ahip—Allow me to suggest th to you. [shall of fact probably, whether the Regulations were intended to apply to this lend in or not, I apprehend that my ing, in effect, on a point of that kind, mill be likely to be upheld by the Court of Appeal, because they will consider that I am in 8 position to know more about that than they do, Can I doubt, can yourself doubt; that the Iand i was vith the limits Was not the British Consulate included Mr. Wainewright—No, it was specially excluded.
His Lordship—But it was within the Timaite, Mr. Waiuewright—One would have thought that if the boundary was the Soo chow Creek it would have been stated.
His Lordship—I have nut the slightest doubt about it.
Wainewright—Well, my Lord, I on the evidence. ip—L have not the alightest doubt that the Regulations were intended to include this ground. I-may aay at once that I shall find that as a matter of fact, and I do not think my finding on " matter of fact of that kind is likely to be upo Mr. Wainewright—Then I might to move for a new trial on the ground that th making any practical obstruction to his doing so, They did perform a rather stupid act of aggression which they lind to pay for, but they did not continue it—they retired from the field altoyether,—auld Mr, Ince Inid out Ts, 3,000 in bu out any further opp: th il, 1 subm that those acts briny thin the law applicable to nat Ju support of this arzoment Mr. 1 ght cited the Gases of Pickard Seara, 6, Adolphus & Lille, p. 475 Freeman Gook, 18., p, 114; Cornish v, Abingdon, 28 L.J. Ex., p. 2625 ex parte Adameon, 8 Eh. Div., p. 817; and Care N.W.R., Law Reports 10, Common Pleas, p. 307. Ho contiuued—Now I say that the Council, by writing that letter in which they jot atopped them from ing this claim, The facts are not ous, but they are pretty well substantiated by evidence. The Sth of the Regulations of 1854 contains a provision that the renter excise any act of ownership ound—that is the laud which is to be surrendered, Now it ce that there have been numerous allowing without any prot ship to ug over a number of years, and by lowing him to lay out money on this land in Luuding it without avy effectual rotest, are estopped now from saying, Now, Mr. Ince, your Labour la in vain, we now come in and say you shan't do anything more with the Ind." I contend that the nota of the Ovuncil, and the omis> of the Council, pr objected to them, 20 far as th goes, That is the first point—th never objected to acts of ownership there have been such acts. Then we have the correspondence of the Municipal Cou cil on the subject of lett ud there I lay particular stress on the letter which fr, Suuyer as Secretary to the Muvioipal Council wrote on the 12th Juno, 1372. That letter your Lordship will bear in mind, was written after the Council had p the position that nothing could unless the foreshore was sur-won—No—that there could be no remission of taxes.
Mr. Wainewright—Yes—No unless the Innd was surrendered, won't gi thing m: ake it, will consider, and it is uunccoasnry for no ut on it at any further length, Lordship—It muy perhaps be cons Mr. Robinaon, if you first deal with the point Ble, Wainewright has raised as to the form of the audit.
Me. Rubingon—1 submit, my Lord, that the form of the quite correct," The cil were not bound to apply to this the defendant used I loh the Council oot a to the publio interest. 1 pretend to have a right to afore rond-material on this ground without the omuer''s consent, Wo any that neither party can utilize this land without the consent of the other, There was nothing to prevent the Council from come ug ton egroument with Mr, Moe that should be allowed to ature road right to tex property or become enhanced Lue at a future time,"
His Lordship—What he meant by that the event of the property being led over to him by the tatepnyers under Regulation 6 of 1869 they would tax it. the age rent th for the pur. pose of storm id materials, which was a matter of ure by the public.
His Lordship—When did they propose that?
Me. Wainewright—In the autumn of 1872. The Council seem to have thought they were very clever, because they said, "It wot do for us to take a lo but our agent will takes lease. We will put our head in nd_aud nobody will see us." Th Oliver to tend to take th guaranteed to good the outlay to him; but I submit that that was on application to lease it from him by the Municipal Council.—Mr. Wainewright read an extract from a letter from Mr. Oliver to Sie. Harwood, dated 2nd October, 1872, applying for a louse of the land in question for the purpose of storing road-materials He coutinued—That was com:
to Bfr. Ince, and he em sidered that the Council were again recognising Fight to the laud, and that in point of foot it that you should that the action should be for a mandatory ivjunotion to him to surrender.
Mr. Robi til, the defendant began to use this land for his own put.
the Gonneil had no locus stands to this Court—and Mr, Cory own that the time he did begin to uso this land was December, 1880, and then the Council interfered.
Mr, Wainewright—Ho stored timber on it before Mr Ro 1 did not obs vps That ovuferred no righto
His Lordship—Tho point which. Bie, Wainewright puts, Dr. Robinson, as it to mo with some force, is that the Regulation provisos that the router surrender" the bexch-geonnd; and as the defendant has not surrendered it, the Council ought to hare proceeded againat him: to mnske him surrender, Mr, Robiueon—When, my Lord ip—Whent That 1 cannot der that the mean all surrender" must be taken red as having unself suggeate very form of suit, and says that will
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.