The Archive · 1881

Not Mr. Herbert S, Morris?

No, L had not sven' him in reference to the claim, Q.—You said you consulted authorities ABL soterred to books only. [did not reter to Mr. L. 8. Morris or Mr, Robiusun, Recexamined by Me, Rowtxsox—L know L could get a stoat insured from Kuchiuotza a for per cent, you hud occasion to recover other policies from the Union Society Q—Had you to wait thirty days in these Mr. Ronrsos then referred his Lordship to the following authorities in support of his case. Arnold, vol. 1, p. 429, 430-38; the eaves of Foley v, United Fire and Marine Society, and Barber v. Fleming, quoted in opening address; Lowndes' " Marine Lusurance" pp. 9-23, quoting the ease of Porte jand the type Friday, 14th September.

The case was resumed this afternoon at 2 o'clock.

Mr. Hexsuer S. Monnts asked his Lordship's permission to make a statement in connection with the case before the Court yesterday; and 'His Lotosum having having given him permission, Mr, Moxnis said—TI have been informed on very good authority,—aud probably your Lordship's notes will' show whether it is correct or othervsise,—that made by the learned gentle 6 on behalf of the defendants in cross-examining Mr. John Morris, one of the plaintiffs in the case of the America, asking him whether there were not other parties besides him, or the firm he represented, interested in the transactions involved in this case. Mr, Morris took exception to the question, I understand, as being irre T was not in Court when he answered the first question, That wae followed by the enquiry as to whether Herbert S, Morris was aut interested party. That statement I should scarcely have taken the trouble to come here to contradict, had it not been a scandalous and improper remark to have made in open Court,

0 Lorpsurr—It was a question, Mr.

Mr, Monris—It is quite devoid of any foundation or the slightest tittle of truth,—in fact it isa lie, {have therefore come' to ask your Lordship kindly to permit mo to ask an explanation as to why that statement was wade, where the information was derived from, who the parties are, and for such a satisfactory apology for making such a ata ment, which affects my character and a ing as occupying a public and prom position of trust in Shanghai, I don't with to take up the time of the Court, but I think your Lordship will agree with me that the enquiry, unless there was some reasonable foundation for it, was most unjustifiable and improper.

Mr, Warsewniout rose to reply.

His Loxvstuy (to Mr. Morris)—I was going to say you cannot insist on any reply at all from Mr, Wainwright, but Ihave no doubt Mr, Watsewxtont—I have already wri note to Me. Morris, and therefore it is not necessary to say ho was informed on good authority, He was informed on my authority that the question was asked.

His Lonvsurr—I understood he was here when the question was asked.

Mr. Mornis—I was not present when the question was asked. [heard my name mentioned just when I came into Court, but I did not hear what was said.

Mr. Waisewricut- turned round im. mediately after putting the question to the wituesr, and saw Mr. Morris behind me, but 1' did not look before putting the question because I did not think it was unterial whether he was here or not. Ae your Lordship is aware, no statement wa: made on the subject. 'I asked Mr. John Morris who the parties interested in the charter were. He hesitated about giving the names, with n view to avoid any unnecessary names being mentioned. I asked him when ther the only gentleman I was interested in had an interest. I did not ask the question Lasked it because my client had been formed by somebody who had said he had ome idea or had heard that Mr. Herbert Morris was interested. I did not mean to wake the slightest imputation even if the question was answered in the affirmative. I did not propose to east any imputation upon Mr. Morris for a moment, but, as your Lordship is aware, a witness' who" has an interest, however high his character and stsnding,—and I would be the last man to cast the slightest imputation upon Mr. Morris's character and standing,—is necessarily to a certain extent, unconsciously it may be, biased la his evidence. I do not mean to say that Mr. Morris was saying a syllable he did not believe was true. It turned out my information was incorrect. Well, there is an eud tot. T £ proas the question, and had no intention of making an imputation, Hut it was am doment in the case. and T bed something to go upon, and had to ack the question fo sift the evidence of Mr, Mor as 1 was bound to de with say witness what.

T did not go out of my way to do it been instructed that there was some. in duty bound to put the question. "I am sorry if I have been the means of hurting Mr. Morris's feelings, becanee that ie the last thing I should wish to do, His Lorpsmm—As your client informed you that he had been informed that Mr, Morris was interested in this, bound to put the questi it would be for Mr, Morris, bound to protect his client, however painful it may be to the witness.

Mr. Mornis expressed himeelf as being fied with Mr. Wainewright's statement as far as ho was concerned, but as to others who had adviced him the matter could not be tisfactorily explained there, but would hat be explained by correspondence, or some other steps would be taken, His Lonpsure—It cannot be pursued here, Mr, Mornts—{ did not wish it to go into the publio prints without come explanation, Mr. Warsewntonr—by client did not a mo to put the question. He gave the in formation, and I thought I was entitled to put the question, Hig Lorpsmir—When the question wi put, I thought the answer would be what it was, I did not conceive it possible that in the position you (Mr, Merrie) hold you would avo an interest in ventures of this kind, Mr, Roprxsoy—I think Mr, Morris may feel satisfied that n0 more satisfactory with drawal could be made withdrawal on the part of Mr. Wainewright in open Court to-day.

His Lorpsure then called attention to the report in yesterday's Daily News, as to his remark about both parties rolyi raph lip) that Mr, Wright had given his Lordship a note of oan whereas it ought to have been that he handed up to his Lordship the cases which Mr, Robinson was quoting; and upon which his Lordship remarked that both parties appeared to rely on the same cases, Mr, Warszwatonr, in opening the case for the defendants, said he did not for a moment contend that the plaintiffs were not entitled to insure freight which wan waiting for them at a port at which their ship was not, bub which they had contracted to get when their ship rived there. He did not contend they were not entitled to insure that freight, but the defendants said this was not a.case where that came into question, all they said was that the plaintiffs did not insure it with them, The sole point was this, under the policy which was before the Court did the plaintiffs secure themselves against the loss of some freight which they were to oam ona voyage from Kuchinotzu to Tientein subsequent to the one of which the defendants had notice? The defendants were asked, as would be proved in evidence, to insure freight on a vessel going on a rowd trip from Kuchinotzu to Tieatsin and back to Kauchinotzu, They were asked to insure freight to the value of Tls. 3,307.50, as the vestd was to make that on the voyage, but there was no indication given that there wae other freight waiting for her and which the plaintiffs wished to cover as well. The p sumption was that at the time the insurance was beepoken from the defendants, there w: no intention on the part of the plaintiffs to all, There wasa cogent reason for inferring that at any rate, What-rer the arrangements between the plaintiffs and the charterers were, the defendants were not parties to that, and they had no notice of the charter-party; they know nothing more than was contained in the application in accordance with which they were asked to insure a certain amount of freight per steamer America, on what the defendants called a round voyage from Kucbinotza to Tientsin and back to Kuchinotzu. There were a few proposi in law which bore upon the case and to which ho would draw attention, the first being that the policy must, according to the Act of liament 30th Vic., Chap. 23, Sec. 7, specify the particular risk and adventure upon which the insurance is effected, and in case of the particulars being omitted the policy became pull and void. "He contended on this poli that the subject matter of the iusuranc ought to be been defined, and the insurer as

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account