any such special instruotions," Moreover, it there had been. such instruction, and they were neglected, it was the fault of Messrs. Broughall & Ca., their London Agents, not Carter & Co.'s. Deesay Jenew the former, and knew the consignment was going to them. Plaintiffs contended therefore that, as between themselves and Dee-say, they were entitled to recover from him the amount of the loss. They (the plaintiff hiad_been guilty of no negligence or dis obedience to instructions, as was shown in the very lengthy written evidence which had been prepared for Sir Edmund Hornby, and which was now before the Court.
Mr. Mxpuvusr suggested that the state-monts prepared for Sir Edmund Hornby should be accepted at this hearing, and to this both sides assented, Drg-say:—I understood from Carter & Ca, that they wore to send the Silk to Broughall tobe soli. I told Mr. Rees to sell on arrival. Instructions accompanied the goods. The transaction was put through, through Messrs. Carter & Ca. A security chop passed. I claim that there was delay in the sale, and hold Carter & Ca. responsible, because I'don't know Mr. Broughall. I knew that the silk was sold at home, Mr. Carter did sond messages when I wrote. Both firms are Chungho's (the hong name of Carter & Ca.) Tnot only refuse to pay the claim, but I claim against Carter & Ca., for the surplus over my debit balance which I lost through the silk not being sold at a suitable season, The Taorat asked Mr. Carter whether the two firms (Carter & Ca, and Broughall & Ca.) were connected.
Mr. Carren,—No.
Witness continued—To the Court—I have no evidence that there is any connection. know Mr. Carter was merely acting as inter-me diary.
The Coxsvi—'Then how can you hold Carter Ca. responsible? You have your remedy og. Broughall.
Plaintiff claimed because Carter & Ca. were the Agents, and because Messrs. Broughall -were-beyond his reach.
Me. Coren read a series of extracts from otters "and telegrams, to prove that there 6 no market in London during the tinie the silk was hold. here were quotations, but it was impossible to sell at them.
Dee-sav alleged that other silk had been sold, and produced circulars.
The Taorat thought it was curious that, if other sih had been sold, this could not be so.
Mr. Carrer explained that this silk was a special kind (Keashing Taysaams), and even if afew hundred bales were sold, itchd not follow that Broughall & Ca. would be able to place their especial Jot. There was no demand for anything like the whole stock on the market. A pw might quite as likely secure what lo wanted from another firm.—Dee-say had not ordered the silk to be sold without reserve; if he had done so it would probably have been sold. He ordered it to be sold at market rates, and market rates were not obtainable. If you asked a broker the value of your silk, he might say it was worth 20s., but if you askd him to buy it he. would not give you 19s, or even 18s. Nobody wanted 'A long argument followed in Chinese, be-Che-moh, I rented a house in the village of tween the Consul, the Taotai and the Plaintiff, Kwo-pu, about 8 miles S.E. of Che-moh, and which resulted in the Taotai's declaring thatin trade. preparations to spend the winter there. his opinion both parties ought to forego their On the day of Nov., I started in the several claims;—a proposition against the jus-morning on horseback, to spend Sunday in tice of which the Consul vehemently protested. the village of Tung Ida-en Taz, passing through Eventually judgment was reserved. the market town of Hwa-yin, which I reached about 94 a.m. There was crowd standing about the theatrical stage, and as I passed Chefoo, 24th May. some of them cried out "'ta ta, sah sah," "'strike Before H. E. the Taorat and E. T. SHEPPARD, him, kill him," and threw stones which Ese., U. S. Consul. struck the horse, but not me, Passing by, The suit of Rev. H. Corbett versus certain went on to Tung-kia-en Tez; on my.return, rioters in the district of Che-moh was com-reached Hwa-yin about sunset. When 1 menced before the Taotai and the U.S. came in sight, the people left the theatre, Consul, this afternoon, and od the ives on each side of the 'A brief resume of the case up to the road which I must pass through, Many had present time is as follows:—Last Dec., Mr. stones in their hand and at once commenced Corbett, who had gone to this region to throwing them at me. I was struck several spend the winter, was attacked by a mob on two occasions, and obliged, finally, under times, but not much injured. Several Iundted persons were comiected with the cover of the night, to leave his rented house attack. 1 said nothing to irritate them. and return to Chefoo. As the local officer I rode swiftly through and past the crowd. did not apprehend and punish the rioters, the All were strangers to me, and I could not case was brought before the Acting American identify any of them. I noticed particularly a Consul here; and, in consequence of his young man in mourning, who. allowed, ston: representations, the Taotai appointed a Depuing me, to the extreme end of the town. ty to repair to Che-moh, and, in connection with the magistrate there, to investigate the The next aay, T went to the Yamun in the city and handed to the magistrate a written matter. This deputy made report to the statement of the above facts. He said he Tao-tai in due time, denying almost every would certainly issue a proclamation to statement in the Consul's dispatch. The Tao-restrain the people, and would punish the tai, following the line of the Deputy's report, offenders. Ina day or two, a person from the declared in his answer to the Consul that Mr.
