The Archive · 1884

The Foreshore Question

Tae decision of Sir Richard Rennie in the case of Saunders versus Bell seems to place the foreshore question as between landlord and tenant upon a pretty clear footing up to a certain point, Mr, Saunders is the tenant of Mr, Bell, and, as euch, claimed a right to the foreshore in front of his house on the Soochow Creek. His argument, in foot, was Uuat, as such foreshore or accretion belonged to the property he was routing, all rights over it were included in the terms of his louse, which secured tohim a "river frontage;" and seeing that Mr, Bell had used the accretion for his own purpose, Mr. Saunders prosecuted him for trespass. The Court has now decided that, while any accretion that may be formed in front of such a lot becomes the property of the owner of that lot on his going through the regular forms and paying the stipulated sum to the Chinese Government, the tenant hao no rights over it in any way, except in so far as he can prevent his landlord from hi ing upon it in euch a mauner as to interfere with his light and air. That, in a few words, is the gist of Sir Richard Reunie's judgment; and it is certainly clear enough. Batitis equally clear that it scarcely invalidates the right of a landlord to build upon such foreshore as long as he does not prevent Mr. Bell or any other landlord from' indulging his architectural taste in any direction that pleases lim as long as this important proviso is con plied with, It is by no means certain, lidwever, that the task would be an easy one. The tenant is in a position to say, "Build, by all means, as much as you please; but the moment you interfere' with the view from my windows Tehall apply for an injunction to' stop you." In fact Sir Richard's judguient is like Portis's. "Cut your pound' of fies, by all means; there lies your knife, freshly sharpened; but if you spill a drop of blood, you bring yourself under the law." The landlord might consider that a row of godowns, not more than ten feet high, could scarcely shut out either light or air from @ house every room in which would overtop its roofs; the tenant might object that the moorest dog-kennel would prejudice his view, and sot the law in motion accordingly. As regards the more important que: tion of the Bund foreshore, we do not see that the Judge's decision affects it either way. In the original litle-deeds of Bund lote, the foreshore, and consequently what is now enclosed, is reserved to the public use, the Iand-renters having surrendered their claim This is endorsed on all the British Constilate-General—and referred to in every new deed which is issued from the Land Office. The land is Uhus vested in the Inw Council as representing the general public, and under present ciroumstances cannot be touched. There is only one firm of the Bund lot-boldero who have not surrendered any claim to the foreshore, and they, we believe, have no title-deeds from any Consulate, preferring to hold their Iand on the no quired lities of the Chinese proprietors rather than surrender their foreshore as others lave done. But it is clear that all this is simply a matter of convenience. At present it is no doubt in the publio interest that the foreshore should be left open; that those who live on the Band should have rheic view of the river, and all the light and air they can, Shanghni, however, is a commercial place, and if it increases in prosperity and trade we shall find it more and more given up to commercial purposes, It is certainly possible that, in say twenty or thirty years, the Settle ments north of the Yang-king-pang will be devoted almost entirely to business houses, and that, when we have railways in the land, people will begin to live out of town, Then public interests will require that every available spot of ground be applied to building purposes, and no wsthetic consideration will be allowed to interfere with the utilization of the fine, broad, and most valuable strip of land which is now an enclosed green. Under these ciroumstances those who come after us may seo the Bund turned into a street. just

the row of business premises recently erected on the foreshore of the French Concession' continued, in one shape or arotlicr, as far as the Pablic Gardei, leavitig a thoroughfare ati their river

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account