A LARGE number of documents concerning the present famine in North-China have been laid before the public in the last few days, but it is still difficult to arrive at a certain conclusion as to its extent and severity. There is ne question whatever as to the distress in Manchuria. The letter recently published from the Rev. J. Webster of the Scots mission is decisive as to that part of Chixa, and it is gratifying to know that Mr. Webster is already rich in the assurance of vastly more than the $100 or $200 for which he modestly asked, and we can only hope that he has fellow-labourers who will assist him in distributing the conparetively large sums that have already been announced to him by telegraph. Dr. Nevius is the chief authority for the existence of wide-spread distress in Shantung, and he also has received important contributions. The suffering portion of Shantung is comparatively manageable, and there are willing hands at work in it; but even here, great as is the want, it is hard to believe that the people are actually dying of starvation, when we find Mr, Bergen writing—as will be seen in his letter in another columm—that on the 14th of January the missionaries had determined to postpone relief until after the present holidays. It is impossible to believe that Mr. Bergen and his colleagues would delay the distribution of funds in their possession for some three weeks, if the intended objects of their charity were actually dying of starvation; and therefore, moving as Mr, Bergen's letter it, it is on the whole somewhat reassure ing; and it is very necessary in a case similar calamities, to which China is so like this, particularly in view of future
constantly liable, that there should be no exaggeration of the actual facts. Charity isa very sensitive plant; and if it were once thought that more had been made of the present distress than the facts warrant, not only would the sources of the present flow shrink up at once, but it would be so much harder to reopen them when the next appeal is made, At the meeting of the North China Famine Relief Committee held in Shanghai on the 28th of January, Mr. Muirhead is reported to have stated "that the present famine was already greater and more widespread than the famine known as the 'Great Famine' of ten years" ago." Unfortunately we have no record of the discussion that no doubt followed this statement, for it seems to us to be hardly borne out by the particulars that have so far been made public. In fact, as it stands it requires elucidation. We do not know whether Mr, Muirhead referred to the extent of country implicated, the number of sufferers, or the want of relief. We should state at once that Chinamen; who ought to know the facts, confirm Mr. Muirhead's averment; in fact, they assert that there has been no such famine in China as this since the tenth year of the Emperor Hsien Feng, 1861; but in precise knowledge of such matters Chinamen are lamentably deficient, and their statements are always of the most general character. In the remarks that follow we are putting aside Shantung and Manchuria, as to which there is no question; it is to the provinces of Honan, Anhui and Kiangsu, which were originally the special object of Mr. Drummond's Committee, to which we are referring, As to Honan, our chief sources of information are the Roman Catholic missionaries, and we may take it as certain that there is great distress in that province, and as it is less access sible from the relieving centres, it may be considered certain that help is much wanted there. As to Anhui it is more difficult to arrive at a ce: tain conclusion. Mr. Coulthard's letter, which we publish this morning, if we accept his conclu i sions as final, disproves much that we have been told of the suffering in that province. Within a circle of seventy miles round Wuhu, which apparently includes the north as well as the south bank of the Yangtze, there is no destitution, there is even an enormous supera~ abundance of grain for export, and Mr. Coulthard argues that "the provincial authorities would not permit a large export of grain were the province ina state of famine." He gives some particulars of the steps taken to relieve distress where it exists, and he adds that there is no increase in the number of beggars in the town of Wuhw itself, nor any invasion by poverty-stricken people from the country. It is too probable that there is more destitution in the north-em parts of Anhui than Mr. Coulthard recognises; but at any rate in this part of the valley of the Yangtze there is no overpowering distress, and on the map which accompanies Mr. Coulthard's report, he marks districts on the north auk of the river as being among those from which the large supplies of rice that are now being shipped away to Canton are derived. As to Kiangsu, we know from Mr. Mansfield's Jate report that the southern portion of this province is in great distress; but it is a remarkable thing that he tells us that the gentry of Chinkiang, having made a first distribution of relief, which would not stifice the recipients for more than about ten days, have put off the next distribution until March, and it is hard to believe that they would thus postpone their charity, if its objects were actually starving. As regards northern Kiangsu, we have the testimony of the Acting Director General of Grain Transport—as we pointed out afew days ago—that " the crops have afforded to the formers a bounteous harvest and it is to be noted that in Chinkiang, as well asin Wuhu, the market price of rice is by no means excessively high, and there is no interference with the export.
In a word, we cannot see that the facts so far published bear out Mr, Muirhead's statement. The great Shansi famine of 1878 was increased by the impossibility of getting supplies into the country. The country affected this year is much better situated in this respect. There is abundance of food in places adjacent to the distri there are, for China, fac' 4 munication. Money to buy food, and fuel, are much wanted, and every penny that is subscribed here or in London is wanted and can be well laid out, in addition to the measures that the government has taken so much more liberally this year than in 1878. All the money that foreigners can subscribe is wanted in-Honan, Shantung, Kiangsu and Manchuria, and will be most valuable. Of still greater value would it be if some one could persuade the central or local authorities to employ the sufferers on public works. The writer of " Chinese Characteristics" has shown re-how much there the money that the missionaries distribute—and we may well pause to point out how well and impartially Mr, Hughes has divided the sum entrusted to him by the Hongkong goverument—will only give temiporary relief. The employment of the starving in public works would obviate the deworalisation that pure charity, however necessary, must produce, and would be of permanent benefit to the country; and the next time the Yellow River breaks out, and by its floods, with droughts in the country near, threatens to cause a famine, what. a cause of rejoice ing it would be if that famine could be easily relieved by the existence of gout roads and waterways made by the sul forers in the famine of 1888-89.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.