An open meeting of this Society was held on Thursday evening. Mr. J. Fryer, Preident, occupied the Chair, and there was large attendance, including several ladies.
Me. Grayston proposed the resolution: "Phot in the opinion of this H mpt to abolish the freedom of in regard to the consumption of alcoholic beverages is inadvisable, whether such attempt be made by the State, or by solfconstituted private Associations." Ho said that every point of interest in history, whether they turned to that of Greece, Rome or England, hinged upon the question of liberty—liberty for the individual, and, through that, necessarily, liberty for the Stop by step they had in England out this principle of liberty, from the time when the curfew tolled not only passing day but the time when every individual was to go into his house, up to the time when English liberty was crowned by the act of Magna Charta. Onward still they went, and to-day they could boast a political freedom which he thought he might say was unequalled: There was a limit to the legitimate into ference of collective opinion with indi 1 independence. He contended th: every mau had a perfect right over his own health, wheth physical or moral ery mau was sole and independer of his own life, Carry out this principle of collective power overraling private judgment, and there was no violation of liberty that it would not justify. John Stuart Mill, in his Essay on Liberty, had said that the sole and only thing for which mankind were warranted, individually or collectively, in interfering with the liberty of any of their number, -protectiou—that the only object for which power could be rightly exercised any member of a civilized community against his own will was the good of the community; the only part of the conduct one for which he was amenable to society was that which concerned others. Over himself—over his own body and mind he was the sole sovereign. (Applause.)
The Rev. W. L. Groves said he was not surprised that their secretary should have had some difficulty in finding some one to open this debate in the allirmative. thought there were few who would feel themselves honoured in taking that position, He did not understand the wording of the motion. Did any one ima, that anybody was going to abolish the use of alcoholic liquor throughout the land? He wished to know, too, how a self. constituted body could abolish anybody's freedom. The opener had somewhat taken the wind out of his sails, He (Mr. Groves) had intended to make what would havebsen a feeble imitation of Mr. Grayston's oration in favour of freedom; he had imagined that he was defending' the cause of freedom, in the abstract and in general. Their friend had confused two terms, liberty.and. license. The essence of liberty was that it was not unlimited, and to aay that to limit a man's liberty was to invade hia right was not arily a logical argument, Already the sale of alcoholic liquors w: licensed, and this licensing had as its object the prevention of the abuse of these liquors. The sale of alcoholic drinks was prohibited absolutely on emigrant ships, as well as to all persons under sixteen years of age. In 1878 an act was passed closing the public houses on Sundays in Ireland, except in some half dozen of the large cities; and in 1881 a similar act was passod with regard to Wales; and the calls for a similar act in regard to England were nu: merous and loud. Local Option, too, had been widely advocated. The terms of the motion would carry them back in the march of civilization. It was perfectly true that no one had a right to abolish a man's freedom in regard to what only concerned himself, though even here there were ceptions. If he attempted to commit sui cide, and failed, the State punished him (Shame). The sale of alcoholic liquors wa however, injurious not only to in duals, bat to the State. They had h it dinned of the eri England was clu alcoholic liquors, and the State ought, in self-defence, to regulate the sale of article which produced so much misery and entailed so much expense upon them in the punishment of criminals, He thought that if Mr. Gladstone had dealt with this instead of wasting his time over ud petty wata in Eyy; in forcing dure Rules down th of the louse of Commoi joy. W. Murrueap said it was they felt that the of alcoholic ages was immensely injurious that hundreds and thousands of people in England and America had set their hearts uniting their use, or, if possible, preventing it altogether. There was a imilar evil extending throughout the length and breadth of this land—he of ferred to opium, Having himself mingled very largely with the Chinese he could say that he had never met a Chinaman, whether he smoked opium or not, who defended the use of it. The universal ery from North and South, East and West, was "Pat it down; if you foreigners will not bring it, we Chin men will not take it." 1! i been another gigantic evil in the referred to slavery. But the British ment determined that no e kept in the bounds of the British Colonies, and they paid twenty millions sterling to set them free. In the same way, he contended, forcible measures should be adopted in regard to the gigantic evil of drunkenness. Could not every Indy and gentleman before him point to some near and dear frioud—perhaps the nearest an dearest—who had ruined himself with drink? Was it, then, any groat deprivation for individuals to deprive themselves of these things which caused such wide-spread misery? He would support the proposae to abolish the freedom of the few for th" sake of the millions the would be thereby benefitted,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.