Shanghai, 15th July, 1874.
A Naval Court of Enquiry was commenced this afternoon into the charges subordination brought by Captain Mont smery, of the ship Arratoon Apear, against CHARLES, first officer; and CHARLES Tacaant, second officer of the same ship, during the voyage between Swatow and Shanghai.
The Court wae composed ae follows Lieutenant G. H. Davis, commanding H. M. on-venal Frolic President; W. G. Srroxcu, H.B.M, Vice-Conaul; Captain Tost P,&O, steamer Malwa; and Captain MAvpi of the Frolic, officiated as clerk of the Court. of the James Sheppard Mr. Couns, Paymaster During o portion of the day Sir Edmund Hornby, Chief Judge, was also present, but I, B, Eases, barrister, by permission of the Court watched the case on behalf of Captain Montgomery; and Mr. from Messr, Siomston & Ca, the agen consist © ship, also attended ti Court a a Shortly after the close of the magisterial investigation on Tuesday, Captain Montgomery, acting upon Sir Kdmund Hornb;
Medhuret, Esq., LIB, M. Consul, for a C.
gestion, made application through of Enquiry, in consequence of the grave counter charges made against him by the first and second officers; and Mr. Medhurst took the necessary steps to convene a Court.
The Court first called upon posed to the same facts, and in nearly the Captain Moxrcoxsny, who, sworn, de-same terms as those fully stated in our, Police Reports of the 'I4th instant, 80 that it is useless to repeat them here. added that when he found the first and second officer had taken the ship entirely out of his hands, he allowed them to steer their own course, as he saw the ship was not going into irom E, N.. E., 80 a8 to go outside day ec Th oe altered the course the Lammock Roche.
By Mr. Eames—I had no farther trouble with them after that. I give the position of the ship's head by com The compass cwatpoints of Bastorly deviation. Wren steering KN. &. by compass we were going East, My object was to get the Lammock Rocks well on board so as to see them, and avoid dangers on the other side, I mean sunken gers. I have been twice as mate, and twice as captain, through this channel before. When going through this passage, it has always been my practice to get well off the Lammocks. After I saw the mates were resolved to go outside the Lammocks, I gave all the courses. No one else interfered. I changed the course about 10.30, about a point at a time, and so brought the ship up. When the officers insisted on going otherwise than the course I gave, the second officer said I was druk, and called me a low mean fellow, He also abused me otherwise, but I cannot remember his expressions. I had had previous is difficulties with the second officer, and had put him off duty two or three times for insolence, The Prestest,—Have you got the logbook here Prosecutor—My official log-book is here.
By Mr. Eases.—I have not had disputes with them about wages. They have not claimed higher pay. The second officer wanted to go home. He wanted his discharge, and I told him I would give it to him when opportunity offered. I produce a letter I received from the second officer in Calcutta, requesting his discharge.
the Courr.—That was some months before the present disturbances occurred.
By the Presipenr.—We ran from eight to nine o'clock on the night in question, E.S.E.
then altered my mind to run outside the Lammocks. I altered the course to E. first, and ran for about ten minutes. I then changed it to E. N. E., and went below to look at the chart. When I came on deck again, I found the course altered without my mission. I gave oners again to steer E.
E., and they would not doit. I then wanted to go back to Swatow, but they would not do that. The second officer was in charge of the deck. The ship was then running E.S.E. Iwas on deck again at 10.30, at that time I bad no further trouble with the officers.
Both mates were here asked if they desired to put any questions to the prosecutor apon what he had already said, and they replied they had no questions to ask hi The Paesipest resumed his questioning and, in reply, Prosecurox said—Whon the two mates took charge of the ship, I had no one else to call to my assistance. They called the chief engineer on deck, to seo if I was drunk. All of them were against me. My crew are Chinese, except three quartermasters. I did not call upon the quartermasters. One of them was at the wheel, and two were down below. My reason for not calling them to my aid was that T did not ike to go to auch extremes as matter, The Presipext—But this was a very serious
Prosecutor—It was so. But there was no danger in going outside the Lammock Rocks, and another reason why I did not like to call them was that I did not desire to' put them against their officers, I did not think they would side with me against their officers.
thought they would not side with me because when the second mate ordered the man at the wheel not to alter the ship's course by my direction, he obeyed him and not me. Alter that I thought the other two quartermasters would be of very little assistance to By Captain Tosttix—The man at the wheel would not alter the course at my order—the second mate dared him to obey uy orders. If he had not done so, I could have put the ship over.
