The Archive · 1880

The Afghan Campaign

Luis now considerably over a month since Reuter's Company gave us any news of the Afghan campaign, The last two messages, received here on the 4th and the 9th September, gave us the cheering information of the signal defeat of Ayub Khan and the capture of his uns, One of them told us also that ton thousand, the other that no prisoners had been taken, The latter account seems the more probable, as it is difficult to see what our armies in Afghanistan, themselves finding it no easy task to keep up the necessary supplies of provisions and fodder, would do with ten thousand prisoners. Of General Phayre's advance to Caudabar, no news has been vouchsafed us; and it will be very interesting to know what has become of Ayub Khan himself, and what disposition has been made of the large English forces which the arrival of Generals Roberts and Phayre have concentrated at Candubar, It shows with how little intelligence our supply of telegraphic information is directed, that the only news we have received from India by that agency for more than month isthe information of theappointment of General Roberts, "Fighting Bobsy," to the Commandership-in-chief at Madras, Now that we know how thoroughly the march of General Roberts from Cabul to Candahar has succeeded, it, is amusing to read the auxivus double on the wisdom of the march expressed both in Parliament and the Press. Sir William Palliser, himself " soldier, was the mouthpiece of the Colonels in the House of Commons, who regarded it as a foolhardy exploit, which could only cod in a disaster from which the present Government could bardly expect to recover. The very men who light-heartedly approved the commencement of the Afghan war, were, when the Inst mail left Home, exclaiming against the rashness of sending General Roberts on an expedition which was safely accomplished by General Nott in 1842, and by Sir Donald Stewart in the present war. Fighting Bobsy" had with him ten thousand picked men, a fair proportion of them Europenns, with all provisions for thirty days, and his march was through a well-supplied country in which no serious opposition wns expected: but the fact that he wax marching er Lair, as it ix culled, that is, with no base on which to retreat if necessary, struck with horror the retired heroes in the Houses of Parliament, That audacity is a great element of success in such expeditions; that Cesar, Napoleon, Sherman, all far. nished favourable precedents for the slop, was forgotten: and it was equally overlooked that Sir Donald Stewart and General Roberts himself were as mach in favour of the march as the Viceroy and his military advisers. Its success will doubtless Lave restored whatever loss of prestige Colonel Burrows's defeat may have occasioned; and will have been another proof that if, fas often happens, small commands are allowed by our own carelessness or endue depreciation of our foes, to be defeated, a severe retribution inevitably follows.

We are anxious to learn now what the present Government propose to clu with Candabar, In acknowledging Abdul Rahman as Ameer of Cabul, we specially excepted Cuudahar and its neighbourhood, mumly because it was considered that it could be ensily retained, and would become under our protection a great commercial contre, its population and that of the surren: ing country being supposed to be very friendly to our role The defeat of Colonel Barrows and the subsequent investment of the city, have shown that oar hopes were fallacious, and it appears uow that if we propose to retain Candahar; we must keep a considerable force in the city itself, and spend no small army in keeping open its communications with India. The criminal folly of this last Afghan war is at Inst proved; to retin the country would require the constant presence of an army at an expense in men and money which India cannot, and England will of, afford, Sic Herbert Edwardes, no went authority, las shown by a forcible illustration that in quarrelling with the Afghans and invading their country, we have been playing into the bouds of Russia. "If," he says, " you had " swamp between you and y enemy, would you cross it to attack him, or allow him to cross it to attack you?" There is only one answer to the question; Afghanistan was the swamp between us and our supposed enemy, Russia; the late Viceroy decided to try and cross it with a view of attacking Russia, It has helped to drown himself and the Government which appointed him; it is the task of the new Viceroy to gob out of it as soon as he can with honour.

This Afghan war has proved again the old truism, that if a man does not want to be friends with you, it is nob advisable to try and thrash him into friendliness. Success ix with many people the test of wisdom, and it is therefore fortunate for the new Viceroy that the evacuation of Cabul and the march to Candahar have resulted so favourably; but they would have been wise steps even had they failed, Whether Abdul Rahman will be able to maintain himself on the throne time alone enn show; of the various available pretenders he was the most eligible, and ho at least succeeded in reaching Cabul without any help from us, That his reign will be any assistance to Russian aggression we do not for a moment believe, for the Afghans have shown us again, as mountaineers have often done before, that poor as their country may be they will fight to the death for its independence.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account