Yamun brought proclamation and showed Corbett had not been stoned; that his proper-it to me.
Tt stated that Mr. Corbett came to ty had not been stolen; and' that the people Che-moh in accordance with the treaty, and were kindly and peaceably disposed; station the same time that the disturbance. had that he must not be interfered with; that the people could listen to him or not, a8 they arisen from an attempt on the part of some pleased, but must not molest him. The proof the native Christians to kidnap children. clamation stated also that the local magist: Ho closed with a request that the Consul had received instructions from his superior should instruct Mr. Corbett in the future to officers to protect me, On the next mar-restrain his native converts from kidnapping Ket gathering, which occurred two days children, and that the matter would be drop-afterwards, 1 went to Hwa-yin, where 1 ped, thus leaving the rioters without punish-learned that the proclamation had not been ment, and the missionary under the implies: ted. 1 sent Lin Lung-me to call the tion of bringing false accusation inst the jocal constable and ask for the reason for this, people of Che-mel and the native learned that this proclamation, though not tudor the charge of Kidnapping posted, had been received, and was in the hands 'On learning these facts, Mr. Shophard, the Of the constable. 'The next day, I sent. a U.S. Consul' for North: China, came from note to the local magistrate, informing him Tientsin with instructions from the American that the proclamation had not been posted, Minister to insist on an investigation of the and urging him to attend to this matter at affair, and that the guilty parties be punished, once, as I found difficulties might arise of a Strengthened by such instractions, he cimeto serious nature in other places, where the people Chefoo, intent on business, and has acted from the first with his characteristic prompt-bad ate Soon Prager it it ness and efficiency. other proclamation, which he tera few days, the a
The native authorities had manifested a At the next fair at Hwa-yin, it bad not been rear unwillingness to have the accused posted, and was not posted till towards avenin, raught to trial, and it was currently ro-when I had made inquiries in the town about ported in the district of Che-moh that there it. This was about a week after the stoning. On the 17th of Dec., after breakfast, I went hould an attempt be made fo. apprehend the Would be a general rising of the people, on horse-back to the U-Hwang Temple, accom-rioters. It seems that the local magistrate panied by Lin Lung-me and Wang lien hing, had been so overawed by the resolute attitude Several of the native Christians also went to of these disturbers of the peace, that he was attend the fair then being held there. I tied powerless to do anything but invent new sub-my horse toa tree and walked to a vacant terfuges to screen the guilty parties, and spot west of the temple The people sur-stave off a trial. rounded me at once. told them that I had The arguments made use of by Mr. Shephard not come to injure or interfere with them, during his previous visit two months ago, and that Lad a passport authorizing me to secured from the Taotai a promise that the come and teach Christianity. Thus I tried accused should be brought to Clefoo to be to quiet them, as did Lin Lung-me; but the tried before himself ju connection with Mr, people commenced throwing stones. I then, Shephard; and the 19th of May was the day passing along under the outer wall, entered fixed upon for the trial. The local officer the temple, hoping that the crowd would having proved himself utterly inefficient, the worse. They, however, entered the court, Taotat appointed Sung, the Fu-shan. hien, to sull throwing stones. I then tried to find make the arrests. He arrived in Chefoo on the local constable, but could not. Retiring the 17th inst., with most of the parties accused to the inner court, Istopped a moment on in charge, numbering in all, together with those the verandah. the people still followed mo and threw stones. After this I entered the who wore already here, twenty-eight. temple and fastened the window-shutters, Mr. Shephard came down from tientsin on but. the people from outside threw stones the 2ist inst., and preliminary interview was gainst it. The inner court was soon filled hield on Friday. last, when it was agreed With people. Some stones thrown in through that the trial should commence to-day. the oe struck me. Some of these stones The parties met according to appointment were larger than an egg. Atthis point, a in the Custom House at 2 p.m. A short man whom I did not know, came to me and timo was. spent in farther determining upon the requisite, preliminaries, after which they said, "You must get out of harm's way." proceeded to business. The Taotai, who scorns replied "I have no way to get out." Hie answered "Give me your riding-~whip and quite equal to the situation, conducts the follow me." He took the whip and opened suit and makes his own notes, away with it on cither side, and I followed Rey. H. Conorrr was called to the stand, him rapidly; he at the same time saying to and, in answer to the Taotai's questions, gave the crowd, "I know you all, and I will bear a fall statement of his grievances, of which testimony' against you, if you injure this the subjoined is a summary man." While we were hurrying out, a few I went to Chemeh in Sept. last, taking men fell down behind us, blocking up for with me my three children, a nurse, ole moment the way; and thus helping to servant, and four assistant preachers. After facilitate my escape. I tried afterwards to spending two months in different villages in find who this man was, so as to make an
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.