The Archive · 1882

THE "PEKIN" COLLISION CASE

muster of the Hattie Tupley, Mr. Dows Mr, Warwzwnianr appeared for the

dull for the Ownora of the Eivo, and Mossra, Latham and K, Robinson for the P. Company.

The petition of the Muster, of the Hattie E. Yapley is as follow The Hattie B. Tapley is a ship of 907 juter, and was at the time of the fter mentioned mauned by a crow of sixteen hands all told, She was on jew South Wales, to 'B. Tapley had been anchored in Yaugteze, near the mouth of the Ri iting until there wa admit of Ler crossing the thor n ae, day of August ripley weighed anchor the mouth of the Ri Woe ded towards whangpoo assisted by two at moly, the tug Heron, which wes the tug Zw, was on the star. board side of thi ip, but which shortly went alead to tow, id ship ahead at th

fixed and huming brightly, and. a good look Papley ha regulation lights properly sot the The Halte

out wae kept on board 0 said tugs also had their regulation and buroing brightly.

4.—Under thone circumstances, and while 1 Papley was turning' round and board the Hattie E. Tapley, on the Hattie B. Tapley's sta distant xbout two m 5.—After turning partly round the Hattie Tapley proceetied slowly tow: Lismore wreck: light-vessel on a cou and about parallel to the southern limit of the White Sector of the Woosung Tight, and with her head pointing between South by West and South-west by West, gradually turning more towards the point, but the Petin, lusterd of keeping out Of the-way and passing the Hattie 2. Tapley on her starboard, ported her elm and at-¥empted to pass ahead of the Hatlie E. Tapley and caused immediate doeger of cullis and although thereupon the engines of th tug Heron were reversed full speed astern, the Pekin struck the Eico on her starboard side and sank her, and the Hattie E, Tapley, having no time to stop her way, ran stem on into the Pekin and thereby sustained considerable dam 6.—When about " mile distant from the Pekin the Pilot in charge of the Hattie Tapley had caused two short blasts to be Viown by the steam whistle of the tug Heron, and this sign jao repeated twice before the collision.

said collision and the damages and quent thereon are attributable to ice and improper conduct of those "Pekin, "No hame is attributable to the Hattie E. Tapley or to any one on board of he ep or proper extent, ported her helm

pass ahead of the Hattie 2. Tapley.

0.—The Pekin improperly attempted to 11.—The Pekin improperly neglected to ease hier engines and improperly neglected to atop and reverse her engines i ie.

And the ssid Robert Ernest Wainewright prays the Honourable the Judge to pronounce for the damage proceeded for, to condemn the defendants therein and in costs and to refer the said damage to the Registrar assisted by Merchants to report the amount thereof, Towhich the owners of the Pekin reply 1,~The defendants admit the allegations in paragraph 2 of the petition, 2.—Tno defendants have no knowledge as to the truth of the allegations in paragraphs 1, 8, 4, and Got the petition and donot admit defendants deny that the Hattie B. Tapley.—As to paragraph 5 of the patitiou, the took the course alleged and th: the Pekin caused immediate danger of colli admit that the colli allegations in the remainder of the said paragraph they have no knowledge and do not admit them.

4.—Tho defendants dew the all ations cout in paragraphs 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11 of the petition, '5.—Save as herein appears the defendants deny the legations of the Pekin, a screw steamer of the not istered tonnage of 2,125 tons mauned by a crew of about 43 hands all told. ig her on her starboard side of the channel bringing the Hattie E, Tapley and her tugs Those in charge of Tapley's bow apparently to tura her head more towards the Whampoa a hoard side of the Taplry, part 14,—The Pekin proceeded on her port helm, but the Hattie E. Tapley did not turn towards the Whangpoo, but came on towards the South Bank, and the Lismore light heading about south and at right angles to the Pekin.

15,—The Pekin was uow close to the Lismore light, which was on her starboard bow, and she was about 400 yards from the Hattie B. Tapley, which was on her port-bow. Those la charge of the Pekin, still expecting rose the Hattie E, Tapley got straight for her course up the Whangpoo Channel, as soon as they saw that they could go further to starboard without hitting the Lismore wreck light-boat, put the helm hard-a-port la order to give the Hattie B, Vapley every chance of turning clear.

16.—Almost immediately after the helm of the Pekin was put hard-a-port the bow tug of the Hattie alley, which had been towing rather on her starboard how, suddenly chauged her course apparently starboarding her helm and attempting to cro bows of the Pekin, In consequence of this the Peki engines were stopped and the tog was hi to go astern, but in about thi stem of the Pekin struck th which bad not slipped her hawes her, the Hattie B. Tapley then came stem on to the Pekin, the Hattie B. Tapley's jib-boom and bowsprit, and then her striking the Pekin on the port side feot from her stem, The Hat Tapley rebounded and struck the Pekin again, on both occasions doing considerable damage to the Pekin, The time of the collisions was about 10.30 p.m, aforesaid collision and consequent thereon ar bu:

improper conduct and negligence those in charge of the H Tapley in again on her way to Shauglai, The night was clear and the moon full. The flood tide was running strong. The wind was light from E, to ONE, The regulation lights wore duly exited on board the Pekin, and continued to burn brightly and a good look-out was kept.

On leaving her m: Pekin, of her eigh following a that no way attributable to voard of her, wh it power to avoid or pr improperly neg.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account