The Archive · 1881

THOMAS CARLYLE

One of Thackeray's shrewdest and most entertaining 'Round-about Papers' deals with the fate which hangs over the heads of most human creatures of being eventually found out. For yours 8 man may enjoy the reputation of a great post, a distinguished savant, or a popular philanthropist but the time may come when the mask shall be taken from his face, and the man appear in his trae colours before a disenchanted world. The poetaster will then be known to have stolon his brightest thoughts and most flowing cadences; the savant will be soon to be a fatuous empiric, whose theories are the illogical result of untenable premisses, and the philan-thrapist a domestic tyrant, the private practice of whose benevolence bears an inverse ratio to the fervour of his public professions. A wise man has said, Call no man happy ere his death. We are disposed to exclaim, Call no man happy ere the publication of his private life and correspondence.

Tu the early part of this yenr, England lost throe prominent persons, all public writers, and all, in a certain sense, philosophers, It is hardly necessary to say that we refer to Disraeli, George Bliot, and Carlyle. Of the gifted woman whose nom.de-plume stands second on our list, we know, personally, alas but little. So strictly did she seek to hide her own individuality from the public gaze, that she was never even photographed; and she has abstained from Teaving, to future generations, the most precious legacy that it was in her power to bequentlo—her own portrait, painted in ink by herself, An autobiography of George Eliot would have been to the fall as interesting as the autobiography of Harriet Martineau, and far less painful to all thoughtful renders, But it is not to be; and we mast be content with such glimpses of hor noble, loving, sympathetic nature as we find in her published works. OF Disraeli we know more; and however hardly we may judge him in his capacity as a politician, we hear nothing but good of him in his private life. He is said to have been possessed of kindly and endearing manners; we know him to have been a most devoted husband and we read with pleasure the injunction in his will, with regard to the publication of his literary remains, that nothing is to be printed likely to give pain to any living soul. Strange and unexpected mandate from the lips of one whom the world regarded as the typo_of tawdry cynicism; and stranger still, by force of contrast, when compared with the posthumous utterances of the modern prophet, the semi-Paritan moralist, whose admiring disciples were wont to speak of him as Wise old Thomas of Chelsea. The publication of Carlyle's Reminiscences has done more than given pain to hundreds. It has destroyed the faith of thousands—their faith inthe man they revered, almost as one of the old Greek philo~ sophers may have been revered, and whose inflaence upon nineteen-century thought and principle has been wide, and deep, and lasting. It is pitiable to contemplate the dismay which the trae character of Carlyle, drawn by himself, has created in the minds of his best friends; it is pitiable to read the excuses made for him and for this "strange, unhappy book," as Mrs. Oliphant calls it, by those who still cling to the hope of being able to clear their master of the aspersions thrown upon him by himself. We do not refer the perversion of his great intellect as manifested in the atrabilious destructiveness of the views he bold with regard to society and life. These are well known to all. How he affected to regard all existing institutions, social, political, and religious, as gigantic shams; how representative government was the biggest imposture of all, since the people were " mostly fools;" how " tyrant was, to him, the only ft ruler of mankind; how he considered slavery as the natural and intended condition of certain classes how fiercely he railed at those who presumed to question his sophisms, and yet how greedily he swallowed the Hattories he pretended to despise; how, in his view, might was right, and force the only arbiter of fate; how the spirit of enquiry was but another name for mental malady; theca and many other peculiarities of his philosophy need only to be mentioned to recur to the minds of all. In his view, Robespierro must have been.a nobler man than Howard—Napoleop Buonaparto than Wilberforce. types of heroic humanity," says one of his best-informed avd most impartial critics, " were strangely chosen; they certainly wore not the apostles of genuine liberty, unselfish duty, and a generous love of mankind. He could palliate the pratal buffuoneries of Frederic William and the mendacity of Prussian ambition, as if he were utterly devoid of moral sense." Opinions may be found in his writings which might "servo as an apology for the most execrable forms of oppression, and which are absolutely opposed to the spirit of freedom, to the active sympathies of humanity, and to the respect due to the opinions of the bumble and the weak. It has ever been to us a matter of enrprise," continues the reviewer we quote, "that a writer whose works are distinguished by principles more cynical than Man-neville, and more tyrannical than Hobbes, should be regarded with enthusiastic admiration by numbers of persons who profess advanced liberal opinions in the United Kingdom, and even in the United States. The net result of Mr. Carlyle's political opinions would seem to be that a government of Bismarcks or Gambettas is the perfection of statesmanship." This is nothing new; of this we have boon aware of all along. Bat the most atrocious theories are often professed by the most amiable and kindly men. Machiavelli himself, the archetype of cynicism, the preacher of assassination, the apostle of treachery and intrigue, was both soft and humane by nature. The susceptibility of his nerves and the activity of his imagination, says Macaulay, inclined him to sympathise with the feelings of his fellow-mon, and to delight in the charities and courtesies of social life. He was a just and beneficent ruler, an elegant critic of the fine arts, and an earnest, student of philosophy. Something of all this we might have hoped to discover in Carlyle, when the recesses of his mind were laid open to the public gaze. But no, As regards any great ness, sweetness, or generosity of soul with which we bad hoped to be able to credit him, Carlyle is found out;' the solemn sage, whom artiste have depicted stand. ing on Chelsea Bridge by moonlight, with sad, prophetic eyes, and a short clay between his teeth, is discovered by his own act to have been a selfish hypochondriac, not above vilifying the kindly friends under whose hospitable roof he was received, and embittering the existence of his devoted wife by his misanthropic rancour, Those must have been heavy evenings to Mrs, Carlyle, when the ponderous footstep was heard on the stairs outside, and the door burst open, and the grim philosopher stalked in with a sheaf of blotted manuscript in his hands, which be thrast vindictively among the burning coals, and than sat, glowering and morose, till bedtime. Nothing, it seems, could have been more perfect, more uncomplaining, than the devotion of this poor lady to the literary ogre she had married. Yet he never saw it, Ho grumbled at the oxpouso of an invalid-carriage for hor on the railway, and never could find time to procure hor the brougham that would have saved her a shooking accident. No; he accepted all ber self-denial throughout their married life, as though his by right, and then eaid 'Ay de mi! Wae's me!' when her suffer. ings wore relieved by death. No wonder thata man with so warped a disposition should have been a possi-mist. His own intellectual life," says Mr. Henry James, who knew him personally, "consisted 80 mach in bemoan. ing the vices of his race, or drew such inspiration from despair, that be could not help regarding a man with contempt the instant be found him recon-oiled to the course of history. Pity was the highest style of intercourse he allowed himself with his kind. He compassionated all his friends in the measure of his affection for them"—— speaking of poor John Mill'? and poor Frederick Maurice' as if, adds Mr. James, the temple of his friend. ship were a hospital, and all its inmates scrofulous or paralytic..A man of whom this may be said cannot be wholly

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account