The China Camera Club is to be congratulated upon its first appearance before the public. Its exhibition is not a very large One, it is trae, and its members have evidently had more regard to quality than to quantity, which is only as it should be, and the result is alike a source of congratulation to the artists of the camera, and of genuine pleasure to the spectators. It is indeed, in a certain sense, a relief to turn from the Art Society's Exhibition to the section devoted to the work of the much abused sister art, for photography in these days is really an art, and no longer a mere mechanical and scientific process. The most approved of, if not the latest developments the art have reached Shanghai, where a: shown by the exhibition, there are several masters of the beautiful bromide process. The bromide seems to be the favourite, and it is in that mode that the best results are obtained. Indeed the samples of that style shown are of the highest excellence, and the pictures of such claver amateurs Dr. W. J. Milles, Dr. D. Reid, there. W. B. Bonnell and one or two others, would bear favourable comparison with any similar work in Europe or America, There are some excellent exhibits in the same process also show by a Chinaman, Chan Chin-tung, one of Li Hung-chang and his family being especially good. It is very hard in the sixty odd exhibits to say which is the best; but we venture to think one result is certain to follow the exhibition in Shanghai, and that is the entire substitution of the bromide process for the old-fashioned silver printing for out-door photography at least. The softness and exquisite tone of the former process, its ter power it reproducing light and shade, its rich colour and delicate tints, are all singw apparent in many of the exhibits, notably in the delightful little bits of scenery picked up round Shanghai, Hangchow, the Tahu Lake, Chefooand the thousand and one places, in which the adventurous and enterprising camera man sets up his tripod stand. There are, we regret rose, no examples of the popular detective camera pictures shown, nor are there any magic lantern slides, a most interesting and grateful branch of the pursuit, on view. Mr. Olsen sends some fine examples of opal printing and a couple of excellent large bromide portraits. His scraps of scenery round about Shanghai are almost as good as anything in the show. Dr. Milles' six little gems, No. 41, are simple exquisite the printing is perfect and the plates without the slightest flaw. Dr, has a wonderful eye for picking up the choicest bits from places we walk through every day without being struck by any artistic beauty. It only needs a camera, however, to develop the latent beauties in many a place that to the ordinary eye is anything a fit subject for a picture. Dr. Reid's Nos. 8, 9, 13 amongst his open air pictures and No. 5, Altar of the Chapel in the Institution of St. Joseph, amongst his interiors, are bits ever to be reserved. The Rev. W. 'B. Bonnell is a prodigious worker; ver, or bromide, portrait or landscape, is all the same to hin. In each he turns out excellent work. His view of Chefoo Hills No. 39, and his Shanghai life studies No. 36, are very good. Mr. R. E. C. Fittock has sent a Very interesting, if small collec+ tion, including a picture of the first locomo+ tive engine built in China, named the "Rocket" with its celestial stokers and river; he also sends a capital group, con: sisting of the Viceroy Li and the native officials of the China Railway, well large size, on bromide paper; but the latter seems to have been a little coarse grained obtained an excellent picture. Dr. Bu for portrait work, though altogether he has a couple of interiors, views of the Cathedral, which are not given in the cata+ logue. Mr. J. Moncarini has an intereest-ing sories of ten silver prints, some of which
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.