The Archive · 1882

The Organ Meeting

To the Editor of the Norri-Cntwa Datty News.

Sm,—As I shall probably not be present at the meeting called by the Trustees of the Cathedral to consider the organ question, and as I took some part in the proceedings at the meeting lately hold at the Consulate, I shall esteem it a favour if you will allow me to make a few remarks in your columns.

The very great objections to placing the organ in the north transept were so fully gone into at the last. meeting, and the agi there seems little ers is 80 strong

fear of a proposal in its favour being again brought forward. Indeed it was only because the site was approved of by one or thro people mho had taken a great deal of trouble in connection with the new organ that it ever received serious consideration. With the great majority the site was only mentioned to be condemned. It is possible however that a site which was not very fully discussed at the Consulate may be revived; I refer to the east end or main entrance.

There are three methods of placing the gallery, the congregation entering under organ there. 1st.—lt may be placed in a do this would shut out the stained-gi: window and would interfere very much with the appearance of the Church as seen from the Transepts. It is an uncomfortable place for the choir. Indeed there is scarcely an argument in its favour except that it is better than the transept. Even among its supporters there is hardly one to be found who would say if I had the whole thing to do over again I would order an organ of the size of the new one and put it over the main entrance." As a rule, this scheme is suggested us the easiest way out of a difficulty and nothing more.

'2ud.—The organ may be placed on the floor (or raised one or two feet above the floor) so far in front of the main entrance that the congregation could still enter at the main door and pass round the organ into the middle aisle. I have no hesitation in saying that if a hoarding the size of the organ were erected for one Sunday in this posting there would not be a single memer of the congregation in favour of the site. The passage between the organ and. the pillars would be so narrow and the effect of entering at the back of the organ so bad, that I feel confident that, if erected, it would not be allowed to remain there, Its effect upon the seats would be such that more sittings would be lost than if it were placed in the transept.

8rd.—The organ may be placed close against the main door, the congregation entering at the side door. Bad as the other re, this is ten times worse. When ion is adopted in churches, the entrance is built accordingly. You enter a porch, whence you pass naturally by side doors to the aisles of the church. In the case of our cathedral you will enter a porch with a closed door in front of you and even if the door be built up you will feel a door ought to be the The side doors are so placed that one could never got accustomed to their use, and there would be nothing for it but to build a new east end to the church better suited to the altered circumstances. But the trouble does not end here. To have to wander outside from the porch to a side door and than inside from a side door to a contre aisle would be intolerable. The wholearrangemont of seats would to be altered. e side seats would have to be placed close to the wall, the passage being loft near the colum The contro aisle would have to be do away with, and the seats lengthened so as tomoot. Indeed, the whole of the east end and all the internal arrangements would have to be altered to be in keeping with the organ, and the result would certainly be most unsatisfactory, while the cost would be prohibitory. "It is only necessary to go thoroughly into the details of scheme to make its condemnation certain.

As regards the new organ chamber scheme little remains to be We have a Cathedral with an organ chamber, and if our new organ is too large for it lot na enlarge that chamber. The drawings lately circulated must have proved that there is no ground for saying that interference with the symmetry of the building would be fatal to its appearance. There are many who would be glad if we were not saddled with an organ so large that we can find no place to put it, but if a slight mistake has been made in ordering so large an instrument do not let us try to cure it by ruining our Cathedr Lam, Yours faithfully, G. Taxes Morntson.

15th July.

To the Editor of the Nozrs-Carxa Darcy News.

Srn,—It is to be hoped that something wise and definite may be the outcome of the meeting called by the Church Trustees at the Masonic Hall, and all interested in the future well-being of the Cathedral congregation should endeavour to be present,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account