The Archive · 1887

Chinese Property Owners in Shanghai

Tire case decided in the Supreme Court on Wednesday was one with more interest for the public than would appear at first. In the first place it served to draw attention to a custom which has been growing of recent years, of transferring the land in the Settlement to Chinese, who under the treaty are precluded from holding such lands in their own name, and who to essay the disability have them registered in the name of a foreigner who no doubt for his protection receives a substantial consideration in one shape or another. In the second it may serve as a warning to intending litigants, and forcibly calls to mind the fable of the cats and the cheese. In the words of Acting Assistant Judge Jamieson, "It was perfectly ridiculous to be ting time over a trumpery case that could have very easily disposed of in one day." No doubt it could, and perhaps in less. No Court at home could have spared the time to listen to such a mass of utterly irrelevant evidence as was produced in this wretched little squabble over a few feet of laud; and a less good-natured judge than Mr, Jamieson would, even in Shanghai, where such liberty and length of speech are allowed to lawyers, have obliged the issues to be confined toa narrower sphere. But while congratulating the learned counsel on both sides on the patience of the tribunal, we cannot help thinking that the client of one of them, at least, will not join with us in the compliment. The suit was ostensibly one for damages instituted by a Chinaman named Hung Chee-foo against Mr. C. W. Ure, who was merely the figurehead for another Chinaman, Chang Mei Sin, the real defendant, a shopkeeper in the Fokien Road. But it was really an attempt to make the latter purchase at an exorbit ant price some houses and a piece of land of which the plaintiff was in possession, and for which he could produce no proper title. The property seems to have been mortgaged half a dozen times to as many foreigners, and the title deed is now in the hands of Mr. H. S. Wilkinson.—Possibl; it may have been mortgaged as many times again upon the flimsy title which Mr. Hung produced in Court, as the plaintiff would have probably found to his cost if he had been foolish enough to buy the land. The issues were complicated and enshrouded by what was aptly called "ancient history" by the Judge, but the gist of the plaintiffs case was that Chang Mei Sin squeezed" him out of a foot or so of a passage leading to his houses in Fokien Road. But he failed to call the most important witnesses to prove this, namely the men engaged in the rebuilding of the place after the fire in 1875, but they were produced by the defendant and proved that the original foundations were exactly followed. Another point which very properly weighed with the Court, was the long sustained attempt to mislead it as to the title, but this was, fortunately for the interests of justice, and for the defendant, discovered. by his Lordship, who stated his mind pretty freely upon the point. During the hearing of the case a Chinese witness was examined as to the title deed of the original property of which he produced one half, naively adding that he thought that half of the title should when the half of the property was sold

accompany each portion. Reverting to the ownership of land in Shanghai, we may state that we have been informed, that more than two-thirds of the land in the foreign Settlement has now passed into the hands of the Chinese, although it was given by the treaty solely for the benefit of and occupation by foreigners. This being so, and by far the larger part of the remaining third being the property of absentees, who do here what their class has done in Ireland, take everything and do nothing for the place, residents who have to bear the heat and burden of very wnremmunerative days should bear this in mind when any adjustment of taxation is necessary.

The whole question of the ownership of Jand in the settlements ought to be carefully considered. The original intention of Captain Balfour, when he first spans Shanghai, was that the Chinese should sell to foreigners such land as was actually required for the settlers to ea on their trade. There was no prohib tion against re-selling the laud once acquired by foreigners to Chinese, because it was never thought that foreigners would take up more Jand than they actually wanted to use. There was a prohibition against building houses for Chinese on foreign acquires land, but when speculators saw what a lucrative business this would be, they put such pressure on Consul Medhurst, that, not being by any means a man, he gave way, and the prohi ion has never been enforced. 'I'he idea that Iand would become the subject of spectlation, and the means of investment, that it now is, never entered the heads of the founders of the Settlements, and accordingly 10 precautions, or very slight precautions, were taken against that issue of the powers given to foreigners to acquire land here, and the regulations under which land is now held by foreigners are quite unsuited to the present condition of affa demand a careful revision.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account