Unpovsrepty this is an age in which there is a mania for making reports. Writing has become such a common accomplishment, and paper and ink are so cheap, that when people have done their work now, they will not have done with it, until they have got somebody to draw up a report on it. It is possible that there exists somewhere a sort of idle people who find a congenial occupation in reading these reports when they have been written, and they no doubt feel themselves to some extent sharers in the work when they have read them. To active-minded people reading such reports is much more toilsome than the work itself. Here is my Lord Mayor of London anxious now to have a report on the China Famine, with an "account of the causes, extent effects" thereof, "and of the operations of the Relief Committees in China." The cynical might suggest that the Lord Mayor is anxious in his own mind for a fuller justification of his appeal to the British people, for he cannot really want a fresh report on the top of all the material that has been sent home already, and it is perfectly certain that a busy man as he is will not read it when it has been compiled by the Rev. F. Storrs Turner, to whom it has been assigned. This gentleman is one of the leaders of the anti-opium fanaticism, and the inaccuracies and exaggerations that characterise the anti-opium organ, The Friend of China, are repeated in the circular which he has sent out, asking for information. Much of the circular is actual nonsense and one may safely say, without any fear of being accused of vanity, that in the file of the North-China Herald for the past twelve months will be found all the information he asks for; at such length, too, that we have sometimes made our readers grumble; therefore we are not vain about it. Of course, the circular is neatly cut up under appropriate headings; Mr. Turner has not enough respect, for the intelligence or common-sense of his correspondents to simply ask them to send all the information they can. His first inspiration The occurrence of drought and inundation in continuous areas (:) in the same season appears to have been an unusual event. Is it unprecedented? Can you explain the physical antecedents of these phe-nomina?" Is it ible that Mr. Turner did not see when he had written this that it was absolute nonsense? he does not know by this time that the drought was a local phenomenon, and the inundation was caused by a breach in the embankment of the Yellow River, and has nothing whatever to do with local climatic conditions, he has not the elementary knowledge' necessary to enable him to draw up a report at all. And what in the name of common sense does he mean by "contiguous areas"? Would he think it unprecedented to hear that there had been heavy rains in France, and a want of rain in Spain What does he mean by the physical antecedents of these phenomena There explain the causes of droughts: and are meteorologists in England who can
the physical cause of the inundation was the weakness of the embankment at Cheng-chou. It does not need any profound scientific knowledge to see that a river which, like the Po, has raised its bed above the level of the surrounding country, will inundate that country if the embankments are not kept up. The next sentence shews the per-factory mood in which Mr. Turner has gone to his task. He says:—The great floods occurred in August, but the
Treaty Ports until December. How is news appears not to have reached the this slow transmission of the intelli-ce explained?" It will not give Hillier much trouble to answer this: he can send Mr. ta copy of the North-China Herald for the 2nd of November, 1887, in which he will find the first mention on the floods, so that instead of the transmission of the intelligence being "slow," the flood was known here months before, according to Mr. Turner, it occurred. Having just asked if the state of things on which he is enquiring is unprecedented, he next wants to know if "in regions so liable to these calamities there is no system of storing grain in good years to anent the necessities of bud seasons Why, it has been shown over and over again that there was no famine, as we understand the term; there was great destitution, from the abject poverty in which the people always live, but there was always grain in the country; the want was of money to buy grain. There is a system of granaries in China, as Mr. "Turner ought to know; but its utility depends so entirely on the honesty of the officials that it cannot be relied on. As to the relief afforded by the government and by the private charity of the Chinese, all the available information on these heads has appeared in our columns from time to time in the extracts from the Peking Gazette and otherwise; and the same may be said as to the extent and effects of the famine. Mr. Turner's request under heading V is only too modest, as our readers may judge by referring to the document itself reproduced in another column; it is of so little practical value that we had not intended to reprint it, but it is perhaps only fair to Mr. Turner that our comments should be accompanied by the document itself. Does he really imagine that any one, Chinese or foreigner, wissiouary or layman, can state' the number of lives saved Does he imagine that the distributors are idle men who can now devote weeks to a fresh perainpulation of the famine districts, and a series of inquiries among the people, "Would you have died but for our relief?", etc., ete.? And the whole is wound up by the equally modest. suggestion that Mr, Turner would like to receive "all information... ofall that has been done by foreigners for the relief of the famine." Of books on China in the last fifty years there has been no end, but they have not dispelled the invincible ignorance of people at home when we find a man like Mr. Storrs Turner, who is supposed to have special knowledge of the country, writing as ift were country in which bureaux ofstatis" tics are as thickly scattered as they are in the West. No doubt he imagines that the People to whom his circular is sent will find registers in every village in which every death is recorded with its causes, The most irritating thing is that if any one is persuaded to take trouble to compile as much of this information as he can, no one will ever read the report which is to be based on it; and we only wonder that a practical business man like my Lord Mayor of London should have consented to father such a futile document as that we have just criticised.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.