The Archive · 1887

Miscellaneous Articles

THE FOREIGN CUSTOMS AS A CAREER

"Tux coming into force of the Opium Agreement of 1885, and the consequent establishment of foreign customs stations at, or near, Hongkong and Macao must involve, if they have not already involved, an increase to the staff of the Imperial Maritime Customs. A similar, but far larger, increase should be brought about by the practical acquisition (if it is to be carried out) by the Service, of the native collectorate of port duties in Kwangtung, and by two conditions which cannot long be deferred, the ning of frontier marts on the borders of Tongking and Burma and the change in the status of Chungking. These circumstances should lighten the block of expectants' (to use a convenient Chinese term), which had become so great that Sir R. Hart was, we wnderstand, obliged last summer to close his nomination list for three years.

The causes of the great popularity of the Service which this last fact illustrates are not far to seek. The throwing open to competition of most branches of the English Civil Service (a change in which it is possible, to an enthusiastic sinologue, to trace the influence of Chinese example) has led to the supply of would-be competition-wallahs' far exceeding the demand; so that any opening is eagerly welcomed by a prox ime access it. But over and above this, the Chinese Customs Service is considered to possess many special attractions. Whether these attractions have a real existence is another matter, and is perhaps beside the question, so long as they are believed to exist. But indeed the present position of a Commissioner of Customs appears sufficiently inviting. His income, as compared with that of foreign officials in China, is still very large, in spite of the considerable reduction made in it by the fall in silver. He lives as a rule in one of the best houses in the best part of the European quarter; he has a considerable entertainment allowance, a large staff of servants, and, generally everything provided that can give him dignity and importance. On the other hand the life of his assistant cannot always be painted couleur de rose. His pay, however good as compared with the salaries of clerks in England, is, owing to the fall in exchange, nothing out of the way in China; and of late his promotion has been slow and uncertain. In a service based, like this, what might be called a patriarchal system, it is not possible, nor indeed right, that. promotion should not be affected by personal considerations. Where the responsibility for the selection of his deputies rests with the Inspector-General alone, he is more than justified in giving the preference to those of whom he has the more intimate knowledge. Then again Sir Robert Hart has never been slow to recognise merit. Further, to use his own words (in his Memorandum to Sir Frederick Bruce, to which we shall again allude), " the cosmopolitan nature of the work to be done called for a cosmopolitan staff, and in the endeavour to carry out in practice what was approved of in principle, a difficult task at all times," Sir Robert Hart may, however, undesignedly, have given grounds for a belief that, to secure rapid promotion in his service it is better not: to be an Englishman.

Still, from an! independent standpoint we think that in the remark of an English member of the service that "the rate of promotion of assistants is in inverse proportion to the amount of their country's trade with China," a certain quantum of truth was sacrificed to the epigram. From all these causes, personal considerations, regard to merit, the cosmopolitan principle, it happens that promotion is little affected by seniority; but this we should regard as, to any able man, adding to, rather than detracting from, the attractions of the service. The only difficulty is, perhaps, that the duties of an assistant are so easy in themselves, and so carefully hedged about by rules, that there is little opportunity for ability to show itself.

Five and twenty years ago the position of members of the Customs Service was in the highest degree un} pleasant. In 1864, at the request of Sir Frederick Bruce, Mr. (now Sir Robert) Hart drew up what might be called an apology for the Foreign Customs, and his memorandum was published as a Blue Book (China No. 1 of 1865). In this careful, and on the whole impartial, paper he traced the causes which had led the members of the young vice to be! looked on as social pariahs.' Before 's establishment foreign merchants in China carried on business on the easy, if wasteful, principle of leaving everything to the compradore, everything at any rate connected with the payment of customs and port duties. But when the service was formed, the new Commissioners declined to recognise the compradore and began to disturb the dreamy existence of the merchant by a cloud of documents which it required him to attend to in person. At the same time the opening of Japan and of new ports in China had obliged the merchant to detach his clerks to the new agencies, and the call of the Commissioners found him shorthanded. The result was an outburst of ill-temper on the merchant's part which often showed itself in many petty ways, such as sending in his application for a permit illegibly scrawled on a dirty bit of crumpled paper delivered by a coolie or a boatwoman. Resentment snd recriminations followed and the result was that the members of the Customs Service were out by the mercantile community. It is however very fairly pointed out by Mr. Hart that owing to the demand for mercantile assistance it became necessary for the Customs, in spite of -the liberal salaries offered, to make shift with men "whose social' position and want of education were prejudicial alike to the standing and efficiency of the offices." At the time he wrote, things had begun to mend. The collapse of the Taiping rebellion had enabled the native refugees, who had crowded into Shanghai, to return to their homes, while the opportunities, created by the rebellion, for making' enormous profits, suddenly ceased. The consequence was a conimercial crisis in Shanghai which brought the men of fixed -incomes to the front. This enabled Mr. Hart to secure better servants and to weed out the discreditable. At, the same time a new generation of merchants was springing up in China, which "unacquainted with the laxity of a purely Chinese regime, felt no inconvenience from the application of Customs' rules." The consequence was a rapid advance in social estimation, an advance which their able head has been careful to foster both by the material advantages we have already enumerated, and by obtaining a recognition of their status (which is primarily only that of his personal aids) from the Chinese Government.

We do not propose to discuss here the relations between the Commissioners and the local Chinese authorities, because these depend so much on personal character. Some Commissioners have always refused to regard themselves as anything more than transcendental tax" gatherers, while others have endeavoured sometimes, perhaps, too successfully) to become the advisers of those authorities on all international matters. Anyway the support given to his Commissioners by the Inspector General has resulted great apparent loyalty to their Chief. in a strong esprit de corps with

We say "apparent," not as in any way disparaging the sentiment, but be cause it is impossible for an outsider to gauge the depth of a feeling partly spring from the conscious dependence in what has been des "equitable despotism." The sys of confidential reports, again, however necessary to enable the Inspector General to form a correct estimate of the char+ acters of his employes, is we think one of the few blots on the system, since it tends on the part of the juniors to an unconscious sycophancy, and on the part of the Commissioners to often unneces sary secretiveness.

On the whole however, we consider the position of a member of the Customs Service a desirable one, and if there were no other: drawbacks than these, we should say to any who had the opportunity offered them to enter it; do so by all means. But there is one other drawback, and that a serious Jone. The Service is at_ present largely held together by Sir R. Hart's personal influence; deprived of this, the rival claims of his lieutenants to the Inspectorate-General would soon go far to break it up. Not only this, but there is no question that the Chinese are anxious to dispense where they can with foreign assistance. All Europeans have been dismissed from the Canton

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account