Reuiaiow and theology do not form fitting subjects for discussion in the columns of a daily paper, but trials for heresy are undoubtedly matters of public interest. Trials of clergymen of the Church of England for alleged irregularities in the performance of Divine Service are common enough, and one reverend gentleman is at present occupying quarters in the city prison at Holloway for failing to comply with certain legal decisions. But in most of these eases, the clergyman is merely accused of introducing ceremonies not authorised or perhaps forbidden by law, with possibly a statement that the practices to which he is addicted indicate that be is imbued with certain unsound beliefs. But if one wants to see a regular good prosecution for heresy, a prosecution where there are no subtle arguments as to whether standing in a certain position indicates a particular shade of belief regarding some abstruse doctrine, but where the contention on the part of the accusers is that the distinct statements of the accused as written, published and subsequently confirmed by them, are so antagonistic to the fundamental law and doctrine of the Oburch that they have no right to remain in it, and that the Church has right to allow them to remni 6 mast turn to Scotland.
The prosecution of Professor Robertson Smith, on account of his views expressed in the article on the Bible in the Encyclopedia Britannica almost came to an end several mouths ago. His opponents, with a view no doubt to abt support from those who did not bold such strong opinions as the lenders of the opposition did, suggested a sort of compromise between acquittal and conviction which gave general dissatisfaction, and the result was a acquittal which seemed to settle the matter.definitely. The appearance, however, of a fresh volume of the Encyclopedia with an article by the same author on Hebrew in which he re-affirmed many of the statements which were objected tu in the first article, gave his opponents a second chance of which Urey were not slow to avail themselves. In August, the Commission of Assembly of the Free Church appointed a committee to examine the writings of Professor Smith and to report in October, The report of the committee, which was adverse to Professor Smith, was only published on the morning of the day of meeting, and the Professor argued that he was being tried practically for offences of which he had already been acquitted, and further that ib was grossly unfair to ask him to reply to a report which had been in his hands a few hours only. A very able reply, however, he did make, but the Commission decided majority of 270 to 202 to "instruct Professor Smith to abstain from teach. ing his class during the ensuing session, leaving the whole question his status and position in the Free Charch to the determination of the General Assembly." To the charges against Professor Smith we mast for manifest reasons refer but briefly. Itwas contended that the statements which ho made regarding the Scriptures were calculated to produce upon the minds of his renders the impression that they did not present a reliable statement of trath, and that God was not the author of them, and it was maintained that sneb doctrines were antagonistic to the fundamental principles of the Church, and that the teaching of them could not be sanctioned. To an outsider looking calmly at the matter, it appears that Professor Smith's opponents had 1 ensy lusk before them in proving the accuracy of their first statement.
Professor Smith speaks of Deuteronomy as probably the work of "the last editor of the whole history from Genesis to Kings." Again, in speaking of the mauner in which part of the Old Testament was compiled, he refers to the absence of idea of copyright, and says, "Ifa man copied a book, it was his to ridd and modify as he pleased and he was not in the least bound to distinguish the old from the new." If he lad two books he took extracts and "harmonise them as he felt nev sary," avd he says this "curious of bination of the functions of copyist and author did not wholly disappear till uw pretty Into date." Again, his account of the Gospels goes to show that none of the Gospels, as we at possess them, are original tions of eye-witnesses, but are founded partly on older documents and partly on oral tradition, A man in the—position of Professor is undoubtedly liable to be judged according to the impression which his statements are likely to convey, and there appears to us to be no door of escape for Professor Smith from the first part of the charge,, As to the second part, viz,, that the Charch cannot tolerate the tenching of such doctrines, we shall say but little further then to remark that all contention that the views of Professor Smith are in them. selves fair and reasonable seems rather wide of the mark, We can well under. stand that the Conservative party iv Parliament might denounce one of their leaders for voting with the ayes on some special point, while the Liberala might justly find fault with one of their party for voting with the nees, And so in this case the question is not who is right, but it is simply this, are the views of the accused so much opposed to the tenets of the Church that he should be expelled, or do they still come thin those limits which may fairly be tolerated by a body of reasonable mon We must leave the answer to this question to those directly interested. Until lately all the fighting has boon in the Free Church, bet lately the established Charch has had a cnse of it own. A volume of "Scotch Sermons' as created a stir which reminds one of "Essays and Reviews." Mr. McFarlan, the author of two sermons, states "the Scriptures are authoritative only in go far as they are trae." With this statement of opinion we suppose fault can possibly be found, though it is clear that some people would look upon it as affirming the authority of the entire Bible, while others would regard it as robbing the Bible of all authority whatever. Some of his other statements are clearer; he says people "cannot be certain that all the words in the Gospels attributed to Christ and his apostles were really the words they spoke undiluted, undistorted, unexaggerated. Neither can they be absolutely sure that the miracles ascribed to them were actually wrought by them." Whether after having thrown over so
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.