The Archive · 1889

The Protection of Catholic Missionaries in China

According to a telegram received by the Paris Temps from Rome, dated the 29th of November last, the Apostolic Delegate to China, whoever he may be, will be charged with mission from the Holy See to the Emperor of China, dealing with the position of Catholic Missionaries in the Empire, and the subject of diplomatic relations between China and the Vatican.

On the other side, the London Daily News to hand by the same mail, states that the Holy See had not yet taken any action relative to the Convention between Italy and China for the protection of the Italian Missionaries and the ratification of their passports, The Vatican, the correspondent of the Daily News says, intends to wait for the steps which may be taken by France, who is most directly interested in this convention, with a view to forwarding her interests in China. Should France do nothing in obtaining any concession, the Holy See will consider itself to be released from its engagements with France, and will open negotiations for sending an Apostolic Delegate to China, who would undertake the refection by diplomatic means of the Under these circumstances, and with a view tu the negotiations, perhaps going on at the present moment, between the parties interested in the question, but certainly to be opened before long, it may be worth our while and that of our readers to look a little closer into the claim of the French Government to the exclusive protection of Catholic Missionaries in China.

No arrangement exists between France and China as to giving the former power any right of protection over Missionaries belonging to any other nationality than her own, and even if such an arrangement did exist, it would be utterly valueless, as no two powers have the right, by an arrangement arrived at between them, to meddle with the sovereign rights every independent power holds over its own subjects or citizens. The exercise of protection over a nation's own subjects is a right of sovereignty belonging to, every power, and which cannot be lessened or done away with by understandings between third parties.

The French Government, as well as that of China, will do well to keep in mind this unassailable rule of international law. The treaties and conventions concluded between France and China oon-tain nothing that would give even a shadow of right to the French pretensions of ex-elusive protection over all Catholic Missionaries in the Empire.

Article XVIII of the French Treaty of 1858 states:—Efficacious protection will be granted to Missionaries travelling into the interior of the country furnished with the regular passports mentioned in Article VIII, and, according to this article,' Frenchmen desirous to proceed to towns in the interior, or to ports to which foreign ships are not admitted, can do so safely under condition that they hold passports written in French and Chinese, and legally issued (légalement délivrés) by French Consular and diplomatic agents in China, and vised by the Chinese authorities The French agents in China will deliver passports to their countrymen (4 lews nationanz) only for those places not held by the rebels at the time the passport is asked for.

There can be no doubt that these Treaty stipulations admit only of the issue of passports by the French authorities to Frenchmen, and the French authorities themselvessare so well aware of this that even in their passports issued to Missionaries belonging to other than the French nationality, they designate the holders thereof illegally, as belonging to their own—the French—nationality.

"T, Minister of the French Republic, issue this passport to the Catholic Mi sionary..... " belonging tomy own country, in pursuance of the treaties concluded between France and China at Tientsin and Peking in 1858 and 1860, and the Articles VIII and VI thereof. As it is well known to me that M. is a renowned scholar of my country." toe es Thus reads the translation of the Chinese text of the passports issued by the French Legation to Catholic Missionaries, and the French text of it is still more explicit, as it refers but to Article VII{ of the French Treaty of 1858, which, as has been shown in the ing, mentions only passports issued to Frenchmen.

If thus Articles VIII and XIII of the French Treaty of 1858 are not only silent on the exclusive right of protection over Catholic Missionaries, but on the contrary are adverse to any such claim, Article VI of the Treaty of 1860 is still more unfavourable to the demand put forward by France.

The French text of this Article only contains the stipulation that the ground and buildings taken from the Christians during the past persecutions should ba restored to the former owners through the intervention of the French Government. to whom the Chinese Government would hand them over; the Chinese text of the same Article contained two more stipulations, the one giving the right to props ate, preach, and practise the Cathofic religion to all people in all parts of China, the other permitting French Missionaries to rent and purchase land in all the provinces of the Empire, and to erect buildings thereon at their pleasure, The difference between the French and the Chinese text of this Article, of the cause of which a not very savoury story is told, gave rise to further negotiations, the Chinese Government objecting with good reason to be bound by the Chinese text, as surreptitiously obtained. Itwas only in 1865 that these negotiations came to a result, the so-called Berthemy Convention, after the French Minister who concluded it, and in the note addressed by the Tsunglt Yamen to the French Legation on the 20th February of that year, it was stated that if in future French' Missionaries were to go into the interior in order to buy ground and buildings, the documents of transfer would have to be made out in the name of the church community, and that neither

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account