The Archive · 1882

SHANGHAI, WE!

ae ose of the la Mow Hong versus Cunpman King & Ca,, in whic judgment was given in the Supreme Court yesterday, involved mutters that we believe often arise between Chi and Foreigners occupying the position of the parties to this suit. When markets are unfavourable the Cuiuese for whom the foreigner lias been ordering manufactured goods from Europe very likely to econ their quality with a severer eyo than when trade is brisk. And, unfortunately, the condition of the woollen goods market at this port has, for some time, beau such as to induce the Chinese to aso th utmost vigilance in the hope of obtai 9 ing, if not entire, at least parting, relict from some of the bargains into which they had entered. There bad been dealings between the Ta Mow Hong and Chapman, King and Ca. for some time before the transactions on which this action arose wore entered upon, and about the beginning of this sear the partners in the English house became alarmed as to the position of the Chinese firm's accounts with them, Had Chapman, King and Ca. then sold the goods which they had imported for Tu Mow, (here would have been a deticiency of some'Tels 10,000; and in these circumstances Mr, Butler, the partner in Chapman's who maunged that part of the business, naturally pressed his native constituents for additional mac-gins. The result of that pressure was Uunbthe representative of Tah Mow Hong who had entered into this contract made a payment of Taels 5,168.75 on the 5th of May. The object of this payuiont was the principal matter in dispute in the ease. Vee Teo Foong, who conducted the whole of the business between the man's, stated in his evidence that the pmynicut was made to pay for 50 bales of camlets which formed part of the securities ined by the house. Vee Tee Faung gave hia evidence regarding this payment with grent precision, and some detail, It was made in two bank orders; and, having received them, he said Mr. Butler did not express disapproval of the account, but being busy at the time asked him to come [ater in the evening for the godown delivery orders of the 50) bales of camlets in dispute. It wns stated by Mr. Batler, who was corrobornied by one of his Portu. guese clerks that the payment was! nade to the general account between is firm and the plaintiffs, and that nothing was said about the godown delivery orders for the camlets, It further appeared that no demand for delivery orders was made for ubout two months after this payment. The books produced in Court, and the entries in them were to the effect that the payment was for the camlets, received from Chapman, King and Ca. The latter entry was explained to be a more memorandum made because Chapman, King & Ca. bad promised to give a godown order for the camlets whioh Ta Mow Hong were to sell for account of the English house, All this was contradicted by Mr. Butler, who denied that he had ever asked Vee Tee Foong to sell the goods for him, Clearer evidence in support of contradictory positions could senrcoly have been given. The English ficwm maintained that the payment was made on general account, and the Chinese that it was for the specific purpose of paying for fifty bales of camlets, and that orders for the delivery of those ud boon promised at the time. It did not Appear that the'l'uh Mow Hong, by their representative Vee Vee Foong, returned 1 the evening and olnimed the delivery ihe stated Me. Batlor had promised; and that, of course, went a a great way to invalidate the story of this part of those transactions which they had told in Court. On the other hand it is somewhat unusual to find a Chinese Hong that has been losing money, and whose existence is somewhat precarious, parting with a largo sum of money to secure foreign. ors with whom they had been doing basines. The Acting Chief Justice after giving the matter very careful oon. sideration came to the conclusion that the payment was not stated at the time by Vee Leo Foong to be on the special account of these fifty bales of oam. lots, Tudgmont on this part of the case was therefore given for the defendante, The other questions which formed part of the action were in regard of the right of the defendants to cotoin possession of certain goods for the delivering of which they had granted godown orders, the quality of the goods imported ander certain contracts between the two parties, and of such losses as might be incurred in consequence of. In these points judgment was given for the plaintiffs, subject to the settlement of certain claims of the defendants for rent and other charges, We believe the mercantile community will thoroughly approve the decision of the Acting Chief Justice ofall these points, and particularly on that one in which the validity of godown order was involved, He held that as regards exch particular lot of goods for which

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account