Dowpau1 for the plaintiffs.
Mr. R. E. Waisewniout for the defendants.
(The following evidence had to be omitted from our report of last wesk owing to pressure on our space).
Mr. Kisusumt, re-examined by Mr. Dowpats, explained how it was that he said he -would not advise anyone to give than Tis, 60,000 for the dock in its state, and that when in order he lown its' value at Tls. 110,000, to Tis, 115,000. If the tenant went to him and asked him what was the least sum for which he could put the dock in good order he would have put it down at Tls. 19,000, but even then he would not guarantee that the landlord would hold the tenant clear. When he mentioned Ts. 50,000 he had in his mind the fact that the purchaser would have to allow a considerable margin for repairs to put the dock in good order. Inthe specifications which the landlords got from Messrs. Morrison & Gratton, he should say that there were certain things which would render the dock better, and of a more permanent nature than it was before, and he should further say that if the landlords got all the things specified done, they should wake a reasonable allowance to the tenants. Front the landlord's point of view there was no redundant work except the chase piles, and on the bulkhead—which was a superior bulkhead to that which existed befure—and possibly there was some re-dun dant work with regard to the bunding, and for this he considered the landlords should bear some of the expense. He did not consider the long piles redundant work for if they were not put in there would be considerable expense fur renewing the piles at the entrance.
His Lorpsuir—And the landlords get a better dock Witness—Very much a better dock, practically a very much better dock.—He considered that a portion of the expense for this should be borne by the landlords and part by the tenants.
By Mr. Dowpatt—I would say to a purchaser—if advising him about. the dock fore repairs were commenced—that he jonid leave a sufficient margin to secure himself against all risks, else, he might find that he had bought the dock at a price altogether beyond its value.
Me J. F. Maxsmare was sworn, and examined by Mr. Wilkinson, as follows Tau an a surveyor to Her Majesty's Ottice of Works and in charge of the Govern-and Siam. ¢ entered Her Majesty's ment buildings in China, Corea, Japan
service in 1854 as a member of the ci branch of the Royal Engineers. I was in that branch 22 years, and for the last Ldyears have been in H.M.'s Office of Works. I had charge of works in my former capacity in connection with barracks and fortifications. Before that I served with a firm of contract tors and had a practical instruction, Taise studied under a civil engineer, and under an architect and surveyor. I visited the Pootung Dock in Dee., 1888, and Jan. this year. Repairs had been commenced and had been going on for four months as far ax Tean say. I visited the dock twice. From what Isaw then I could judge what had been the state of the dock before I saw it. Te was in a state of disrepair generally, more especially the portion at the entrance, which includes the wharves and bunding, and the dock head. The planking of the staging—the bunding—was worst. I should say that this state of things had been brought about by want of proper repair and by neglect. There was no sign whatever of bursting, or of any accident having happened. The part that I have mentioned was in very great disrepair,—the bunding and wharves. The disrepair of the dockhead was not go great as in the case of the wharves and Goody; that of the entrance was considerable. The inside was also in disrepair, but not so much so as the outside. I should say that the disrepair came about gradually. I do not claim to have any special knowledge of docks, but from what I know I would say that such a dock would require constant repair. It would be subject to leaks at jarly time through the decay of timber, and the neglect of preservative precautions. If those leaks were not attended to they would increase rapidly.
Cross-examined by Mr. Warxewarcun—The piles of the entrance, right and left, on the inside of the entrance, were decayed in many instances, and the planking was also decayed. I examined the piles. A portion of the planking was removed that I could see the piles down for a considerable distance. I could only form a judgment from what decay I saw outside.
did not probe the piles witha gimlet. 1fT was repairing the dock, they were in such estate that I would have replaced them, The new chase piles were in when I was there. _A portion of the sheeting which was
say third of it. This was the sheeting exposed vas partially decayed; T should of the lower pier. In my opinion this required rene I am not sure of the date of my visits. Neither visit was later than the end of January. I should think that my second visit was not later than the tenth of January. I did not py much attention to the struts. The loot of the entrance outside the caisson,
floor on the inner side of the chases was in hen T saw it was partly stripped. The moderately good condition. A portion of the planking was there. I noticed some concrete there. I did not examine it minutely, I stopped and looked at it, and it seemed to me to be in fairly good condition. I saw no traces of of water through the floor inside the caisson chase, There was decay in the inner portion of
decay in the outer portion to a moderato the flooring." There were also signa of extent. The flooring outside the caisson chase could probably not be repaired without a cofferdam. I should think I could not repair the flooring outside without a cofferdam. I think the state of the floor outside could be ascertained without a cofferdam by boring. 'The inside flooring could be repaired' without a cofferdam, The flooring inside appeared to me to be seriously out of repair I chauid say thivel of it was in bad repair. I would not have been able to tell that there were springs of water coming up inside in the time I devoted to the inspection. I could not say that there had not been a spring of water coming up. Teall a' bursting in" as applied to a dock, some sudden rushing in of water. Idont think Ihave ever heard the term "bursting" applied to a duck, In my opinion a giving away of the revetment of the dock would be a bureting." I would call the sliding down of the mud at the altars, from the effect of water, a "bursting." To cause a sudden bursting, a spring, I should say, would commence suddenly. Such a thing would not come suddenly, there must be notice of its approach. If'the spring came up through the flooring from under the bulkhead, I would probably put in a cofferdam to examine it. I would call somethin, very sud i a bursting, The "bursting" of a water pipe might be only through a very small aperture. I would apply the term "accident" at the entrance to the sudden giving way of the timbers, or the snapping of a bolt, 'The bunding and wharves on the two sides of the dock entrance were in' an equally bad state. The piles were out of position, they had slipped, the planking was rotten in many instances, the cross timbers were decayed, the tie rods were bent, and the retaining piles were also rotten. I only tested the retaining piles with my eye; the rottenness here being very apparent. Quite half of the piles, generally, were The greater part of the retaining piles were exposed. The tie rods may have been bent by heavy loads having been carried over them; they being only two or three feet below the surface. Many of them were bent. If the foot of the piles slipped out into the river, the tie rod might have been bent, but I don't think that was the cause. The buckling of the reds may have bent them. I cannot, think "f any other cause. I attach very great importance to the retaining piles in such a structure. If the retaining piles gave way, and the front piles were not far enough in the mud, the front of the bunding
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.