Shanghai, 6th August, 1886, Before Gronax Jasttxsox, Eeq., Acting Assistant Judge.
THE "ALBANIA" CASE, The hearing of the claim of $63.40 for we yon, brought against the Captain of the Albania by Alex, Mack, A.B. seaman, was resumed.
ALEXANDER Mack, the plaintiff, was recalled. Ho said he had been on board the Albania five months and three days, and his claim was at the rate of 810 4 month. That was the rate of pay ruling in New York when he left, and he swore that the shipping master had told him he wan to yet $16, Capt, BuowNeLL—I think, your Ho nur, Hf you will allow me, I can prove that that war not the rate of woges in New York at that time.
His Hoxoor—I will hear you present:
The Plaintiff, further questioned by his Honour, anid the Articles were not read to him, but he supposed h ipped for two years, No one told him so; but that was the usual time for which men were shipped in New York.
His Honour—You see, Captain, the section of the Merchant Shipping Act with reference to shipping substitutes—Sectiv 150—is this: "The Master shall, before the ship puts to coa if practicable, and if not as soon after as possible, cause the agreement to be read over and explained to the seamen, and the seamen shall thereupon sign the same in the presence of a witness." That it is incumbent upon you to do, Defendant—Your Honour, I think I have proved clearly that the Articles wore read to these men His Hoxova—No, Defendant—The steward has sworn that it was done in his presence.
His Honovr—I am not satisfied that they were rend to this man, and even if over they were certainly not way this section requires. it was in a desultory way, without seeing that the men under-tood them. The whole gist of the matter that they were shipped for three mouth at aabilling a mouth and the rest of the voyage for £2 58; whorens I ace that the shipped in Hamburg have £2 16s, for the most part, and I am informed that the average wages from London are about £2108. Do you menu to say you can get men to ship in New York with their eyes open for lees than in London or Hamburg Defendunt—I don't know. This is just the came as in other ships that have currie from New York.
His Hoxoux—It convinces me that there 8 fraud all along. Iam bound to you have triied to ave that the were properly read over and ex-
Defendant—I have given my evidence, and the steward's, that the Articles were rend to him, His Hoxous—I have given full weight to that, and I do not find that you had them road over and explained.
Defendant—I have never hoard them explained any differoutly—with the exception of the wages, His Roxovs—Th you yourself admit that the wages were never read to them, Defendant—I think the Articles clu not terminate in Shanghai, His Hoxour—I do vt say the Articles terminate in Shanghi 3 but you have failed to make any hi gage ment with this man. of understand it man's word for every-g—that he is telling the truth and all the rear lies.
His Hoxouk—You mac not keep interrupting me, and you need not arne with mo when I am telling you the couolujon to which I have arrived. Say what you want to say now, and fondant polo, ud said—I up in Articles drawn up to terminate in a foreign port; and if there is any dispute to settle about the wages think the termination of the voyage is the time todo it. I shall certainly object to pay any wages he Hix Hoxovx—Ido wot aay ti proper agreem. Tt was not read. over and properly explained to him, Defoudant—It was road over, that is the only way L know of explaining it, His Hosour—Then you have to learn how to do it differently.
Defendant - Ihave been fifteen years a shipmaster, and I have ever had a case brought against me by a sailor before, I know nothing about the agreement betw n and the shipping master and boarding master.
His Hoxovr—That is where you are wrong. You employ him, and you are bound by what he has done.
Defendant—The sailors employ him too to get them shi His Hoxovur—No; he is your agent, not th joxour—No, you are quite wrong.
Defendant—They pay him money to get them " chance, end ho is their agent as well ae mine.
His Hoxovr—No, he your 'Mind you, Lam speaking only' with reg to this man, who is a substitute—not the meu shipped before the Consul.
Defendant—Hi of wages is just the same, He is a substitute for another mau, with the of way If he goto lower rate there might be sume fraud on my part.
His Hoxovr—Do you mean to tell me that the ordinary rate of wages in New York is £2 5s. 2 Defendant—That is what I was told. Th ver naked me the rate.
is Honour—What is the rate in London Defendant—I don't know. It varies considerably—£2 10s, and £2 15s, L have paid £2104, His Hosour—Aud yot you think you can get them for £2 ds, in New York.
Defendant—I get them j Just xt this time wa very Th lon, voyage at £2 5a, told me they were loaving for His Honovr—I am informed that in ships which have left New Yurk since you, the wages have been S14, Defendant—I can call Captains who left about the same time that I did.
His Honoun—I do not think it is material. 1 hold u i have failed to comply with the require ments of Section 150; therefore you have no valid agreement with him; therefore you extinct compel him to go on doing work therefore he is entitled to his dis-and you are bound to pay him at the rate of $16 without any deduction, Defendant—Without any deduction His Hoxour—Yes, [tin a deliberate to evade a law which isin force in and America, Defendant—Well, I object to pay it.
Mie Hoxour—Oh! Lhen is will be levied on you.
Defendant—Well, I shall have to and it in to the Board of Trade and have an i IE pay it, it will be under protest.
His Honour—I am informed that it will be referred to the Board of rade, It is ould His Honoun—What fondant—I can bring Captains to give evidence as to the rate of wager His Honour—It is imu: jor a verbal ay) with your agent, Defendaut—And that go against the His Hoxoux—And that over-rides the Articles. hold that distinctly, His Honour then informed the plaintiff that he would got hisdiecharge, and would get his salary at $16 8 month, with no deduction for advance.
Defendant—I refuse to pay it, Sir.
Oth August, Before Geonae TAMrEsox, Uaq., Acting Assistant Judge.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.