The Archive · 1879

Charge of Theft Against a Chief Mate

Prisoner, who is chief mate of the ship Birkr, was brought up in custody charged with feloniously stealing 28 bars of iron of the value of Tls. 7.00, the property of the master, Captain William Reynolds.

Captain Wrettam Revsoxps deposed—I am master of the British chip Birker. The prisoner is my chief officer. Ho haa held that position since the vessel was built, a little over three years ago. He was chief officer when I took charge of sp, and he is still on the articles, Wo arrived in Shanghai on or about the 6th March. Iam not to thoexact date, We came from London with a general argo, chiefly, however, consisting of iron. 'There were several descriptions of iron—bar iron, angle iron, boiler plates, ships' plates, rod iron, nailrod iron, fire bars, a great amount of scrap iron, and also some horse shoes. It the mate's duty, if on board when the cargo account of the quantity employed for the purpose cargo taken on board in London. Prisoner did not tally any of the cargo that was then taken in, I cannot speak positively, without reference to the log, which the ship, as to the date we comme: discharge cargo in Shanghai, but I think i was on the 8th or 9th of the mouth, It wi the duty of the prisoner, as chief mate, to take an account of the cargo discharge When I asked him what cargo had been di charged, it was his duty to show me hi accounts, and from day to day I asked him for his accounts, and be showed them to m The last time I saw his book was yesterday morning, but I may say I had access to it at

table, It was about half-past nine o'clock yea-time, It wan generally. on the cabin terday when I last looked through the book, I then went through the account of all the cargo that had been discharged, and di took at any particular portion of it. Subsequently I received some information from 8 Chinaman, in consequence of which I went to the Central Police Station. there got constable to accompany me to the Hongkew Wharf, Ltbere found 98 bars of iron which Mdeutified ce part of the cargo of the Bivke. The two bars produced were among them. I identified some of the bars as being part of the cargo of the Birker by the letter *B" which eas stamped on thew, and Lue others Lidentitled by the letter *L," which was painted on them in whit it. On the two bars now produced but the letter "L" not easily seen, 'His Lonpsaip examined the two bars and exer, as be himaele could not make out' the then remarked that the Captain must have good letter '*L" on them. It was all very well for the Captain, who knew where to look for it, to say the mark was there, bat he could not if, and they must have some better of the identification of the iron than It was a question whether it would not be better for them to be playing bowls than wasting their time with such vague evidence.

Mr. Srarextxo, Inspector of Police, who was conducting the case for the prosecution, said evidence would be given that the bars taken out of the Birker, His Lonpsutp said that was very well, but he wanted better evidence than they were now having. He could not sco either of the letters *B" or "*L" on the two bars of iron which were produced.

Mr, Sratriixe despatched a constable to fetch' all the bars from the Police Station, #0 that they could be examined.

Witness coutinued—I did not examine all the bare, I only examined two or three of the Station. I'did wot examine the now produced. When I found the Wharf, they were concealed in a small lighter boat,' They were stowed in the bottom of the boat and covered with planks, Texamined a few of the bars, and they had either the mark "L" or "8" on them, I knew the bars of iron which composed part of the cargo of the Birker, were marked "L"

by the bill of lading.

I have not of lading with mo.

His Lonpsusr said the Lih of lading would have to be produced. session, and that gentlemen lad promised to Witness said it was in br, Taumeyor's po be present and produce it, STR.PLING said he instructed the witness to have the bill of lading with him.

His Loxpsmrr told the Captain that he was trifling with the time of the Court, and that if he wished to prove his case he must produce the best evidence he had. The bill of Inding would have to be produced.

Sergeant Witsox was sent for to ask Mr. Taumeyer to attend the Court, and bring the Dill of lading with him, Witness coutinued—I cannot say whether the marks in the Dill of lading and those on the iron correspond, I think the letter is the only one given in the Dill of lading, but I should prefer to say. no more~ on that point until the bill of lading is produced, The foreign constable was with when I found the iron in the boat, There were three Chinese on the boat at the time, We, myself and the constable, took one bar to the Police Station, That bar was stamped with the letter "*B." I did not look for any other letter on it. I did not seo the letter "L" on it. In addition to the constable I have named, who was an Englishman, there were Mr, Taumoyer and the Chinaman who had bought the iron with me. I donot know whether a Chinese constable was with us or not, Mr, Taumeyer was with ne simply because he was the eyner of the iron which was supposed to have been stolen, The iron was otsigued. to Mr. Primrove, but it belonged to Mr. Taumoyer. The English constable gave instructions for the iron in the boat to be conveyed to the Police Station, I know of my own knowledge that we had a shipment of this kind of iron on board the Birker. it was shipped in London, I cannot say the exact number of bars we bad of this description without reference to the Lill of lading, T know that there was a dispute in London about this particular shipment of iron, The docu. ill of with it.) According to it 8,220 bara. shipped, but the shippers claimed that there we 8,276 bars, and the dispute in Lo umber of bara that had in thie way. 'The iron was London from another ship which brought it from Antwerp. Daring the tranebipment there arose a dispute as to the tallying of it, and it was settled in this way, that whatever over 8,' bars wore to be delivered: here if these 28 bars, alleged to have boon stolen by fauna in the ship. We delivered 8,220, and

thomate, we found in excess, T have a receipt for the delivery of the 8,220 bars, I have not it here now. The 8,820 bars were deli vered to the order of Mr. the delivery being completed the day Lofore yesterday, I think, I knew then that there were some bare over, but T did not know the an f to the Dill of lading white, +B" white, and "D" white, The prisoner reported to me that there wore some hi i of the number stated in 8,276 ba ioned la the bill of lading which is not signed by me, but by the owner of the ship. The shipper of the iron said there were 8,276 bars, but the tallying clerk gave the return as 6,320 bare, and by ageeement it was arranged, a8 I have said before, that if it proved that there were more than 8,220 bara in the ship they were to be delivered. The mate did not report to me the number of bars were in excess of the 8,220. I did not a the number in excess. knew that they were in the hold of the ship. I gave instructions to the mate to keep the iron in the last, and then we would to the rightful owner. I gave him structions both verbally and in writing, I produce the written instructions I gave hi obtained them from the prisoner, Thi instructions were contained in a letter dressed by mo to him dated the 25th March. (Letter produced). This was after ho had reported to me that there were some bare in excess of the 8.220. Either before or after 1 gave him those instructions I did not give him any authority to dispose of any part of the cargo of the ship, nor had be any authority from anyone else to do #0, $0 far as Iknow. Up to the time of the prisoner's arrest he did not inform me that he had disposed of any part of the cargo, I charged him on board the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account