The Archive · 1883

The British Assessor

_. Tau proceedings in the Mixed Court on. Monday. morning have caused a great deal: of excitement among residents of all nationalities. The letters which appear in our columns to-day but faintly. interpret the indignation which hes been generally expressed at the conduct of the British As-sosser, and its result, in the surrender of Si-yung to the City authorities, Phe strong epithet which Mr. Drummond applied to the surrender of the Aetective was, we believe, universally approved. The explanation which we were enabled' to give subsequently of the circumstances under which "nately relieved the members of the Municipal Council of the odium which would have fallen on them had the man "oon given up by their instruction, or with their knowledge.

It made it, aloar that the British Assessor was -chiefly to blame in the matter. We fate not inclined to allow Mr. Penfold free of blame, but investiga. tion into his condact can stand over for the present, What. we have now to do la to point out the di ger to the community of the tention la "office of the present British Assessor. Ttisa painful task to have to write ofan' 'English official as we now feel ovirselves compelled to write of Mr. Scott; but our daty to the publi overrides every: other consideration. Phot it la time for us to discharge that @aty' "will be' shown by the briefest possible history of ocoarrences hero during the Inst three weeks, in which Mr. Scott ling borne a part.

ho Maloo riots, springing from the _abtempted change in the market place, "resulted -in one. of the most violent of the rioters being brought up for trial "before Chen the magistrate, Mr. Scott ing a Assessor. The man's guilt was 80 completely proved that Chen sou tenced him to receive a hundred blows with the bamboo, Mr, Scott interfered, arid persuaded the magistrate to allow "the prisoner to go free, on the farcical condition being complied with that he,

"appear. when called on. Soott's afreet romely, should give 8 separiy to demeanour on that haden was euch as to'create a feeling of astonishment and indignation among residents. He, sitting as the adviser of o Chinese magistrate, virtually told the Chinese that: they might set at defiance any -rogulations or laws which the Man "pality "of Shanghai should consider necessary. to the good government of the Settlement. A. moro.deadly blow gould not have been struck by an official in his position at our institutions. "But'on Monday last there appeared at "the Mixed Court Si-yung, ove of the 'Obineserdetectives, who bad been requested'to attend the inquest on the hody,.of, " Chinese rowdy-and rioter "who died on' Saturdey. Si-yung. was charged by the friends of the deceased with having caused his death, and the inquest on the body was commenced on Sanday. On that day Oh6n was particularly anxious. to obtain possession of Si-yung, but failed to do so. On Monday Si-yang was taken to the Court by the Superintendent of Foreign Police. No one was present to accuse the man; indeed that would have been impossible, as the inquest was not-then finished; no written demand was made for him, or warrant produced for his arrest. Mr, Scott and Cheo held a conversation on the detective's case, and the former told the Superintendent of Police that the man was to besant into the city. We meroly state what took place, and refrain from all comment on the proceedings of the Superintendent of Police, who may have considered himself justified in surrendering Si-yung on the verbal authority of the British Assessor. Bat as regards that official we do not see that any excuse can be offered for the part ho took, So far as he knew officially, no charge had been brought against the detective. No one appeared in Court to demand his being handed over to the Chinese authorities. Cheo wanted hi into the city, where doubtless other officials and the lawless symp: with the dead rowdy also wanted him. Bat Mr, Scott must have heard enough about the case to have made a prudent man, one suited to the position he held, cautious, to say the least. Unfortunately Mr, Scott acted with as complete an absence of discretion as he had shown in the case of the Maloo rioters, The generous indignation at his conduct which was everywhere displayed as soon as it was known, showed how deeply burt and humiliated the com. munity felt, But we submit that things are too serious, and the outlook has been made too grave by Mr. Scott's conduct, for the affair to be allowed to pass with no more result than blaming him. We take the liberty of suggesting to the British Consal whether another occupants of the position of Assessor in the Mixed Court cannot be provided. In the meantime the strongest pos representations should be made to the British Charge d'Affaires at Peking of the dissatisfaction which the retention of Mr, Scott in office at this port will give to all the Queon'a subjects. Wo should think that if this were done a message from Peking would relievo Mr. Haghes of whatever responsibility might attach to his suspension of Mr. Scott.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account