The Archive · 1885

THE FRANCO-CHINESE TREATY

Ir ie perhaps rather a hazardous task to attempt to pronounce definitively upon the merits of the Franco-Chinese Treaty from the unavoidably meagre abstract transmitted to us from official sources, or even the somewhat faller version given by a Correspondent of the Shen Pao. Granting, however, that the schedule we first published fairly represents the salient points provided for in the fall document, the general opinion will be that the arravgemect is on the whole more favourable to China than to France. The firét'artiole, which stipulates that the soldiers of neither nation shall invade the territory of the other, is of course fair enough, and no doubt efficient measures will be taken to prevent any trouble arising from this coi gency. Ibe second article, pro that no arrangements between France and Aunam which would annoy, embarrass, or wound the prestige of, the Chinese Gover ment—the character used is lasa specific, and unless the fall text of the clause goes into the matter rather more particularly there seems here a certain loophole fur future misunderstandings, As it stands, it seems as though China had obtained a right to dictate to France whut a rangements the latter should or should not make with Annam, forbidding such as might for any reason he disagreeable to her; so that here, almost at the ry outset, we find that France has vou a deliberate acknowledgment that China has a right to interfere in Frauco-Annamese affairs! Or, taking the Shen Pao's version, that she may define the attitude Annam is to assume towards her ancient suzerain, reserving to herself the right to protest against any action that sli mental to her dignity. translated arrangements' means more strictly, treaty or contract, ems scarcely applicable subsisting bette conquered country and its conqueror and it looks as though it had been lected as implying a refusal on the part of China to acknowledge that An has actually become French soil, Still, it must be remembered that we lave not the official text of the Treaty before us, and that we only able to deal on the present occasion with what is confessedly no more than a resamé of the complete rument. The provision that a Boundary Commis. sion shall be appointed to settle which forms the third article, is no doubt a good one; and no objection that we see oan be urged agains passport clause which follows, however, will occasion some slight surprise. Pao-sheng and Langson are, apparently, not French territory; on the contrary, they are to remain ander the fiscal administration of China, and France is to acknow' 1 the most formal manner possible—namely, by sending Consuls to reside there, The Shen Pao expr "north of Langeon," is too indefinite to form any basis for argoment, and while it may be correct it is not official. We can only argue upon the version that was received by the local mandarins and by ourselves; and in the provision as therein stated it is difficult not to see afiual French defeat. Such an arrangement would have been impossible if, when they had actually gained possession of Langson, the French had been content to hold it. The fatal mistake they made in deserting it to engage in a useless pursuit has been attended with what all Frenchmen if not all foreigners will agree in considering a most disastrous and regrettable rosult. Langson is the place where Col. Dagenne met with the disaster that resulted in the bombardment of Foochow, Keelang, and Chinhai, the seizure of the Pescadores, the stoppage of rice~ shipments, and the wholesale shedding of blood. It was at Langson that, according to the French theory, the act of treachery took place whioh ecossitated, or at any rate led to, all the trouble, mischief; and wasteful expouditure of the past year, It was ab Langson that, only a few weeks ago, the French achieved a signal victory followed by a signal and most exasperating defeat; and now that they are not to have Langson after all, but simply to reside there as aliens, represented by Consuls accredited to Chinese tax-collectora, the position must be "ast galling. Whether any other artaugement would have been more consonant with poetic justice we need not now stop to enquire. We have never held it as proved that treachery did take place a yearsago, while the purity and righteousness of the French cause ab initia is a question that has been threshed out to a gauzy thinness and rownins a question still. At any rate we have no intention of reopening it; we simply point to the net result of the whole business, and lot our renders draw their own conclusions, The next point is that commoroiul relations are to be established " by Innd" between Pei Ch'i and the two Chinese provinces of Yunnan and Kunngsi. Who Songkoi, or Red River, is, then, not to be opened; and it would be interesting to know on what ground this has not been insisted on. It is true that Mr, James George Scott, in his recent work on "France and Ponquin," points out that the Red River is, after all, not worth having commercial highway, Many causes combine to render it comparatively useless, and it may have been considers ations of this nature which decided the French to waive their claim for the right of open navigation, Still, the fact remains that, to all appearance, the claim has been waived; and Lhe Chinese ure scarcely likely to Iny much strews upon the actual reasons which led to the abandonment of the desi by France, That the latter country is about to construct a railway in Pei Eh, or the north of Tonquin, is matter for congratulation, though here again we fail to see why the fact should Lave been stated in an instrament of mutual agreement, Tonguin belongs either to China or to Fre If it longs to China, France has fought for an idea, gained nothing, and lost everything. If it belongs to France, she can do as she likes there, and it is no more necessary to inform China that she is going to make a railway than that she is probably going to open ca/is chant ants. It is not stuted where the termini of the railway are to be; if one is to be on the Chinese side of the frontier a great gain will no doubt have been procured, but of this there is no mention, It is true that the Chinese words Pei Ch'i, that we have translated "the north of Tonquin," eau literally "the north boundary but the term is applied to the northern

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account