The Archive · 1883

Miscellaneous Articles

THE CHINESE MANIFESTO

Taz Document we publish elsewhere, headed The Chinese View of the Aunam Question,' is the formal utter. ance of those who represent the Government of Peking at the present juncture, and muy be accepted as embodying the standpoint taken up by His Excellency Li Hung.chang. It has been privately communicated, in addition, to representatives of friendly Powers; and it therefore forms a satisfactory basis for discussing the subject malter in all its bearings. Without, however, going into the merits of the dispute, the mere fact of the Chinese having appealed to the snffrages of the foreign public through the medium of foreign newspaper is in itself remarkable. It show inet move in a very desirable direction, and the terms of the Document are such as suggest, however distantly, a willingness to make for peace. But of this more hereafter. The writer of the Aappeal—for such we may call it—exorta-himself to prove tholong-standing suzerainty of China over Annam, and quotes freely from Chinese autho: in support of the olnim be advances. "The term of Tributary State applied to Yuob.uan is plainly written in the rooorde of the Government and promulgated in the History of Chinn, It is n8 oovspionons to all as the sou and the stars. Iv ie known to the Tenn Thousand States of the whole world." The Emperor las constantly interfered in' the internal affairs of of his power. "The payment of tri-bates and of respects continued ever afterwards, and accession to the Aunames Throne was alvwnys referred to the Great Euper: well and very sat goes, bat it is, we submit, a new prin. ciple in International Law that intorference in, or assistance rendered to, the affairs of another State renders that State a dependency of the inter. foring or assisting Power. It would be more to the point if, instend of to the archives of China, the writer had brought forward evid. ence from the Annamese side to prove that Annam recognised China as her suzerain, The only testimony that has beau forthcoming was that tendered by the Annamese Ambassadors to Admiral Dopré in 1874, in which was embodied an indignant deum! of all Ohinese claims to lordship over their country, an assurance that the irregular system of tribute, or presenta, rather, had only been instituted as the price of non-interference, and the deliberate assertion that, whatever might have been the acts or pretensions of China, Aunam had never done or said anything that could by any possibility be interpreted as an acknowledgment of their validity, Were further groand wanted for guarding ourselves from being led astray by the marked ability of the writer, we might Gud it inthe fact that certain important statements made with respect to the proposals and negociations of M, Bouré2 are so inaccurate as to lave compelled Unt gentleman to rectify, in a formal and public manner, the i tion liable to be produced by them. Itis only necessary tendd that the excuse of maltitudin. ous engagements at home, advo by China in explanation of her failure to protest against what she calla the rebellious act of the King in making a Treaty with France without her sauce tion, will scarcely carry much weight with foreign publicists.

Now there are certain points in the provisional propositions made by Bf. Bourés to the Chinese Government which onll for our attention, In one of his first interviews with Li Hang-chang, the Chinese statesman opened the conversation by demanding an explanation of the doings of the French in country over which China claimed the rights of suzerainty. M. Bourée At once stopped the discussion at that polt Tf you appeal to your alleged suzerainty," he said, " we immediately fall back upon our protectorate, You deny our protectorate, we deny your euzoraiuty; ta attempt negotiations on such a footing is to Innd us both inn dead-lock. Let us, for the moment, ignore both claims, and discuss the matter on its merits The result of as eminently successful ional agreement was even-dat between the two tors in which no recognition of Chinese suzerainty was accorded by France, while fall recognition of the Frouch protectorate was accorded by China, This fact is, of itself, of the very first importance, and must not be overlooked. Th ion sent by M. Bourée to his Government of the agreement he had suggested was favourably received; and bad not another Pharaoh arisen who knew not Joseph—who was, in fact, the exponent of other principles and other aims—it is highly probable that it would have been accepted by France. The author of the ' Chinese View ' has here shown considerable shrewd us As shareholders, and representatives of other shareholders, in the yet unprospected mines of Tonquin, the Cabi in which M. Challemel-Lacoar directs the foreign policy of France condemned the proposed agreement us unsatisfactory; and the entire orchestra of French journals blended their notes in a concert of denunciation of the Minister at Peking. To him was attributed, with that recklessness of assertion and extravagance of invective which too often characterises a section of the French press, a policy which be would have been the frst to condemn, and it was, we believe, solely through the instrumentality of friewls to whom he bad confided tle trae details of the affair that any light was thrown upon it. The last mail brings us a copy of the Temps, in which we read that, at a sitting of the Chatuber, the attention of the Comission was called to the project of. treaty made by M.- Bourés,.A member thereupon rose, and informed the Deputies that he had recei direct from BIN. Bourée, advices of a detailed and precise nature, which con. tradicted flatly those which had been published to his prejudiow in the Paris papers. It had been suid, for instance, that the Minister's proposals had i cluded an acknowledgment of Chinese seignory in Anunw, This was totally and radionlly false, the object of his proposals having been simply to give the Chinese Government satisfaction on a point which did not in the least degree injure the interests of France, China only protested against having any common frontier (frontidre mitoyenne) with a European Power, and she ind asked that a neutral zone should be established between Tonquin and hor own territory, This neutral zone was, to comprise the lawless hordes of the district, among whom neither the Chinese nor the Fronoh would ever have desired to go; an consideration of this concession, Chins would have acknowledged the Protectorate of France in Tonguiv, The Gil Blas next takes up the story, Lo questions put to bim by the Commis. sion, M. Challemel-Lacour explained that the propositions of M. Bourée, made under reserve for the consideration of his Government, lad for their object the establishment of a neutral zone between Tonquin and Chita, over which the latter country reserved to herself certain rights. China, on her promised to encourage the naviga-tiou of the Red River; stipulating only, by way of compensation, for the own ship of Lao Kui, for the collection of Customs duties, This town, be it observed, is situated in the very heart of the country sabjevt to the raids of the Black Flug pirates. Such were the conditions on which China consented to recognise the French Protectorate and we way remark in passing that the London Times supported the policy proposed, pointing out that he opening of the Red River to foreign commerce was all that was worth fighting for. Order, both municipal and civil, was to be maintained by France, as indicated by M. Chatlemel-Lacour; the financial and judicial administration, uow in the hands of the Annamese mandarins, was to be made over to the Touguinese, or to Annamese known to be friendly France. M, Challemel-Lnoour added that he was wot favourable to the re-establishment of the national dyunsty of Tonquin, in consequence.of the number of competitors.

The above. facts are sufficient to prove that at the date of last advices a less excited spirit was beginning. to show itself, and we bear from well-informed sources that the Journal dee Débats was, and probably still is, inclined to modify its policy with regard to the situation, Sivce thou,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account