By the Presipent—These officers and quarter masters came with me from England. AsT have said, I have had trouble with the second officer before, several times, about letters. When he did not get letters, lo wanted to leave the ship. Ihave "logged" the second officer for insolence, but never reported him to the Consul at Hongkong.
The Second Mate—I was before Captain Thomsett, the Marine Magistrate at Hong-cong.
The Presrpaxt—Is that so?
Prosecutor—Yes, and the chief engineer as well, but not officially. It was simply a private arrangement to try and settle matters. It does not appear in the log. I merely took him to let him see that he was in the wrong. Captain Thomsett ordered him to return to his duty. Thit was on the 18th of June, He had remained off duty till we got to Hongkong from Saigon.
The PrestpEsr (referring to the log-book)—There is no mention here as to his returning to his duty or that he is in the ship yet. Why did you not enter these things?
ProsecoTon—I thought it would not be safe to enter them—that it would be endangering the ship to let the officers know what charges I meant to bring against them. I entered it in pencil on a piece of paper when I was down below, but not in the log-book, I have not got the pencil memorandum, Ihave no paper to show the result of my taking him before Captain Thomsett. I was satisfied to take the second officer back, I have no witnesses to call in support of my statement, except the agent and pilot at Swatow.
The Presienr.—What was it about the chief engineer?
Prosecutor—The chief engineer came on deck on the night of the 7th, when this occurrence happened. The mate called him up. Idid not ask his assistance. I presumed. by his action that he would not assist me.
The Prestwext—Why did you presume such a thing?
@nosecvToR—I had been treating him for delirium tremen with laudanum and brandy on that day, and I did not think ho was capable of giving mo assistance, Both on that day and subsequently ho was suffering from delirium tremen. He was asking mo every day for liquor." That was my re: for not calling him. I have had some difficulties with him before that, and he now seemed to side with the officers. I have not By tain Biaoee—i did not call the other engineers, because they are all against lad difficulties with them before the magistrate at Calcutta, but they asked me to let them off, and TI did'so.
The Prestwest.—Wero you satietied to bring this man (the chief engineer) away from Swatow with you?
Prosecuror.—Thero is no help for such a thing at Swatow. I did not think it unsafe to entrust the engines to him, He got better and promised amendment after the affair at Cal-cutty, The next trouble I had with them was at Hongkong, when I wanted the engineers to fe, and live under the bridge. They ware iving right aft, but behaved so badly, that {got Aessrs. Siemssen to give me permission to have the berths under the bridge got ready for them. They refused to go into them, but as the paint was not dry I did not then press them to go.
By Captain Tomuts—Did you feel yourself justified in going to sea with a chief engineer suffering from delirium tremen?
Prosecuron—le has not kept watch since he left England. The others kept watch for him. The second engineer was in charge of the engines, but I gave my orders to the first engineer. My orders went through him to the second engineer.
The PrestpENt—Have these things occurred before?
Proszcuron—Yes; the chief engineer was the worse for drink in Calcutta, Ho promised amendment, and I did not want to deprive the man of his engagement. Wo thought the vessel was going tobe sold, and that we should have to part, and that made me more lenient.
The Presioest—But you surely did not think a man with delirium (remans was fit to go, fo sea in charge of engines?
Prosecutor—He is a good man when sober—a very good workman, When I took him before Captain Thomsett at Hongkon; was told he would have to leave the ship if he did not amen Captain Mappex—But why do you nob enter these occurrences in your official logbook. It is most important that they should be entered. What is the official logbook for It is a great omission.
Proskcuror—I thought Captain Thomsett would have entered it. He took down all that was necessary.
Captain Mappex—But Captain Thomeett does not keep your official log. You should have entered if, and Captain Thomeott would have affixed his cal to it.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.