The Poet-laureate has contributed what we suppose must be called a poem to the May number of The Nineteenth Century. Just as most men judge their wine by the abel on the bottle, so most people read poetry and profess to admire it, not for what is really in it, but on account of the manufacturer, Here is a specimen Tu thin own shadow ant ths eey ign And oont into mystery, nnd the pan this divibletadirite workd Aimong the numerable nmvemerable Sit, sri and sun, Cro? Antenne space amd so on in maundering that would do credit to Tupper's reputation. Or take "the Human Ory'
Talon' be Thy name—Hallduish Hallowed be Thy uaine—Hlatleuiah neither better nor worse than many a Christy minstrel chorus. It is bosh, pure and simple, not even as intelligible as that blessed word Mesopotamia." The mere is offensive, but yet more offensive the attempt to conjure with such terms as infinite, real, innumerable, which convey no idea but one of conceit and affectation on the part of there who seek to introduce them into affirmative propositions. But being Tennyson's this production is doubtless largely paid for, and receives the place of honour and all the distinction that heavily leaded type can confer on it.—The first of M. Ernest Renan's Hibbert lectures is reproduced. It will, we fear, disappoint most readers. From sucha man as Renan, lecturing on such a subject as Marcus Aurelius, we expect something more than, and different from, a mere catalogue of great and virtuous deeds, a picture of amiability which in some respects was almost fatuous, and a resume of excellent maxims and precepts delightful for the compiler of copy-books. We should have desired a vivid picture of the age, against the background of which Marcus Aurelius should have stood out, and no age is more worthy than that of the Antonines of being photographed as few are so capable as M. Renan of photographing it,—Mr. Mallock contributes a dreary paper on Atheism and the Rights of Man, in which the search after the ideal, which in truth lies at the foundation of all progress, is confused with a certain erystallised form of belief in the supernatural. It is simply untrue that both have hitherto in the world's history accompanied one another, but were it true the association need not have been a necessary one. Whether the strong modern movement against a belief in the supernatural be a good thing or a bad thing, it is a fact that cannot be ignored. Its probable influence on the social system and the practice of morals is therefore one of the most important topics for argument. But mere assertion goes for nothing either one way or the other.—Acharming paper on the Ceremonial Use of Flowers among Christians will well repay perusal. The beauty of life in itself and the mystery of the life-giving forces of Nature find expression, inarticulate yet 80 ample and suggestive in flowers, that in all ages they have been felt: as an influence on the human mind, bringing consolation in sorrow, hope into the midst of despair, adding sympathy to sober joys and gaiety to unconstrained revels. In every conjuncture of life flowers have their plac They are strewn with equal suitability over the infant's cradle, around the nuptial couch, upon the dead man's bier, and before the altars of religious worship.
Dr. Clam in the Contemporary Review makes a telling onslaught on the doctrine of the production of species by natural selection. Unfortunately he confounds the more general doctrine of organic evolution with the special form which it assumes in order to apply itself to the solution of purely biological problems, He brings together a very strong case against the English expositors of Mr. Darwin's views, and an overpowering case against the Germans who have not hesitated to reconstruct whole families of hypothetical animals in order to fill up the gaps in the geological record. But the doctrine of evolution stands on a wider basis than he seems to suspect. The evidence for it rests not only on the interpretation of physiological observations, but habits roots in the adopted system of cosmogony. The syllogism with which he triumphantly concludes his paper will not stand a moment's investigation. He propounds it thus in unexceptionable logical form Without verilcation a theoretic conception isa more figment of the intellect The theory of organic evolution is an unverified theoretic conception Therefore organic evolution isa mere Aigment of the A conclusion, however, is not necessarily true because it forms part of a syllogism in Barbara. The terms have to be examined.
An unverifiable theoretic epneeption is certainly a mere figment of the intellect, such as the announcement once made by a grave theologian that the world was created at half-past four o'clock in the afternoon on a certain Friday, the 6th of September. But many a theory that still awaits verification is far more than a mere figment of the intellect. What undoubtedly is true is this, which Virchow has so forcibly insisted on—that no theory
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.