Shanghai, 24th Jan, Esq., Conaul-General, ing as Judge, and Mr, C. Burnes and Captain Bassert, Asscesore, Fav-Cuono v. Cuantes A. Surts, Mr. Warszwaicu? was present on behalf of the plaintiff, Mr. Haxperson, the defendant's attorney, In thia following judgment The Covzr said—Svction 4,107 of the Revised Statutery second edition, provid that the Ad shall note "upon record ti and if the Conswi and his Associates concur in opinion the judgment shall be final, The Avsvciates in this ease are skilled in nautical matters, and therefore are especially competent to weigh the evidence in a case like this. They have arrived at a conclusion, and have submitted their tinding to me in writing, as follows To Davie H. Barter, Esq., Consul-General of the United States.
Sm,—In the United States Court, over which your Honour presided, acted as Associates in the hearing of Fuuchung v. Swith, we, the Associates, lave coe to tite following conclusions, which we trust may meet your consideration and approval.
We have patiently weighed all the yuluruinous and contradictory evidence, and with a spirit of justice tried to fathom the vague depth of hold.—The evident shows the midship mould was ma "The plaintiff state made less by the request and consent of the defendant. This be positively denies. The lorcha proves to he 26ft. Gin. beam and 9ft. din, depth of hold. The contract calls for 25ft, beam, and 10ft. hold. the vessel's carrying capacity to be about the same according to specification in contract. The dil nce in beam and hold nearly balancing each oth cond—One timber less.—We are of this has been proved to be the case, and the defendant entitled to claim for the omission, Tis, 25.
Third—Fastenings (between bolts and spikes.—We judge the defendant is entitled toa for n fastenings be-spikes and through bolts, He spikes wore used than called for dit in admitted award Tis, 200 for deficiency of fasten Fourth—Overtime lorcha was building. This is clearly a breach of contract by th plaintiff, less the time necessary for extra Work, and one course of The defendant entitled to claim for thirty days at Tle. 10 per day.
Fifth—Bad workmanship.—Ther appear to us to be sufficient establish this claim, only many, and not corroborated by Captain Roherts's statement.
Sixth—Extras charged Mang of thea articles, nec and requisi in a well finished vessel, without being ally mentioned, could not in thes interpretation of its meaning be included i this contract, The following taken from the'plaintiffs Lill, we consider as belonging to contract; all others are to be paid for Tls. 10.00 2 days carpeutera and 45 ft. wood for pin rail 5.00 96 feet wood, 24 Ibs, iron bolt days carpenters for 4 Indders, fis. 10, allow half of this sum for the' two forecastle ladders, none for poop...
160 Ibs. of iron pia 00 1.60 2 Iron chain pipes, 100 ibs. " 5.00 1 Iron sheave and screw. n 0.35 1 Dolphin st its place) 3.50 1 Main pump and fit seeseeeee gp 40.00
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.