The Archive · 1878

-CHING-FOONG, v. LANE, CRAWFORD AND

Tue decision by the Supreme Court of the case Ching-foong v. Lane, Crawford & Ca. deserves review, as affecting the subject of contracts generally. The question for decision was, whether the defendants were legally obliged to accept and pay for a cargo of kerosine oil, that formed the subject of a written contract in the English language between them and the plaintif—which contract was concluded through a foreign broker, as agent for both parties. By that contract Ching-foong sold to Lane, Crawford & Ca. 12,000 cases of Devoe's kerosine oil, "to arrive" per steamer Pajanattian. uhar, with a stipulation that "damaged goods and leaky cases should be allowed for in godown." With reference to this last stipulation, it is to be observed that the usual form of contract gives the power to the buyer to reject damaged goods, while in the present case the power to reject was strack out, and it was stipulated in lieu thereof that damaged goods and leaky eases should be allowed for. The Judge of the Supreme Court appears to have treated this contract as a contract by Ching-foong "to supply" 12,000 cases of oil, each case to contain 10 gallons. But if the words of the contract are to be allowed their natural meaning, this seems to us a mistaken interpretation. Ching-foong undertook to supply no definite quantity of oil whatever. Ho simply agreed sell a particular cargo of oil, consisting of 12,000 cases, each containing 10 gallons of oil, laden on board the steamer Rajanattianuhar, provided that vessel should arrive here with the cargo, and subject to that cargo being damaged or the cases leaky. And it is to be borne in mind that Ching-foong personally knew nothing of the cargo, Like Lane, Crawford and Ca., he had himself bought it from Messrs. Melchers and Ca., "to arrive." When the cargo arrived here, it turned out that there had been great leakage, and on refilling the leaky cases according to the usual practice, it was found there remained only 10,798 full cases of 10 gallons each. The defendants contended that this was not reasonable performance by Ching-foong of his contract, as regarded the quantity of oil the plaintiff' ought to have delivered. But if they intended to stipulate for any definite quantity of oil to be delivered, they ought to have provided for that by their contract. Instead of that they agreed to accept an allowance; and the effect of deciding that Lane, Crawford & Ca. were not bound to accept this cargo with an allowance, is practically to strike out from the contract one of its most material terms, or, in short, to make a totally different contract from that which the parties made for themselves. The Judge says that in his opinion the contract only contemplated the "usual per centage" of leakage. This view is, however, difficult to reconcile with the express agreement that the buyers should not be at liberty "to reject" the cargo. Whatever the defendants may have contemplated, the plaintiff evidently did not contemplate any such restriction, and it requires two parties come toan agreement, The Judge mosts this difficulty by saying that this agreement only affected the mode in which damaged goods were to be dealt with, and not the extent to which that mode should be applied. Pat shortly, he holds that the buyers are ab liberty to reject, although they have expressly waived that power. Allusion was made to the state of the cargo when shipped at Hongkong, but with that Ching-foong bad nothing to do. Ho was as much a stranger to the cargo as Lane, Crawford & Ca. When, therefore, the Judge asked the jury whether Ching-foong bad substantially complied with his contract in bringing to Shanghai and landing 12,000 cases of oil, of which 57 per cent. were Teaky, he seems to us to have misdescribed the contract.

The remaining question left to the jury was whether, as rensonablo men and men of business, they thought this cargo of oil could be fairly and reasonably taken into the market and sold as Devoo's Kerosine Oil. Ching-foong contended that, having by his contract expressly stipulated under what terms he would deliver the oil, it was not competent to tke Court or jury to introduce into the contract a warranty that the oil should be saleable on the be saleable for the Japan market. It was Devoo's Kerosine Oil, and dofendants were therefore bound to take delivery, subject to whatever allowance might be fair in consequence of the bad condition of the cases.—Tho result arrived at may be correct legally, but it will strike other minds besides those of the natives, as an unfortunate contradic. tion, that a Chinaman who bad entered into two contracts under identical conditions with two foreigners, to bay from one, and to sell to the other, should be told that ho is liable to perform his contract to the foreigner from whom he bought, but cannot compel the foreigner fo whom he sold, to a similar performance.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account